There is a small shop in Birmingham, Alabama, that is quietly changing the way people think about olive oil. A unique tasting room inside a local marketplace lets visitors sample dozens of freshly sourced olive oils and balsamic vinegars before choosing their favorites.
Since opening in 2015, this destination has been drawing curious food lovers who want to experience the difference between ordinary oils and carefully crafted small-batch products. From rich flavors to expert guidance, every visit feels like a chance to discover something new.
If you have never tasted truly fresh extra virgin olive oil straight from the source, this gem offers an experience that may completely change the way you think about one of the kitchen’s most essential ingredients.
Come Taste Truly Fresh Olive Oils From Around The Globe
Most people have never tasted olive oil that is actually fresh. The stuff sitting on grocery store shelves has often been there for months, sometimes longer.
At Simply Infused, located at 5287 Highway 280 #249 inside The Mercantile in Birmingham, Alabama, every oil on the tasting bar is sourced from both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres to guarantee peak freshness year round.
Because olives are harvested at different times depending on which side of the world they come from, the shop can rotate in newly pressed oils throughout the year. That means no matter when you visit, you are tasting oil at its absolute best.
The difference in flavor compared to store-bought oil is genuinely surprising.
Some oils taste grassy and bold. Others have a buttery, smooth finish or a gentle peppery kick at the back of your throat.
That peppery sensation, by the way, is actually a sign of high polyphenol content, which is linked to real health benefits. You can taste each one before committing to a bottle, which makes the whole experience feel low pressure and genuinely fun.
This is not shopping. It is a flavor education that sticks with you long after you leave the store.
Do Discover Many Unique Fused And Infused Olive Oil Options
Forget plain olive oil. Simply Infused carries an impressive lineup of fused and infused oils that can completely transform the way you cook.
Fused oils are made by crushing whole ingredients directly with the olives during pressing, which locks the flavor deep into the oil itself. Infused oils are blended after pressing, creating a lighter but still vibrant flavor profile.
The bestselling Baklouti Green Chili Pepper olive oil is a fan favorite for good reason. It starts with a smooth, fruity taste and then builds into a slow, satisfying heat that lingers just long enough to keep things interesting.
It is the kind of oil that makes a simple pasta dish feel like something special.
Other popular picks include Blood Orange, which pairs beautifully with salads and grilled fish, and Tuscan Herb, which is basically a ready-made flavor bomb for bread dipping. Basil, Wild Mushroom and Sage, and Garlic infused options round out a lineup that covers nearly every cooking style imaginable.
The variety here is genuinely exciting, and because you can taste everything before purchasing, there is no risk of buyer regret. Many visitors end up leaving with two or three bottles they never expected to love.
That is part of what makes browsing this tasting bar such a rewarding afternoon.
Try A Variety Of Aged Balsamic Vinegars From Italy
Balsamic vinegar gets a lot better when it actually comes from Modena, Italy, and has been aged properly. Simply Infused carries more than 40 barrel-aged balsamic vinegars, ranging from 12-year and 18-year aged varieties to a luxurious 20 to 23 year Molto Denissimo that pours like thick syrup and tastes almost like dessert on its own.
The flavor range across the balsamic selection is genuinely wide. You can sample the 12-year aged Umeboshi Plum Balsamic, which has a tart, fruity depth that works brilliantly with pork or duck.
The Cascadian Wild Raspberry White Balsamic is lighter in color and sweeter in profile, making it a natural match for fresh salads or even sparkling water.
Speaking of sparkling water, that is actually a great way to try a balsamic before committing to a bottle. A few drops in a glass of bubbly water lets the flavor speak for itself without any distraction.
One of the more surprising suggestions from the shop is drizzling a traditional balsamic over vanilla ice cream. It sounds unusual, but the combination of sweet cream and tangy aged vinegar is genuinely delicious.
If you have only ever used balsamic vinegar straight from a supermarket bottle, the quality difference here will honestly catch you off guard in the best possible way.
Make The Tasting Room Your Personal Flavor Playground
There is something genuinely playful about the tasting room setup at Simply Infused. You are not handed a menu and told to pick something.
Instead, you are encouraged to try combinations, ask questions, and follow your curiosity wherever it leads. The shop has even been described by its own owner as a culinary playground, and that description fits perfectly.
Pairing olive oils with balsamics is where things get really interesting. A citrusy Blood Orange olive oil drizzled with a Dark Chocolate balsamic creates a flavor combination that sounds strange but tastes like something you would order at a high-end restaurant.
A robust Garlic olive oil paired with a Fig balsamic makes an instant marinade that works on almost anything.
The interactive nature of the experience means you are not just buying a product. You are learning how to use it.
That knowledge goes home with you and changes how you approach cooking in your own kitchen. Visitors who come in skeptical often leave with a completely new perspective on what simple ingredients can do.
The tasting bar is open during regular shop hours, which run Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM, with the shop closed on Sundays. You can reach them at 205-408-4231 or browse online at simply-infused.com before your visit to get a feel for the full lineup.
Plan To Elevate Your Health With Ultra-Premium Products
Not all olive oils are created equal, and the difference between ultra-premium and standard grocery store oil goes far beyond taste. Simply Infused stocks oils that are certified for purity, free from added chemicals, artificial colors, and pesticides.
Every bottle on the shelf meets a higher standard than what most people are used to finding at a regular supermarket.
For anyone focused on health, the robust olive oils with high polyphenol content are worth paying close attention to. Polyphenols are natural plant compounds that have been studied for their potential anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties.
Some health-focused visitors take two tablespoons of a high-polyphenol robust oil daily as part of a personal wellness routine, and Simply Infused is one of the very few local places in the Birmingham area where you can actually find these specialty oils in person.
The 750ml bottle offers the best value if you plan to use olive oil regularly for health purposes. It lasts roughly a month at a two-tablespoon daily serving, which makes the cost per use more reasonable than it might initially appear.
Buying locally also means you can ask questions, taste before purchasing, and know exactly what you are getting. For anyone serious about putting better ingredients into their body, this shop delivers a level of quality and transparency that is genuinely hard to find elsewhere in Alabama.
Find Gourmet Specialties Beyond Just Oil And Vinegar
Simply Infused is primarily known for its olive oils and balsamic vinegars, but the shop carries a broader selection of gourmet specialties that are worth exploring on their own. Handmade pastas line the shelves, offering a quality that is noticeably different from what you find in a standard grocery aisle.
These are the kind of ingredients that make a simple weeknight dinner feel like something you actually put effort into.
The seasoning selection adds another layer of variety to the shopping experience. Whether you are looking for something to rub on a cut of meat before grilling or a blend to finish a roasted vegetable dish, there are options here that go well beyond the usual salt and pepper.
The seasonings are curated to complement the oils and vinegars, so the pairings feel intentional rather than random.
One item that keeps coming up among repeat visitors is the Sicilian Lemon stuffed olives. They are bright, briny, and citrusy in a way that makes them impossible to stop eating.
They work beautifully as a standalone snack or as part of a larger spread. The overall product mix at Simply Infused reflects a genuine love of food and quality ingredients.
Every item in the shop feels like it earned its spot on the shelf, which gives the whole experience a sense of curation that casual grocery shopping simply cannot replicate.
Come Get Expert Guidance At The Welcoming Tasting Bar
Walking into a shop full of dozens of oils and vinegars can feel overwhelming if you do not know where to start. That is exactly why the staff at Simply Infused make such a difference.
They are genuinely knowledgeable about every product on the tasting bar and happy to walk you through the options based on what you actually cook and eat at home.
Whether you are building a high-polyphenol health routine, looking for the perfect salad dressing combination, or just curious about what makes a barrel-aged balsamic different from a regular one, the team here can answer your questions clearly and without making you feel rushed. The atmosphere is warm and conversational, not salesy or pressured.
You get the sense that everyone working there actually uses and believes in what they are selling.
Recipe suggestions come naturally during the tasting process. You might learn that a Lemon olive oil paired with a Honey Ginger balsamic makes a brilliant glaze for salmon.
Or that a drizzle of Persian Lime oil over black bean tacos changes the whole dish. These are the kinds of practical, kitchen-ready ideas that stick with you.
The shop is easy to find inside The Mercantile at Brook Highland on Highway 280, and the staff are consistently described by visitors as friendly, warm, and genuinely enthusiastic about sharing what they know.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
