I’ve been driving through Boone County for years, and every time I pass through Thorntown, I see the same thing. Cars packed around Stookey’s Family Dining.
It’s not some trendy new spot or a chain restaurant with fancy marketing. It’s a local place that’s been serving up comfort food since the 1960s, and folks keep coming back for one simple reason.
The food is exceptional, especially the catfish. Once you try it, you understand why generations of Hoosiers have made this their go-to restaurant.
The kind of place where servers remember your name and your usual order, where the portions are generous, and where the atmosphere feels like home. I finally stopped in myself, and now I’m part of that loyal crowd that can’t stay away.
The Legendary Catfish That Started It All
Catfish is the star of the show at Stookey’s, and once you taste it, you’ll know why people drive from all over central Indiana just for this dish. The fillets arrive at your table golden brown, perfectly crispy on the outside while staying tender and flaky inside.
Each piece is hand-breaded with a seasoning blend that’s been perfected over decades.
The breading has just enough cornmeal to give it that signature crunch without being too heavy or greasy. You can taste the freshness in every bite, and the fish itself is mild and sweet, never fishy or overdone.
They serve it with homemade tartar sauce that has the right balance of tang and creaminess.
Most orders come with generous portions, often two or three large fillets that hang over the edge of your plate. The kitchen doesn’t rush the cooking process, so everything comes out at the perfect temperature.
Regulars often order it on Friday nights, a tradition that’s been going strong for years.
After your meal, you might want to walk off some of those calories at Sugar Creek Park, located at 100 W Main St, Thorntown, IN 46071, just a few blocks away. The catfish at Stookey’s isn’t just food; it’s an experience that keeps families coming back generation after generation.
Family Recipes Passed Down Through Generations
Walking into Stookey’s feels like stepping into someone’s kitchen, and that’s because the recipes here have real history behind them. The Stookey family started this restaurant in the 1960s, and many of the dishes you’ll find on the menu today use the same recipes from back then.
Nothing has been modernized or changed to follow food trends.
The coleslaw still has that perfect creamy-tangy balance that grandmothers used to make. The green beans are cooked slowly with just the right amount of seasoning.
Even the dinner rolls taste like they came straight from a home oven, warm and buttery.
The kitchen staff takes pride in maintaining these traditional cooking methods, even though it would be easier to take shortcuts. They make their sides from scratch daily, peel their own potatoes, and hand-cut their vegetables.
You can taste the difference between food made with care and food made quickly.
This commitment to authenticity is rare these days, especially in small-town Indiana where so many local restaurants have closed or been replaced by chains. The consistency is remarkable too.
Order the same meal five years apart, and it’ll taste exactly the same. That reliability builds trust with customers who know exactly what they’re getting every single visit.
Portions That Actually Fill You Up
Restaurants today seem to be shrinking their portions while raising their prices, but Stookey’s never got that memo. When your meal arrives, you might actually laugh at how much food is piled on your plate.
The portions are genuinely generous, the kind that leave you taking home a to-go box.
A single catfish dinner includes multiple large fillets, a heaping scoop of real mashed potatoes, your choice of vegetable, coleslaw, and fresh rolls. Some folks can barely finish half of it in one sitting.
The value is incredible when you consider what you’re getting for the price.
The sides aren’t skimpy either. The mashed potatoes come in a mountain that could easily be split between two people.
The coleslaw bowl is full to the brim. Even the dinner rolls come out in a basket with several pieces, not just one sad little roll.
This old-school approach to serving sizes is part of what makes Stookey’s special. They want you to leave satisfied, not still hungry.
Many customers mention that they can get two meals out of a single order. After you’ve eaten your fill, you might want to explore downtown Thorntown, where you’ll find the Thorntown Heritage Museum at 115 N Market St, Thorntown, IN 46071, showcasing local history.
A Menu That Goes Beyond Just Catfish
While catfish might be the signature dish, Stookey’s offers a full menu of comfort food favorites that deserve attention too. The steaks are hand-cut and cooked to your exact preference, with a char that adds flavor without drying out the meat.
Their fried chicken is another customer favorite, with a crispy coating that rivals any Southern kitchen.
The menu also features classics like pork chops, shrimp, and chicken tenders that appeal to pickier eaters or kids. Each entree comes with your choice of potato, vegetable, and a trip to the salad bar.
The variety means that even if someone in your group isn’t a fish fan, they’ll find plenty to enjoy.
Breakfast is served on weekends, with fluffy pancakes, perfectly cooked eggs, and crispy bacon that keeps people coming back. The biscuits and gravy have a following of their own, with a rich, peppery sausage gravy that coats every bite.
The hash browns are shredded and fried until they’re golden and crispy on the edges.
Daily specials keep the menu interesting for regulars who visit frequently. The kitchen isn’t afraid to experiment with seasonal offerings while still maintaining their core classics.
If you’re visiting nearby Lebanon, you might also check out Donner Park at 1500 W Ulen Blvd, Lebanon, IN 46052, about fifteen minutes south.
Service That Makes You Feel Like Family
Good food only goes so far if the service isn’t up to par, but at Stookey’s, the staff treats every customer like they’re part of the family. Many of the servers have worked here for years, some even decades.
They remember regular customers by name and often know their usual orders without asking.
The service strikes that perfect balance between attentive and giving you space. Your water glass never sits empty for long, and someone always checks to make sure your meal came out right.
But they’re not hovering over your table constantly, letting you enjoy your meal and conversation in peace.
Even when the restaurant is packed on a Friday night, the staff manages to keep things running smoothly. Wait times are reasonable, and the kitchen keeps up with the orders without sacrificing quality.
The servers are patient with children and accommodating to special requests when possible.
First-time visitors often comment on how welcoming the atmosphere feels, like they’ve been coming here for years. That warmth isn’t something you can fake or train into people.
It comes from genuine pride in their work and respect for their customers. This kind of hospitality is becoming harder to find, making Stookey’s stand out even more in today’s fast-paced restaurant industry.
An Atmosphere That Feels Like Home
The moment you walk through the doors at Stookey’s, you can tell this isn’t trying to be something it’s not. The decor is simple and comfortable, with booths and tables that have hosted countless family dinners over the years.
The lighting is warm without being dim, and the noise level stays at a pleasant hum even when busy.
There’s no pretension here, no attempt to be trendy or Instagram-worthy. The focus is entirely on providing a comfortable space where people can enjoy a good meal together.
Families with young children feel welcome, as do older couples celebrating anniversaries or groups of friends catching up.
The restaurant has that lived-in feel that only comes with decades of service. The walls hold memories of birthday celebrations, Friday night traditions, and special occasions.
You might see three generations of the same family sitting together at a table, all of them knowing exactly what they want to order.
This authenticity is rare in a world where so many restaurants try to manufacture an experience. Stookey’s doesn’t need to try because it’s the real thing.
The comfortable chairs, the familiar faces, and the consistent quality create an atmosphere that makes you want to linger a bit longer. Nearby, you can visit the Boone County Fairgrounds at 900 E 100 S, Lebanon, IN 46052, which hosts events throughout the year.
A Thorntown Tradition That Keeps Growing
Thorntown isn’t a big city, but Stookey’s has become such an institution that people travel from surrounding counties just to eat here. The restaurant has survived economic downturns, changing food trends, and the rise of chain restaurants by simply staying true to what they do best.
That consistency has built a loyal customer base that spans generations.
Many customers have stories about coming here as children with their parents and now bringing their own kids. Some folks plan their trips through central Indiana specifically to include a stop at Stookey’s.
The restaurant has become part of the fabric of Boone County, a place where memories are made and traditions continue.
The success hasn’t led to expansion or franchising, which speaks to the owners’ priorities. They’d rather maintain quality at one location than spread themselves thin trying to grow.
This focus on doing one thing exceptionally well is part of what makes Stookey’s special.
Local events and community gatherings often involve Stookey’s in some way, whether it’s catering or simply serving as a meeting place. The restaurant gives back to the community that has supported it for so long.
At 125 E Main St, Thorntown, IN 46071, this unassuming building holds something truly special that keeps customers coming back for life.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
