Some places just stop you in your tracks, and a certain riverside tavern tucked into a small Virginia town does exactly that. Locals have been debating for years whether this spot is the best-kept secret in the state or criminally underappreciated by the wider world.
I say it is both, and after my visit, I am convinced this is one of those rare places that genuinely earns every ounce of its reputation. Steeped in colonial history, perched along the Rappahannock River, and serving food that borders on unforgettable, this Virginia gem is the kind of dining experience that makes you rearrange your entire road trip just to go back.
A Building That Has Seen It All
Few buildings in Virginia carry as much living history as this one. The structure at 314 S Water Lane in Tappahannock has been standing since the early 1700s, surviving wars, floods, and centuries of change without losing an ounce of its original character.
Back in its earliest days, it operated as what colonials called an “ordinary,” a combined tavern and inn that served as a critical waypoint for sailors, merchants, and travelers passing through one of Virginia’s busiest ports. The Rappahannock River was a commercial highway, and this building sat right at its edge.
Walking up to the entrance today, you can feel the weight of all those years. The exterior holds its colonial bones with quiet confidence, nothing flashy, just genuinely old and genuinely proud of it.
Tappahannock itself is a small town, easy to miss if you are cruising through Virginia on autopilot. But slow down, take the turn toward the water, and suddenly you are standing in front of something extraordinary.
The building alone is worth the detour, before you even step inside.
Stepping Inside Feels Like Time Travel
The moment you cross the threshold at 1710 Tavern, something shifts. The air feels different, heavier with history, warmer with atmosphere.
Wide-plank hardwood floors creak softly underfoot, and exposed ceiling beams stretch above you like the ribs of an old sailing ship.
Cast iron wall sconces throw a golden glow across the room, and original lead glass windows filter the outside light into something softer and more forgiving. Every surface tells a story.
The fireplaces are original, the stonework unrestored in the best possible way.
Restoration work here was done with remarkable care. The team behind the project preserved every authentic detail they could find while quietly weaving in the modern comforts that make a long dinner feel effortless.
One of the most charming details is a framed menu from the original 18th-century establishment, displayed near the bar area as a quiet nod to the tavern’s roots. It puts everything in perspective.
You are not just eating dinner in Virginia. You are sitting inside a piece of American history, and somehow, it never feels like a museum.
It feels alive.
The Bar Area Deserves Its Own Spotlight
Not every bar can claim to be a conversation piece, but the one inside 1710 Tavern absolutely earns that title. The handcrafted Old World-style wooden bar is a centerpiece of the room, built with the kind of craftsmanship that makes you want to run your hand along the surface just to appreciate the detail.
It anchors the space beautifully, giving the room a sense of ceremony without feeling stiff or formal. The surrounding decor leans into the colonial aesthetic without going overboard.
Nothing feels like a costume or a theme park version of history.
A Menu That Honors the Land and the River
The culinary philosophy at 1710 Tavern is rooted in something genuine. Locally sourced ingredients take center stage, and the kitchen treats them with the kind of respect that only comes from truly caring about the final plate.
Modern interpretations of colonial-era dishes run through the menu like a thread connecting past and present. A seared lamb lollipop starter arrives with butternut squash puree, Idaho gold potato cubes, and house-made salsa verde.
It sounds ambitious, and it absolutely delivers.
Seafood plays a starring role, which makes complete sense given the tavern’s riverside location. The Rappahannock River has fed this region for centuries, and the kitchen channels that tradition into every course.
Rockfish, scallops, and she crab soup appear regularly and are prepared with precision.
Virginia has a long culinary heritage tied to its waterways and farmlands, and this menu celebrates both without apology. The portions are generous, which surprises many first-time visitors who expect fine dining to mean tiny plates.
Everything is made in-house, including desserts crafted by a dedicated pastry chef. That level of commitment to quality shows up in every single bite from start to finish.
Award-Winning Status That Actually Means Something
Awards in the restaurant world can feel hollow sometimes, handed out by committees who never actually ate the food. The recognition that 1710 Tavern received from Virginia Living Magazine is a different story entirely.
In 2025, the tavern claimed the top spot in Fine Dining category in the Best of Virginia awards. Winning one category is impressive.
Winning both simultaneously is a statement. It signals that this is not a place coasting on its historic charm alone.
The culinary execution at 1710 Tavern is genuinely at the highest level Virginia has to offer. The kitchen and bar operate in sync, each pushing the other toward something better with every service.
What makes this recognition feel earned rather than ceremonial is the consistency. A single brilliant night can fool award panels.
Sustained excellence over time cannot. The team here has built something that holds up under scrutiny, under busy Saturday nights, under the weight of high expectations from people who have driven hours across Virginia just to eat here.
That is the real achievement, and the awards are simply the paperwork confirming what the food already proves every evening.
Tappahannock: The Town That Sets the Scene
Tappahannock is the kind of Virginia town that does not shout for attention. It sits quietly along the Rappahannock River, going about its business with the unhurried confidence of a place that knows its own worth.
The town itself has colonial roots stretching back centuries. At its peak as an international port, ships from across the Atlantic docked here, and the streets hummed with trade, commerce, and the kind of lively debate that eventually helped fuel a revolution.
Today, Tappahannock moves at a gentler pace. The historic downtown district is walkable and charming, with architecture that rewards anyone willing to look up from their phone for five minutes.
The river remains the town’s defining feature, broad and reflective, giving everything a slightly cinematic quality.
Arriving in Tappahannock for the first time feels like finding a chapter of Virginia history that nobody bothered to oversell. There are no crowds jostling for the best photo spot.
No lines snaking around the block. Just a well-preserved riverfront town doing what it has always done, offering genuine hospitality to anyone smart enough to stop and stay a while.
The tavern fits perfectly into this setting.
The Patio Experience Changes Everything
Most people book a table inside, drawn by the fireplaces and the beamed ceilings, and that is completely understandable. But the back patio at 1710 Tavern is a revelation that deserves far more attention than it typically gets.
Tucked behind the building, the outdoor space has a completely different energy from the interior. It feels like a private garden party that somehow never ends.
String lights, greenery, and the quiet sounds of a small Virginia town at night create an atmosphere that is genuinely hard to replicate.
On warm evenings, the patio fills up quickly, and for good reason. Sitting outside with the old building rising behind you, the night air carrying the faint scent of the river, is one of those experiences that burns itself into memory.
The service extends seamlessly from inside to out, with the same attentiveness and care that defines the entire operation. Groups celebrating special occasions tend to gravitate toward the patio, and it is easy to see why.
There is something about being outside under the Virginia sky, surrounded by centuries of history, that makes any meal feel like a proper occasion worth remembering long after the evening ends.
Staying the Night Makes Perfect Sense
One dinner at 1710 Tavern is rarely enough. The good news is that staying overnight in Tappahannock is not just possible, it is genuinely appealing.
The Historic Essex Inn sits directly across the street, making the logistics almost embarrassingly convenient.
The Essex Inn is part of the same family operation as the tavern, run by the Huff family who have invested deeply in preserving and celebrating this corner of Virginia. The inn carries its own historic character, offering a bed and breakfast experience that matches the quality standards set by the restaurant across the road.
Guests who stay at the inn get the full Tappahannock experience: dinner at the tavern, a night in a historic building, and breakfast the following morning prepared with the same care and quality that defines everything the Huff family touches.
For anyone driving through Virginia and looking for a place to genuinely slow down and absorb some history, this combination of inn and tavern is a rare find. Parking is available nearby at Prince Street Parking or the lot between Barbour Printing and Martin-Sale Furniture.
Handicap parking is conveniently located across the street at the Essex Inn itself.
A Place That Locals Actually Love
There is a reliable test for any restaurant claiming to be special: check whether the locals eat there regularly. At 1710 Tavern, the answer is an emphatic yes.
On any given evening, the dining room holds a healthy mix of people celebrating special occasions and regulars who simply cannot stay away.
That local loyalty is telling. Tappahannock is a small community, and word travels fast.
A restaurant that consistently delivers at this level earns genuine devotion from the people who live nearby and have plenty of other options for comparison.
The owner is known for walking the room, engaging with tables, sharing the history of the building, and occasionally pulling out actual artifacts like bullets and cannonball pellets found during restoration. That kind of personal investment in the guest experience is rare and refreshing.
Virginia has no shortage of restaurants leaning on colonial history as a marketing hook. What makes 1710 Tavern different is that the history is real, the food is exceptional, and the warmth feels completely unperformed.
It is a place that earns its reputation one table at a time, every single night it opens its doors to the community it has served for over three centuries.
Plan Your Visit and Make It Count
Getting to 1710 Tavern requires a bit of intention, and that is part of what makes the trip feel like a proper adventure. Tappahannock sits in the Northern Neck and Middle Peninsula region of Virginia, a stretch of the state that rewards those willing to leave the interstate behind.
The tavern is open Thursday through Monday for dinner, with Sunday brunch rounding out the weekly schedule. Tuesday remains a day of rest.
Reservations are strongly recommended, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings when the dining room fills up fast. Calling ahead at (804) 925-6710 or booking through the website at 1710tavern.com takes about two minutes and saves considerable frustration.
The address is 314 S Water Lane, Tappahannock, VA 22560, right along the river where this building has stood since the early eighteenth century. Parking is available at Prince Street Parking or the nearby lot between Barbour Printing and Martin-Sale Furniture.
Coming to Virginia and skipping this place would be a genuine mistake. Pack a bag, book a table, and cross the street to the Essex Inn for the night.
Some experiences are worth building an entire trip around, and 1710 Tavern is absolutely one of them.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
