How big does a pizza slice have to get before you stop calling it a slice? That question gets answered pretty quickly here.
A 22-inch pie comes out of the oven, and the slices are so wide that your hands suddenly seem much too small for the job. The breadsticks are no better behaved, the boxes struggle to contain everything, and leftovers are practically part of the order.
This Indiana pizza spot has the kind of energy that makes you stop mid-conversation when a giant pie comes flying out of the oven. Dough gets tossed high, the stone oven stays busy, and nobody seems particularly interested in making small pizzas.
Late-night hours keep the place buzzing after dark, while lunch specials bring hungry customers in earlier. If a slice can double as dinner, tomorrow’s lunch, and a minor arm workout, it might be time to admit that this is not ordinary pizza.
The 22-Inch Pie And Its Legendary Slices
Order one slice and watch the paper plate give up immediately. Slices here get cut from a hand-tossed 22-inch New York style pie, which means the tip hangs off the plate and the wide end covers most of a face.
People are not exaggerating when they say the slices are bigger than their heads. It is a running joke among visitors, and photos of it fill social media feeds from all over.
One slice usually works as a full meal for an average appetite. Two slices tend to defeat even confident eaters, so plan accordingly before ordering a mountain of sides alongside.
Groups get the biggest thrill from ordering a whole 22-inch pie for the table. A single pie has fed large families with slices left over for the next morning, which makes it a smart move for travelers with a hotel fridge.
The Vinny, topped with ricotta, has become a favorite among first-timers who never thought to put creamy cheese on pizza. Meatball and jalapeno is another combination that regulars reach for.
Ask for the pizza well done if a crispier bottom sounds appealing. Regulars swear by that request, and the kitchen is happy to oblige.
Choosing a slice from the display counter is part of the fun, so take a second and pick the one that looks best.
New York Style, Made Right In Indianapolis
Visitors from the East Coast tend to arrive skeptical and leave surprised. The style served here follows the New York playbook closely, from the thin, foldable slice to the chew in the crust and the light char underneath.
Dough is made fresh daily, hand-tossed, then baked on stone. That combination is what creates the crackle on the bottom and the soft pull along the edge.
Sauces are prepared in house, which keeps the flavor bright rather than flat. Cheese melts into the sauce instead of sitting on top like a blanket.
The fold matters more than most people realize. A proper slice bends in half without cracking, and holding it that way keeps toppings from sliding onto shoes.
Travelers who grew up on thick, cut-into-squares pizza often need a minute to adjust. Once they figure out the fold, the whole thing clicks.
West Coast guests have written about finally understanding why New Yorkers order by the slice instead of the whole pie. That single-slice culture is the point.
Anyone curious about the difference between styles gets a live lesson here without leaving Indiana. It is a short walk from the theaters and shops of Mass Ave.
Bring an appetite and skip breakfast. The crust alone deserves undivided attention.
Breadsticks So Big They Get Folded Into The Box
Nobody warns first-timers about the breadsticks, and that is half the entertainment. These things stretch close to two feet, long enough that the crew folds them in half just to fit them into a takeout box.
Garlic butter goes on generously, followed by parmesan and a dusting of oregano. A dipping sauce comes alongside, and marinara is the classic pick.
The breadsticks show up in conversation almost as often as the pizza itself. Hundreds of visitors have singled them out, which says something at a place known for giant slices.
Sharing is strongly recommended. One breadstick easily covers a table of three or four people who also plan on eating pizza.
Other bread options round out the lineup for anyone who wants variety. Cheese bread, sun-dried tomato bread, and pesto bread all get their turn, and garlic knots deliver a chewy, aromatic bite.
The lunch special pairs a slice, a side, and a drink, which is how plenty of downtown workers discover the breadstick for the first time.
Photographs rarely capture the scale properly. Standing next to one at the counter is the only way to appreciate the length.
Grab extra napkins before sitting down, because garlic butter has a way of finding fingers.
Dough Spinning That Doubles As Dinner Entertainment
Kids press against the counter for a reason. The open kitchen puts the pizzaiolos in full view, and they spin, toss, and flip dough high overhead while pies move in and out of the stone oven.
Families with restless children find the show buys them a solid twenty minutes of peace. The tricks are genuinely impressive, not just a quick flourish.
Flour puffs into the air, the dough widens with each toss, and someone always gasps when it climbs higher than expected. It happens throughout the day, not on a set schedule.
Watching the process also explains why the crust tastes the way it does. Hand-stretching keeps the air pockets intact, something a machine press flattens right out.
Ladling sauce, spreading cheese, and sliding the pie onto stone all happen within arm’s reach of the line. Nothing is hidden behind a wall.
The crew tends to be talkative, happy to explain toppings or steer newcomers toward a slice that just came out.
Standing room near the counter fills up fast on Friday and Saturday nights, when the kitchen runs at full speed and pizzas fly in every direction.
Anyone traveling with a camera should keep it ready. The dough toss makes for the best photo of the whole meal.
A Mass Ave Room With Real Personality
The front room feels like a classic corner slice shop, complete with warm lighting, rustic touches, and the constant clatter of a busy counter. Bread baking scents hit before the door even closes.
Seating is comfortable and casual, the kind of place where sneakers and a backpack fit right in. Travelers straight off a walking tour blend into the crowd without a second glance.
Toward the back sits a separate lounge area with moody lighting and darker decor, a noticeable shift from the bright counter up front. Regulars mention it as a distinct second half of the visit.
Outdoor seating is available when Indianapolis weather cooperates, which makes people-watching on Massachusetts Avenue part of the meal.
Staff greet guests quickly and tend to remember faces. That familiarity is a big reason locals treat the place as a regular stop rather than a one-time novelty.
Souvenir cups come with drink orders, and plenty of visitors take them home as a small keepsake from the trip.
Weekend nights get loud in a good way, with conversation bouncing off the walls and the oven door swinging constantly.
Weekday afternoons run calmer for anyone who prefers a quieter table and a slower pace.
Either way, the room has character that a chain simply cannot fake.
Late Night Slices When Downtown Winds Down
Theaters empty out, games end, and downtown Indianapolis starts looking for food. That is exactly when this counter shines, since Friday and Saturday hours stretch all the way to 3 AM.
Sunday through Thursday the doors stay open until midnight, which still covers most post-event appetites. Opening happens at 11 AM every day of the week.
Late-night slices are one of the most talked-about parts of the whole operation. A hot slice at one in the morning has a way of ending a night on a high note.
The Mass Ave location sits within walking distance of plenty of downtown attractions, so no car shuffle is required after an evening out.
Grabbing a single slice keeps things simple when a full meal feels like too much. Ordering by the slice is the default here anyway.
Lunch runs on a different rhythm, with a special that combines a slice, a side, and a drink for a quick midday stop.
Office workers, students, and visiting families all cycle through at different hours, which keeps the crowd interesting.
Calling ahead helps for large orders, especially on weekend evenings when the kitchen is slammed.
Reaching the counter is easy on foot from most of the avenue’s shops and venues.
Cannoli, Black And White Cookies, And Everything Else Worth Ordering
Skipping dessert here would be a mistake, and the display case makes that clear the moment anyone walks up. Housemade cannoli arrive filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips, crisp shell and all.
Black and white cookies bring a proper New York touch, with that split of vanilla and chocolate icing across the top. Cheesecake and chocolate chip cookies fill out the sweet lineup.
Savory options go well beyond pizza too. Calzones come stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and a choice of toppings, and they land on the table heavy.
Subs are a serious part of the menu. The Al Pacino meatball sub with marinara and the Chicken Parmigiana Hero both make sturdy, satisfying meals.
Lighter appetites have real choices as well. A Caprese salad with Fior di Latte mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil offers a fresh counterpoint to all that dough.
Pasta salad and a spring mix salad round things out for anyone splitting a pie with friends.
Ordering a cannoli to go works nicely for travelers heading back to a hotel room. It survives the walk better than a slice does.
Save a little room, because the dessert case is right by the exit.
Address: 545 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46204
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
