I have driven past a lot of bakeries in Indiana, but nothing quite stopped me in my tracks like Concannon’s Pastry Shop in Muncie. The second you walk in, you’re met with rows of donuts that feel more like edible art than breakfast, glossy glazed rings, thick chocolate frosting, colorful sprinkles, and cream-filled favorites stacked high behind the glass.
People drive from an hour away, some even crossing state lines, just to grab a dozen. Since 1959, this hometown staple has been proving that a simple $2 donut can still be unforgettable, soft in the center, lightly crisp on the outside, and made fresh daily.
One visit is usually all it takes before you start planning the next one.
The $2 Donut That Started It All
Some foods just hit differently when they are made the right way, and the donuts at Concannon’s Pastry Shop are proof of that. Priced at just $2, these hand-crafted rings of fried dough have been drawing loyal fans from across Indiana and beyond for decades.
Reviewers consistently call them some of the best donuts they have ever had, and that is not a small claim.
What makes them stand out is the balance. They are not overly sweet, not too dense, and the glaze settles in just the right way.
One customer who drives a full hour from home described the trip as completely worth it every single time. Another Muncie native who now lives in Florida says stopping at Concannon’s is a non-negotiable part of every visit back home.
Fresh is the key word here. Customers who have tried the donuts both in-store and at home say the difference is remarkable.
Getting one straight from the case, still warm and soft, is an experience all on its own. The apple fritter alone has earned serious praise, described as huge, delicious, and absolutely worth every penny of that $2 price tag.
If you only do one thing in Muncie, make it this.
A Muncie Staple Since 1959
Sixty-plus years in business is not something that happens by accident. Concannon’s Pastry Shop has been a fixture in Muncie since 1959, and that kind of staying power says everything about the quality and community connection this place has built.
Generations of Muncie families have walked through these doors for birthday cakes, holiday treats, and everyday indulgences.
There is something deeply comforting about a local business that has outlasted trends, big-box competitors, and changing tastes. Concannon’s has done exactly that by staying true to what it does best: honest, freshly baked goods made with care.
Reviewers repeatedly mention that this is where their families have always bought birthday cakes, and that tradition carries real emotional weight.
Located at 4801 W Baker Ln in Muncie, the shop sits in a spot that feels like it belongs to the neighborhood. It is not flashy or oversized.
It is exactly what a beloved local bakery should be. The kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and where first-time visitors quickly become repeat customers.
Muncie has a lot of history, and Concannon’s is woven right into the fabric of it. Visiting here feels less like shopping and more like connecting with something genuinely rooted in Indiana culture.
The Pretzel Twist Donut You Will Think About for Days
Not every bakery takes creative risks with their menu, but Concannon’s has a pretzel twist donut that one reviewer called the best donut they have ever eaten. That is a bold statement, especially from someone who had clearly eaten a lot of donuts before stopping in.
The combination of soft dough, a slightly salty finish, and that twisted shape makes it genuinely unlike anything you will find at a chain bakery.
It is the kind of item that sounds simple but delivers something unexpected. The contrast between sweet glaze and a hint of pretzel flavor creates a bite that keeps you reaching for another piece before you have even finished the first.
Customers who tried it on a whim ended up making it their regular order.
Concannon’s has always excelled at taking classic formats and giving them just enough of a twist, pun intended, to feel fresh and exciting. The pretzel donut is a perfect example of that philosophy.
It shows that the bakers here are paying attention, experimenting, and genuinely caring about what ends up in the display case. If you visit and the pretzel twist is available, do not hesitate.
Grab one immediately. You will absolutely understand what all the excitement is about after the very first bite.
Custom Cakes and Special Orders That Knock It Out of the Park
Ordering a custom cake can feel stressful, especially when the event really matters. Concannon’s Pastry Shop has a track record of making that process easy and the results genuinely impressive.
One reviewer shared that they needed a special cake made for an event and that Concannon’s completely delivered, helping make the whole occasion go smoothly.
From birthday cakes to wedding cakes, the shop handles special orders with the kind of skill and care that only comes from decades of experience. Families in Muncie have been trusting Concannon’s with their most important celebrations for generations, and that trust has been earned one perfectly decorated cake at a time.
The staff is described as wonderful and sincere, people who genuinely want to help you get exactly what you are looking for. Pre-orders are accepted, which means you can plan ahead and arrive knowing your custom creation is ready and waiting.
The shop also carries an impressive variety of everyday baked goods, so even if you are just browsing, you will likely walk out with something special in hand. For anyone planning a party, a wedding, or even just a memorable family dinner in the Muncie area, Concannon’s custom cake service is one of the most reliable and rewarding options in all of central Indiana.
A Sweet Shop Experience Beyond Just Donuts
Walking into Concannon’s feels like stepping into a place where every corner has something new to discover. Beyond the legendary donut display, the shop features a full retail area stocked with candies, chocolates, gourmet popcorn, and a variety of house-baked goods that go well beyond your typical bakery fare.
One reviewer joked it was a diabetic’s dream and nightmare all at once, which honestly sounds about right.
The shopping area gives visitors a chance to bring a little piece of the Concannon’s experience home. Whether you are grabbing a box of chocolates as a gift, picking up a bag of gourmet popcorn for movie night, or loading up on assorted pastries for the office, there is no shortage of options.
The variety is genuinely impressive for a local shop of this size.
Muffins, cookies, pies, cakes, and seasonal specialties fill the cases alongside the famous donuts. The atmosphere is cozy and fun, with plenty of seating if you want to sit down and enjoy your treats on the spot.
It is the kind of place where you go in for one donut and leave with a full box of assorted goodies. Concannon’s has mastered the art of making a simple bakery visit feel like a full, satisfying outing worth every minute of the drive.
Friendly Service That Makes Every Visit Feel Personal
Good food matters, but great service is what turns a one-time visit into a lifelong habit. At Concannon’s Pastry Shop, the staff consistently earns praise for being warm, attentive, and genuinely kind.
One recent reviewer specifically called out a team member named Melanie T, noting that she taped boxes, stapled bags without being asked, and stayed calm and welcoming even during a very busy rush.
Those small gestures add up. When you are navigating a crowded bakery on a Saturday morning with a box full of donuts, having someone who takes care of the details without being prompted makes a real difference.
It reflects a workplace culture where people take pride in what they do and actually care about the customer experience.
Long-time regulars describe the staff as sincere and helpful, people who treat every customer like a familiar face even on the busiest days. For a shop that has been in business since 1959, that level of consistent hospitality is no small feat.
New visitors often mention being surprised by how efficient and friendly the whole operation feels, even when the line is out the door. Concannon’s proves that great service and great donuts are not mutually exclusive, and that combination is a big part of why people keep coming back year after year.
Perfect Starting Point for a Full Day Out in Muncie
Starting your morning at Concannon’s Pastry Shop sets a great tone for a full day of exploring Muncie. After grabbing a fresh donut and a coffee, the city has plenty to offer just a short drive away.
Minnetrista, located at 1200 N Minnetrista Pkwy, is a beautiful cultural center and museum campus sitting right on the banks of the White River, perfect for a leisurely morning walk after your bakery stop.
If you enjoy outdoor spaces, Tuhey Park at 2001 N Morrison Rd offers a relaxed setting with open green space and picnic areas ideal for enjoying any extra pastries you picked up. For art lovers, the David Owsley Museum of Art on the Ball State University campus at 2000 W University Ave features an impressive collection that is free and open to the public most days of the week.
Muncie also has a charming downtown area with local shops and cafes worth exploring, including the Muncie Civic Theatre district nearby. The city has a lot of character, and Concannon’s fits right into the spirit of it.
Open Tuesday through Sunday starting at 6 AM, with Sunday hours beginning at 7 AM, the bakery makes an ideal first stop before a full day of seeing what this underrated Indiana city genuinely has to offer.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
