Pulling off the highway into downtown Kyle, Texas, I almost missed it. Hidden along West Center Street, Texas Pie Co sits in a modest little building that smells like butter and brown sugar before you even reach the door.
Walking inside felt like stepping into someone’s grandmother’s kitchen, the kind of place where the oven is always warm and the counters are dusted with flour. Baking-themed decor lines the walls, small pie tins hang like artwork, and the whole room hums with a quiet, cozy energy that immediately slows you down.
I had driven out from Austin on a whim, half-expecting a cute novelty shop, but what I found was something far more genuine. Texas Pie Co is the kind of place that makes you want to pull up a chair and stay a little longer than planned.
A Small Town Spot With a Big Reputation
Kyle, Texas is one of those towns that sneaks up on you. It sits just south of Austin, easy to pass through without a second glance, but locals know it holds a few hidden gems worth stopping for.
Texas Pie Co is probably the most talked-about of them all. With over 1,000 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, word has clearly spread well beyond the city limits.
People drive from Austin, Round Rock, and even farther just to grab a box of pies to bring home.
The shop sits at 202 W Center St, right in the heart of downtown Kyle. It is a short, walkable stretch with a small park across the street, which makes the whole visit feel like a genuine small-town afternoon.
There is nothing rushed about this place. It operates Tuesday through Saturday, opening at 10:30 AM, so planning ahead is part of the experience.
Arriving on a weekday feels like a little reward. The neighborhood is quiet, the pace is slow, and the moment you step inside, the outside world fades.
For a town growing as fast as Kyle is, Texas Pie Co feels like a steady anchor to something simpler.
Walking Into the Coziest Room in Texas
The inside of Texas Pie Co is exactly what you hope for when you imagine a hometown pie shop. Baking-themed decor fills every corner, from rolling pin displays to vintage tin signs, and the whole space feels curated without trying too hard.
Tables are simple and close together, the kind of setup that makes you feel like you are sharing a meal in someone’s home rather than a commercial restaurant. Natural light comes in through the front windows, landing softly on the display case full of pies lined up like little works of art.
There is a counter where you place your order, which keeps things casual and unpretentious. The room smells incredible, a warm blend of pastry, cinnamon, and something faintly sweet that hits you before you even look at the menu.
It is the kind of smell that triggers a memory you did not know you had.
Customers chat quietly at their tables, a few people linger near the display case making impossible decisions, and the staff moves around with a comfortable familiarity. The atmosphere alone makes the trip worthwhile.
It is genuinely one of the most inviting small spaces in Central Texas.
Pies That Taste Like They Were Made This Morning
Every pie at Texas Pie Co is made in-house, and you can taste the difference from the very first bite. The crust alone sets these pies apart, thick, flaky, and buttery in a way that reminds you what pie crust is actually supposed to taste like.
Flavors range from classic to creative. Pecan, Dutch Apple, and Key Lime sit alongside Peanut Butter Mousse, Fudge Chocolate, Snickerdoodle, and Strawberry Peach.
There is always something familiar and something surprising waiting in that display case.
One of the best features is the option to buy individual five-inch pies, perfect for trying multiple flavors without committing to a full-sized pie. Several customers have mentioned buying five or more small pies in a single visit, which honestly seems like the right strategy.
The shop will even warm up your pie if you ask, which turns an already great experience into something borderline magical. Dense chocolate filling, real whipped cream, tart citrus, and buttery pastry all show up consistently across the menu.
These are not shortcuts or frozen fillings. They are the real thing, made with care, and it shows in every single slice.
The Lunch Menu Deserves Its Own Moment
Most people arrive thinking about pie, which is fair, but the lunch menu at Texas Pie Co quietly earns its own loyal following. Sandwiches, daily specials, and hearty comfort dishes round out a menu that goes well beyond dessert.
The chicken salad sandwich has been called the best in the city by more than one regular. Box lunches come with chips and a drink at a price that feels almost too reasonable for what you get.
Friday’s chicken pot pie special draws repeat visitors who plan their week around it.
Daily specials rotate through the week and lean into classic American comfort food. Meatloaf on Thursdays, pot pie on Fridays, and King Ranch chicken on Tuesdays give the menu a home-cooked rhythm that feels intentional.
It is the kind of rotation a good cook would plan for a family dinner.
There are also ready-to-go meal options, casseroles and dishes you can take home and heat up for a family meal. For anyone new to the area or just passing through, stumbling onto this lunch menu feels like a bonus discovery inside an already great find.
Pie for dessert just makes the whole meal feel complete.
The Pie Crust That Customers Cannot Stop Talking About
If there is one detail that comes up again and again in customer reviews, it is the crust. Multiple people have called it the best pie crust they have ever had, which is not a small claim when you are talking about something as personal as pie.
A great pie crust is harder to make than it looks. It needs the right ratio of fat to flour, a light hand during mixing, and enough time in the oven to develop that deep golden color without losing its tenderness.
Texas Pie Co clearly has that process figured out.
The crust holds up beautifully whether it is wrapped around a fruit filling, a chocolate mousse, or a creamy custard. It does not go soggy.
It does not crack apart. It just holds everything together the way a good crust should, firm enough to slice cleanly, tender enough to melt in your mouth.
Even the lemon squares, which are not technically a pie, come with a homemade crust that customers rave about separately. That level of consistency across an entire menu is the mark of a kitchen that takes its craft seriously.
The crust alone is reason enough to make the drive.
Bringing Home a Box Full of Happiness
One of the best things about Texas Pie Co is how well the pies travel. The small five-inch pies stack neatly into a box, and they hold up beautifully on the drive home, whether that is twenty minutes or two hours away.
Customers regularly leave with five, eight, or even ten small pies at a time. The variety of flavors makes it easy to grab something for everyone, a classic pecan for dad, a peanut butter mousse for the kids, a Dutch apple for anyone who leans toward fruit.
It turns a simple stop into a full gift.
Buttermilk, Chocolate Fudge, Snickerdoodle, Blueberry, Strawberry Rhubarb, and more line the display case depending on the day. Not every flavor is available every visit, which gives each trip a slightly different character and a good reason to come back soon.
The shop also offers to-go meal options for families, casseroles and ready-to-heat dishes that make weeknight dinners easier. Pairing a family meal with a box of pies for dessert is genuinely one of the better ideas this place quietly encourages.
It is the kind of takeout that feels like it came from someone who actually cooks.
A Park Across the Street and Pie in Hand
Right across the street from Texas Pie Co sits a small, pretty park, and once you know it is there, it completely changes how you plan your visit. Grabbing your pie and walking outside to find a bench is one of those simple pleasures that feels almost too good to be accidental.
Families with kids especially appreciate this setup. Children can run around while adults sit back and actually enjoy their dessert without the usual pressure of managing a small table inside a busy cafe.
It gives the whole experience a relaxed, unhurried quality that is hard to find anywhere.
On a clear Central Texas afternoon, eating a slice of key lime pie on a park bench in downtown Kyle is genuinely one of the better ways to spend an hour. The light is good, the air smells like grass, and the pie tastes even better outside for some reason.
It is a small detail, but it adds a lot to the overall memory of visiting this place. Texas Pie Co is not just about what happens inside the shop.
The whole block, the street, the park, and the small-town feel all combine into something that sticks with you long after the last bite.
Worth the Drive From Austin and Then Some
Kyle sits about 25 miles south of downtown Austin, close enough for a spontaneous day trip and far enough to feel like a genuine escape. Several reviewers have made the drive from Round Rock, San Marcos, and even the Rio Grande Valley specifically to visit Texas Pie Co.
The drive itself is easy. South on I-35, a quick exit into downtown Kyle, and suddenly you are on a quiet main street that feels nothing like the city you just left.
It is the kind of short road trip that resets your mood before you even arrive.
For Austin locals looking for a weekend outing that does not involve a crowd or a two-hour wait, Texas Pie Co offers something refreshingly low-key. You show up, you order at the counter, you pick your pies, and you leave happy.
The whole process is simple by design.
First-time visitors often say they cannot believe they waited so long to make the trip. Repeat customers plan return visits before they have even finished their first box of pies.
That kind of pull is rare, and it speaks to how consistently Texas Pie Co delivers something genuinely worth seeking out. Make the drive.
You will not regret it.
A Neighborhood Gem That Keeps People Coming Back
Texas Pie Co has been part of the Kyle community for years, and the loyalty it has built says a lot about what it consistently gets right. Regulars return for the Friday pot pie special, the rotating dessert case, and the simple comfort of a place that has not tried to become something it is not.
New residents to the area often discover it through a neighbor’s recommendation and then become regulars themselves almost immediately. There is a reason over a thousand people have taken the time to leave a review.
This place makes an impression that lasts.
Operating Monday through Friday from 10:30 AM to 6:30 PM and Saturday until 4 PM gives the shop a schedule that feels deliberate. Sunday is a day of rest, and somehow that fits the personality of the place perfectly.
It is a shop with boundaries, a craft to protect, and a standard to maintain.
Whether you are a Kyle local or someone passing through for the first time, Texas Pie Co offers the kind of experience that is increasingly hard to find. Good food, made from scratch, in a room that feels like home.
Address: 202 W Center St, Kyle, TX 78640.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
