Tucked away on East US Highway 36 in Avon, Indiana, sits a seafood gem that has been winning over locals and travelers alike. Ugly Crab might have a quirky name, but its reputation for serving some of the most delicious lobster tails and seafood boils in the area is no joke.
This casual eatery offers a refreshing break from the typical chain restaurant experience. With a laid-back vibe and a menu packed with fresh catches, it has become a go-to spot for anyone craving authentic seafood without the fuss.
Whether you are a seafood enthusiast or just looking to try something new, Ugly Crab delivers an experience that is both memorable and satisfying. From buttery garlic sauces to perfectly seasoned boils, every dish is crafted to bring bold flavors to your table.
If you have been searching for a place where quality seafood meets a welcoming atmosphere, your search ends here. Get ready to discover why this unassuming restaurant has earned rave reviews and a loyal following throughout Indiana.
Lobster Tails That Are Absolutely Worth the Trip
Lobster lovers, prepare to be amazed. Ugly Crab serves lobster tails that have earned a reputation for being tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection.
Many customers rave about how these succulent tails stand out as the star of their meal, offering a rich taste that rivals anything you would find at high-end seafood restaurants.
What makes these lobster tails special is the way they are prepared with a variety of signature sauces. You can choose from garlic butter, house blend, or a spicy kick that adds layers of flavor to every bite.
The sauces soak into the meat beautifully, creating a mouthwatering experience that keeps people coming back for more.
Each tail is generously sized and arrives piping hot at your table. The presentation is simple but effective, with everything served in a classic seafood boil style that encourages you to dig in with your hands.
Bibs and gloves are provided so you can enjoy your meal without worrying about the mess.
Customers often mention that the lobster tails are priced fairly for the quality and portion size. While seafood in the Midwest can sometimes be hit or miss, Ugly Crab consistently delivers freshness that makes the drive to Avon worthwhile.
Whether you are celebrating a special occasion or just treating yourself, these lobster tails will not disappoint.
Snow Crab Legs That Bring Authentic Seafood Flavor
Snow crab legs are one of the most talked-about items on the menu, and for good reason. These sweet, tender legs are cooked fresh and served with your choice of sauce, making them a must-try for anyone who loves seafood.
The meat pulls away easily from the shell, and each bite delivers that classic crab flavor that seafood fans crave.
Ugly Crab offers snow crab by the pound, so you can order as much or as little as you like. Many diners choose to combine snow crab with other seafood options like shrimp or sausage for a full boil experience.
The flexibility of the menu lets you customize your meal to match your appetite and preferences.
One thing customers appreciate is how well-seasoned the crab legs are. The garlic butter sauce is a popular pick, but the house blend adds a mild spice that enhances the natural sweetness of the crab.
Some guests even mix sauces to create their own unique flavor profile, and the staff is always happy to accommodate special requests.
While some reviews mention that the snow crab can take a bit of effort to crack open, most agree that the reward is worth the work. The quality of the meat is consistently praised, with many noting that it tastes fresh and never fishy.
This attention to quality is what sets Ugly Crab apart from other seafood spots in the area.
If you are new to eating crab legs, do not worry. The casual, self-serve style of the restaurant means you can take your time and enjoy the process.
There is a sink available near the drink station, making cleanup easy and convenient after your meal.
Flavorful Sauce Options That Elevate Every Dish
One of the standout features at Ugly Crab is the variety of sauces available to accompany your seafood. From mild garlic butter to spicy house blends, these sauces are crafted to bring out the best in every bite.
Customers often mention how the sauces are rich, buttery, and packed with flavor, making them just as memorable as the seafood itself.
The garlic butter sauce is a classic choice that never disappoints. It has a smooth, creamy texture that coats the seafood perfectly, adding a savory richness that complements the natural flavors.
Some diners note that the seasoning in the garlic butter becomes even more pronounced the next day, making leftovers taste even better.
For those who enjoy a bit of heat, the house blend in mild or spicy levels offers a delicious kick. The spice is balanced and not overwhelming, allowing you to enjoy the flavor without losing the taste of the seafood.
Many regulars recommend trying a mix of sauces to get the best of both worlds.
What makes the sauce selection special is how customizable everything is. You can request your preferred level of spice, mix different sauces together, or even ask for extra sauce on the side.
Casual and Relaxed Atmosphere Perfect for Any Occasion
Walking into Ugly Crab feels like stepping into a no-frills seafood haven where the focus is squarely on great food and a comfortable experience. The atmosphere is easygoing and unpretentious, making it an ideal spot for family dinners, casual dates, or even a solo meal when you are craving something delicious.
The restaurant features a self-serve style that some guests find refreshing. You order and pay at the counter, fill your own drinks at the soda machine, and clear your table when you are done.
While this might feel different from traditional sit-down restaurants, it keeps the vibe relaxed and allows you to enjoy your meal at your own pace.
Seating is comfortable and the space is kept clean, with tables that are wiped down regularly. The dimly lit interior adds a cozy feel, though some customers mention they would prefer brighter lighting.
Still, the ambiance works well for creating a laid-back dining experience where you can focus on enjoying your food without distractions.
Music plays softly in the background, typically modern pop tunes that keep the energy light and upbeat. During the holiday season, the restaurant has been known to decorate festively, adding a cheerful touch that enhances the overall vibe.
These small details show that the team at Ugly Crab cares about creating a welcoming environment.
Generous Portions That Leave You Satisfied
Hungry diners will be thrilled to know that Ugly Crab does not skimp on portion sizes. Many customers report leaving with plenty of leftovers, even after sharing meals with friends or family.
The seafood combos are especially popular, offering a hearty mix of crab, shrimp, lobster, and sausage that can easily feed two people.
Each boil comes with sides like corn on the cob and red potatoes, which are just as filling as the main seafood. The potatoes absorb the flavorful sauces, becoming tender and delicious, while the corn adds a sweet contrast that balances the richness of the seafood.
Together, these elements create a complete meal that satisfies even the biggest appetites.
The pound-based ordering system allows you to control how much food you get, which is perfect for both light eaters and those looking to indulge. You can start with a smaller order and add more if needed, or go all out with a multi-pound combo that includes a variety of seafood options.
This flexibility is a big plus for groups with different hunger levels.
Guests often mention that the value for money is solid, especially considering the quality and quantity of food served. While seafood can be pricey, Ugly Crab offers a dining experience that feels worth the cost.
You are paying for fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and enough food to enjoy a second meal at home.
Friendly and Helpful Service That Makes You Feel Welcome
From the moment you walk through the door, the staff at Ugly Crab greets you with warmth and genuine friendliness. First-time visitors often comment on how the team takes the time to explain the menu and ordering process, making sure everyone feels comfortable and informed.
This level of attentiveness goes a long way in creating a positive dining experience.
The counter-service format means you interact directly with the staff when placing your order, and they are always ready to answer questions or offer recommendations. Whether you are unsure about which sauce to choose or need help deciding on portion sizes, the team is knowledgeable and eager to help.
Their enthusiasm for the food is evident and adds to the overall welcoming vibe.
Servers are quick to bring your food to the table once it is ready, and they check in to make sure everything is to your liking. If something is not quite right, they are more than willing to make adjustments or bring additional items.
This responsiveness shows a commitment to customer satisfaction that guests truly appreciate.
Even during busy times, the staff maintains a friendly and efficient demeanor. There is no rushing or pressure, and you are encouraged to take your time and enjoy your meal.
Convenient Location and Hours for Easy Access
Located at 9655 East US Highway 36 in Avon, Ugly Crab is easy to find and conveniently situated for both locals and travelers passing through the area. The restaurant sits in a busy commercial zone with plenty of parking, making it a hassle-free stop whether you are running errands or planning a special meal out.
The operating hours are designed to accommodate a variety of schedules, with the restaurant open Tuesday through Saturday from noon until 10 PM, and Sundays from noon to 9:30 PM. Mondays are the only day the restaurant is closed, giving the team a well-deserved break while still offering six days of availability for guests.
For those who prefer to plan ahead, Ugly Crab accepts phone orders at 317-220-8168, and you can also check out their website at uglycrabavon.com for menu details and updates. This makes it easy to order ahead and pick up your meal, which is perfect for busy weeknights or when you want to enjoy seafood at home.
The location is also close to other attractions and amenities in Avon, making it a great spot to include in a day of shopping or exploring. After your meal, you can easily head to nearby parks, shops, or entertainment venues, turning your visit into a full outing.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
