You know that feeling when you bite into a perfectly cooked steak and suddenly understand what all the fuss is about? That is exactly what happens at Mountain Jacks Steakhouse in Lafayette.
This place has been serving up some of the best prime rib in Indiana for decades, and once you try it, you will understand why locals keep coming back. Forget the chain restaurants with their frozen sides and rushed service.
Mountain Jacks is the real deal, an old school steakhouse where the owners are on the floor every night, making sure your meal is perfect. From the moment you walk in and see those crackling fireplaces to the last bite of chocolate mousse pie, this is dining done right.
Whether you are celebrating something special or just craving a steak that makes you rethink your dinner plans for the next month, Mountain Jacks delivers. Let us talk about why this Lafayette gem might just convince you to start house hunting nearby.
Prime Rib That Has Earned Legendary Status
People have been driving from all over Indiana for the prime rib at Mountain Jacks since 1979, and nearly 50 years later, it is still the gold standard. This is not your average prime rib that shows up dry and flavorless.
Every cut is tender, juicy, and cooked exactly how you order it.
The seasoning is simple but perfect, letting the quality of the beef shine through. When it arrives at your table with a side of rich au jus and fresh horseradish, you will understand why regulars order it every single time.
One guest who visited in November 2025 said it best after returning for the first time in over 40 years: it is still the best prime rib in town.
You can order it in different sizes depending on your appetite, but fair warning, even the smallest cut is generous. The meat practically melts in your mouth, and that perfectly pink center is a thing of beauty.
Pair it with their au gratin potatoes, which are more like a creamy, cheesy potato casserole, and you have got a meal worth writing home about.
Mountain Jacks takes pride in consistency. Whether you visit on a busy Saturday night or a quiet Tuesday evening, the prime rib tastes the same: incredible.
That kind of reliability is rare, and it is one of the biggest reasons this steakhouse has stood the test of time in Lafayette.
The Famous Salad Wheel Experience
Before your steak even arrives, you are in for a treat with the farmhouse salad experience. Mountain Jacks brings a salad prep wheel right to your table, loaded with fresh toppings, and you get to choose exactly what goes on your greens.
It is interactive, fun, and honestly kind of genius.
The wheel is packed with options like bacon bits, shredded cheese, croutons, diced tomatoes, onions, and more. Your server will pile on whatever you want, and they are not stingy about it.
Guests rave about how generous the toppings are and how fresh everything tastes.
This salad wheel has been a tradition at Mountain Jacks for decades. One reviewer mentioned it might even be the same type used back in 1979, which adds a nostalgic charm to the whole experience.
It is one of those little touches that makes dining here feel special, not just another meal out.
Even if you are not usually a salad person, this one is worth trying. The combination of crisp lettuce, your favorite toppings, and a tangy dressing is the perfect way to start your meal.
Plus, it is included with your entree, so you are getting serious value along with a memorable dining moment.
Kids love it too. Letting them pick their own toppings turns a simple salad into something exciting, making Mountain Jacks a great choice for family celebrations or special occasions.
Cozy Atmosphere With Crackling Fireplaces
Walking into Mountain Jacks feels like stepping into a warm, inviting lodge. The fireplaces scattered throughout the dining rooms add a cozy glow that immediately puts you at ease.
On a cold Indiana evening, there is nothing better than settling into your booth near the fire with a cocktail in hand.
The interior has that classic steakhouse vibe, dark wood, intimate lighting, and a layout that does not feel crowded even when the place is packed. Individual lights at each table provide just enough illumination to read the menu without feeling like you are under a spotlight.
It strikes the perfect balance between romantic and comfortable.
This is an older building, but it is well maintained and clean. The decor has a timeless quality that makes you feel like you are dining somewhere with history and character, not some cookie cutter chain.
Regulars appreciate that Mountain Jacks has kept its charm over the years instead of chasing trends.
Whether you are celebrating an anniversary, a graduation, or just treating yourself to a great meal, the atmosphere here sets the right tone. It is upscale without being stuffy, which means you can dress up or keep it casual and still feel at home.
The side rooms offer a bit more privacy if you are dining with a larger group, though they can get a little louder during busy times like Purdue football weekends.
Service That Goes Above and Beyond
Great food is only half the equation at a steakhouse. The other half is service, and Mountain Jacks absolutely nails it.
Servers like Benz and Mike have earned glowing reviews for being attentive, friendly, and genuinely invested in making sure your meal is perfect.
What really sets this place apart is the ownership. The owners are on the floor every single night, greeting guests, bussing tables, and making sure everything runs smoothly.
One reviewer was blown away to see the owner clearing dishes and doing whatever was needed to help the staff, even on a packed evening. That level of care is rare and speaks volumes about how much pride they take in the restaurant.
If something is not quite right with your meal, the staff handles it with grace and urgency. Several guests mentioned that when a steak came out slightly undercooked or overcooked, it was quickly corrected without any fuss.
The goal is simple: they want your experience to be perfect, and they will do what it takes to make that happen.
Even during the busiest times, like Thanksgiving or Purdue game days, the service remains top notch. Reservations are honored promptly, and walk ins are accommodated as quickly as possible.
You never feel rushed, and your server checks in just enough without hovering.
This kind of hospitality is what turns first time visitors into regulars.
A Menu That Goes Beyond Steak
While the prime rib and steaks steal the spotlight, Mountain Jacks offers plenty of other options that are just as impressive. The walleye is a standout, cooked to flaky perfection and seasoned just right.
Guests who order it often say it is some of the best fish they have had at a steakhouse.
If you are in the mood for something a little different, the whiskey glazed salmon is a solid choice. It has a sweet and savory glaze that complements the rich flavor of the fish.
The chicken Kiev pasta dish is another favorite, especially for those who want something hearty but not quite as heavy as a steak.
Appetizers are worth ordering too. The hot and spicy shrimp, coconut shrimp, and stuffed mushrooms all get high marks from regulars.
The potato skins are loaded and shareable, perfect for starting off your meal. The onion soup comes topped with crispy fried onion twists, a nice touch that adds texture and flavor.
Sides are included with your entree, and you can choose from options like wild rice pilaf, green beans, au gratin potatoes, and more. The au gratin potatoes are especially popular, rich, cheesy, and comforting.
Even the Caesar salad is well executed, crisp and flavorful without being overdressed.
For dessert, the chocolate mousse pie and carrot cake are both excellent choices. The creme brulee also gets rave reviews for its smooth custard and perfectly caramelized sugar topping.
Surprisingly Affordable for a High End Steakhouse
One of the biggest surprises for first time visitors is how reasonable the prices are at Mountain Jacks. For an upscale steakhouse with this level of quality and service, you would expect to pay a lot more.
The portions are generous, and when you factor in the included salad and sides, the value is hard to beat.
A perfectly cooked ribeye or New York strip will not break the bank here. The prime rib, which is the star of the menu, is priced fairly for the portion size you get.
Even the largest cut, which is more than enough for a hearty appetite, comes in at a price that feels reasonable compared to other steakhouses in Indiana.
Entrees come with a salad and one or two sides, so you are not nickel and dimed for every little addition. That is a big deal when you are dining out with family or friends and want to keep the bill manageable without sacrificing quality.
The drink menu is well curated too, with a diverse wine list and classic cocktails like martinis and whiskey drinks. The Razzmatazz is a popular choice if you like sweeter cocktails, and it is priced in line with what you would expect at a nice restaurant.
Mountain Jacks proves you do not have to spend a fortune to enjoy a memorable steakhouse experience. It is the kind of place you can visit for a special occasion without feeling guilty about the cost.
Perfect Location for Purdue Fans and Lafayette Locals
Located at 4211 South Street in Lafayette, Mountain Jacks is perfectly positioned for anyone visiting Purdue University or exploring the Greater Lafayette area. It is a popular spot for pre game dinners during football season, and the staff is used to handling the extra crowds with ease.
After your meal, you are just a short drive from campus and all the excitement of a Purdue game day. The restaurant is also close to other Lafayette attractions like the Tippecanoe Battlefield Museum at 200 Battleground Avenue, where you can learn about the historic 1811 battle, or Columbian Park Zoo at 1915 Scott Street, a great spot for families.
If you are looking for more dining or entertainment options nearby, downtown Lafayette offers plenty of local shops, cafes, and breweries. The Wabash Heritage Trail is also close by, perfect for a post dinner walk along the river if the weather is nice.
Mountain Jacks is open Tuesday through Sunday, with hours that make it easy to plan a visit. They are closed on Mondays, so plan accordingly.
On weekends, they stay open a bit later, with Friday and Saturday service until 9:30 PM.
Whether you are a Purdue alum returning for a game, a Lafayette local celebrating something special, or just passing through on a road trip, Mountain Jacks is worth the stop. It is the kind of restaurant that makes you want to plan your whole evening around it.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
