Every dessert lover in Indianapolis knows about The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, but not everyone understands why it has such a devoted following. Located at 6515 Carrollton Ave in the heart of Broad Ripple, this bakery has turned into something more than just a place to grab a sweet treat.
It is a full sensory experience that combines whimsical decor, high-end pastries, and an atmosphere that feels like walking into a fairy tale. From the moment you walk through the doors, you are greeted with sparkling chandeliers, pink florals, and edible glitter on nearly everything.
The staff treats every guest like royalty, and the menu offers everything from decadent cakes to savory quiches and sandwiches. Whether you are celebrating a birthday, bridal shower, or simply treating yourself to a midweek pick-me-up, this bakery delivers an experience that keeps people coming back daily.
An Enchanting Atmosphere That Feels Like a Fairy Tale
Walking into The Cake Bake Shop feels like stepping into a storybook world where everything sparkles and shimmers. The interior design is a dream for anyone who loves pink, florals, and all things glamorous.
Fairy lights dangle from the ceiling, chandeliers cast a soft glow across the dining room, and every corner is decorated with thoughtful details that make you want to linger.
The Broad Ripple location on Carrollton Avenue is smaller and more intimate than the Carmel shop, which makes it feel even more special. Tables are close together, creating a cozy and bustling environment that adds to the charm.
Guests often mention how the decor alone is worth the visit, and it is easy to see why.
The aesthetic is not just for show. It sets the tone for the entire experience.
From the moment you sit down, you feel like you are being treated to something extraordinary. The staff embraces the whimsical vibe, often sprinkling edible glitter on desserts and drinks, which has become a signature touch that guests adore.
Families love bringing their children here because it feels magical for kids. Young girls especially light up when they see the sparkles and pastel colors.
But adults appreciate it just as much, finding it a refreshing escape from the everyday routine.
Award-Winning Cakes That Are Almost Too Beautiful to Eat
The cakes at The Cake Bake Shop are the main attraction, and for good reason. Each one is a work of art, covered in delicate frosting, intricate designs, and of course, edible glitter.
Popular flavors include the Earl’s Court Chocolate Cake, Carrot Cake, Lemon Blueberry Cake, and the famous Cookie Dough Cake. Every slice is generously portioned, so you definitely get your money’s worth.
Guests rave about the moistness and richness of the cakes. The Earl’s Court Chocolate Cake is a standout, with layers of deep chocolate flavor that satisfy even the most serious chocoholics.
The Carrot Cake has a muted, creamy frosting that complements the spiced cake perfectly, making it a favorite among those who prefer less sugary desserts.
The Lemon Blueberry Cake offers a lighter option with a refreshing citrus flavor. Some guests find the texture slightly different from traditional cakes, with a finer crumb that some describe as mealy, but most agree that the overall flavor and presentation make up for any textural quirks.
The Cookie Dough Cake is a fun choice for those who want something playful and indulgent.
One thing to note is that the frosting style here is unique. It is not overly sweet or heavy like traditional buttercream.
Instead, it has a lighter, more refined flavor that lets the cake itself shine.
Savory Menu Options That Surprise and Delight
While desserts steal the spotlight, The Cake Bake Shop also serves a thoughtful selection of savory dishes that deserve recognition. The menu includes quiches, sandwiches, soups, salads, and even charcuterie boards.
Many guests come for lunch or brunch and are pleasantly surprised by the quality and flavor of the food.
The Broccoli Quiche is a customer favorite, offering a rich and satisfying option for those who want something hearty. The Half Turkey and Gruyère Sandwich is another popular choice, served with fresh arugula salad or a cup of soup.
The Chicken Velvet Soup is frequently mentioned in reviews as a showstopper, with a creamy texture and comforting flavor that pairs perfectly with the warm bread and butter served before the meal.
The Croque Madame and the Brie and Ham Sandwich also receive high marks for their rich, indulgent flavors. The sandwiches are made with quality ingredients and are generously portioned, making them a great value despite the higher price point.
The Lemon Caesar Salad offers a lighter option with a unique twist on the classic Caesar.
The charcuterie board is a great option for sharing, featuring seasoned nuts, quality meats, and cheeses that are beautifully arranged.
After enjoying a meal, consider taking a walk through the nearby Broad Ripple Park at 1426 Broad Ripple Avenue, where you can enjoy green space, a playground, and access to the Monon Trail. The park is a great spot to relax and digest before heading back for dessert or exploring more of the Broad Ripple area.
Exceptional Service That Makes Every Visit Special
Service at The Cake Bake Shop is consistently praised in customer reviews. The staff is attentive, friendly, and genuinely excited to make each guest feel welcome.
Many reviews mention servers by name, highlighting how personalized and warm the service feels. Whether you are celebrating a birthday, bridal shower, or just stopping by for a treat, the staff goes out of their way to make the experience memorable.
Guests often mention how patient and accommodating the servers are, especially when dining with children or large groups. The staff is knowledgeable about the menu and happy to offer recommendations based on your preferences.
They are also great at pacing the meal, ensuring that you never feel rushed but also that your food arrives in a timely manner.
Guests appreciate the cozy atmosphere and the feeling that the staff genuinely cares about making their visit special. Even when the restaurant is at full capacity, the service remains friendly and efficient.
If you are planning a special celebration, The Cake Bake Shop also offers a private dining area that is perfect for bridal showers, birthday parties, and other events. The staff can help coordinate printed menus, special decorations, and other details to make your event unforgettable.
Nearby, you can also explore the Indianapolis Art Center at 820 East 67th Street, which offers classes, galleries, and events for art lovers.
Signature Edible Glitter That Adds a Touch of Magic
One of the most talked-about features of The Cake Bake Shop is the edible glitter, affectionately known as pixie glitter by the staff. It is sprinkled on cakes, drinks, and even in your hair if you are celebrating a special occasion.
This whimsical touch has become a signature element that guests look forward to and often mention in their reviews.
The glitter is not just for decoration. It adds to the overall experience of feeling like you are in a magical, fairy-tale world.
Kids absolutely love it, and adults find it fun and Instagram-worthy. Many guests joke about finding sparkles on their faces and clothes long after they leave, which has become part of the charm.
The glitter appears on almost every dessert, from cakes to truffles to cookies. Even the drinks, like the Sparkling Lavender Lemonade and Unicorn Hot Chocolate, are topped with a sprinkle of shimmer.
It is a small detail, but it makes a big impact on the overall atmosphere and experience.
Some people might find the glitter over the top, but most guests embrace it as part of the fun. It is one of those things that makes The Cake Bake Shop unique and memorable.
The staff is enthusiastic about the glitter and often mentions it when describing menu items, adding to the playful and celebratory vibe.
The glitter also makes the bakery a popular spot for social media posts.
Perfect Venue for Special Celebrations and Events
The Cake Bake Shop has become a go-to destination for special celebrations in Indianapolis. Bridal showers, birthday parties, anniversaries, and other milestone events are frequently hosted at the Broad Ripple location.
The intimate size of the shop makes it feel exclusive and personal, while the glamorous decor sets the perfect tone for any celebration.
The bakery offers a private dining area that can be reserved for larger groups. Guests who have hosted events here rave about the attention to detail, from printed menus to special decorations and personalized service.
The staff works closely with hosts to ensure that every aspect of the event is perfect, making it a stress-free and enjoyable experience.
Birthday celebrations are especially popular, with the staff going out of their way to make the birthday guest feel special. They bring out a little dragon decoration, sprinkle glitter, and present the cake with a candle, creating a memorable moment that guests talk about for years.
The overall atmosphere is joyful and celebratory, making it an ideal spot for any happy occasion.
Bridal showers are another common event at The Cake Bake Shop. The elegant and feminine decor is perfect for bridal parties, and the menu offers a variety of options that can be tailored to the group’s preferences.
Many guests mention that hosting a bridal shower here made the day feel extra special and memorable.
Unique Beverages That Complement the Sweet Experience
The drink menu at The Cake Bake Shop is just as impressive as the food. Signature beverages like the Sparkling Lavender Lemonade, Unicorn Hot Chocolate, and various coffee options are designed to complement the sweet treats and enhance the overall experience.
Many of these drinks are topped with edible glitter, adding to the whimsical presentation.
The Sparkling Lavender Lemonade is a customer favorite, offering a refreshing and floral flavor that pairs beautifully with rich desserts. The slight fizz and delicate lavender notes make it a sophisticated choice that appeals to adults and kids alike.
It is also visually stunning, served in an elegant glass with a sparkling finish.
The Unicorn Hot Chocolate is a hit with younger guests and anyone who loves a fun, indulgent drink. It is rich, creamy, and topped with whipped cream and colorful sprinkles, making it a treat for both the eyes and the taste buds.
The hot chocolate is a perfect choice for cooler days or when you want something extra comforting.
Coffee lovers will appreciate the quality of the espresso drinks and brewed coffee. The Cake Bake Shop takes pride in serving well-crafted beverages that meet the same high standards as the food.
Whether you prefer a classic latte or something more adventurous, the drink menu has plenty of options to choose from.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
