I remember the first time someone told me about a family restaurant in Schererville that’s been serving lake perch since 1929. I thought they were pulling my leg.
A seafood spot in Northwest Indiana that’s been around nearly a century? But after my first visit to Teibel’s Family Restaurant, I understood why generations of Hoosier families keep coming back.
This place isn’t trying to be trendy or fancy. It’s doing what it’s done best for almost 95 years: serving up honest-to-goodness comfort food with a side of Midwestern hospitality that feels like coming home.
Whether you grew up going there for special occasions or you’ve never heard of it until now, Teibel’s is one of those rare gems that reminds you why local restaurants matter.
Nearly a Century of Family Tradition Since 1929
Walking into Teibel’s feels like stepping into a time capsule, and that’s exactly what makes it special. The restaurant opened its doors in 1929, right before the Great Depression, and somehow managed to survive everything the last century threw at it.
That kind of staying power doesn’t happen by accident.
What started as a small family operation has grown into the spacious restaurant you see today. The building itself tells a story with its old-school decor that hasn’t changed much in decades.
Some folks might call it dated, but I call it authentic.
The family ownership means something here. You’re not eating at some corporate chain where decisions get made in a boardroom three states away.
The people running Teibel’s have skin in the game, and it shows in how they treat their guests.
During the holidays, they go all out with elaborate Christmas decorations that have become legendary in the community. We’re talking animated figures, a train display, and enough festive cheer to make even the Grinch smile.
It’s the kind of tradition that brings families back year after year, creating memories that span generations.
Lake Perch That Keeps Locals Coming Back for Decades
Ask anyone who’s been to Teibel’s what to order, and nine times out of ten they’ll say the lake perch. This isn’t just any fish on the menu.
It’s the dish that built the restaurant’s reputation, mentioned in over 150 customer reviews.
The perch arrives at your table golden and crispy, breaded just right so you get that satisfying crunch without overwhelming the delicate fish inside. They serve it with drawn butter, though you’ll want to make sure it arrives warm since some diners have noted temperature issues during busy times.
What makes lake perch special is its sweet, mild flavor that’s nothing like the fishy taste some people associate with seafood. It’s a freshwater fish that’s been a staple of Great Lakes cuisine for generations.
Teibel’s knows exactly how to prepare it.
The portions are generous enough that you won’t leave hungry. One regular customer who’s been visiting for 53 years swears by the yellow lake perch dinners, though he did mention quality can vary depending on when you visit.
That’s the reality of any restaurant that’s been around this long.
Old-School Relish Tray and Classic Side Dishes
Before your main course even arrives, Teibel’s serves up something you don’t see much anymore: a proper relish tray. This isn’t some afterthought appetizer.
It’s a trio plate featuring coleslaw, cottage cheese, and pickled beets that harkens back to a different era of American dining.
The coleslaw has earned its own fan club, with customers praising its tangy, crisp flavor that cuts through the richness of fried fish. It’s made fresh, though you’ll want to visit during peak hours to get it at its best.
The cottage cheese adds a cool, creamy element to your meal.
Those pickled beets are divisive. You either love them or you don’t touch them.
But they’re part of the Teibel’s experience, a nod to the German and Eastern European influences that shaped Northwest Indiana’s food culture.
The restaurant also serves up classic sides like mashed potatoes with gravy and green beans. Some reviews mention the mashed potatoes taste like they might come from a mix, which is a bit disappointing for a place that prides itself on homestyle cooking.
The baked potatoes, available with dinner orders after 3 PM, seem to fare better in customer opinions.
Broasted Chicken That Rivals Grandma’s Recipe
While the lake perch gets most of the glory, the broasted chicken at Teibel’s has its own devoted following. This isn’t your typical fried chicken.
Broasting is a pressure-frying technique that seals in moisture while creating that crispy exterior everyone loves.
The chicken arrives as a generous quarter portion, either white or dark meat depending on your preference. The breading has that classic, straightforward seasoning that reminds you of recipes from old church cookbooks.
It’s not trying to be Nashville hot or Korean-style or whatever the latest trend is.
Multiple reviews mention this as some of the best chicken they’ve had, with one customer specifically noting it beats other options in the area. The meat stays juicy inside that golden coating, though timing matters.
A few diners have reported getting chicken that sat too long under the warmer, which can dry it out.
You can also get a combo plate that pairs the chicken with lake perch, which is perfect if you can’t decide or you’re dining with someone who wants to share. The portions are large enough that you might be taking home leftovers, which isn’t a bad problem to have when the food tastes this good.
Walleye and Frog Legs for the Adventurous Eaters
Beyond the famous perch, Teibel’s menu ventures into territory that might surprise first-time visitors. Walleye appears in 20 customer reviews, and frog legs get mentioned 40 times.
These aren’t dishes you find on every menu, even in Indiana.
Walleye is a prized freshwater fish known for its sweet, delicate flavor and firm, flaky texture. It’s popular throughout the Great Lakes region but can be tricky to prepare properly.
When done right, it’s a real treat. When overcooked, it becomes dry and loses that subtle sweetness.
Reviews of the walleye at Teibel’s are mixed. Some diners rave about it, while others have complained it tasted more like tilapia or cod, or arrived overcooked.
Consistency seems to be an ongoing challenge, especially during busy service times.
The frog legs are even more of a wild card. If you’ve never tried them, they taste like a cross between chicken and fish, with a tender texture that surprises most people.
They’re typically breaded and fried at Teibel’s, making them accessible even to skeptical eaters. It’s the kind of dish that makes for good dinner conversation and gives you bragging rights for trying something different.
Service That Makes You Feel Like Family
The waitstaff at Teibel’s gets mentioned almost as often as the food itself. When you read through hundreds of reviews, names like Sheila, Mary, and Camille pop up repeatedly.
That tells you something important: people remember being treated well here.
Good servers don’t just take your order and bring your food. They know the menu inside and out, make recommendations based on what you actually like, and check in at just the right moments without hovering.
The best ones at Teibel’s have been there for years, building relationships with regular customers who request them by name.
That said, service quality can vary depending on how busy they are. Some recent reviews mention long wait times, slow food delivery, and servers who seemed overwhelmed.
A restaurant this size, especially one that’s been around this long, sometimes struggles with consistency during peak hours or special events.
The management’s response to problems also gets mixed reviews. Some customers felt heard and appreciated when issues arose, while others left frustrated that no one seemed to care.
It’s worth noting that Teibel’s closes on Mondays, so the staff gets a regular break, which hopefully helps them stay fresh for the rest of the week.
A Gathering Place for Northwest Indiana Communities
Teibel’s isn’t just a restaurant. It’s become a community institution where Northwest Indiana families mark life’s important moments.
The reviews mention funeral gatherings, birthday celebrations, business meetings, and holiday dinners. This is where memories get made.
The restaurant can accommodate large groups, with a spacious dining room that handles parties of 11 or more without breaking a sweat. Though one family did mention being seated in the bar area despite having young children, which wasn’t ideal.
The facility is big enough to handle crowds, with ample parking that never seems to be an issue.
Located right on US-41 in Schererville, Teibel’s sits in the heart of Northwest Indiana’s restaurant corridor. You’re close to other local spots and attractions, making it easy to build a whole day around your visit.
After lunch, you could head over to Centennial Park at 1028 Parrish Avenue for a walk, or check out the shops along Indianapolis Boulevard.
The restaurant’s longevity means it’s woven into the fabric of the community. Multiple generations have eaten here, creating family traditions that span decades.
That’s not something you can manufacture or fake. It’s earned, one meal at a time, over nearly a century of showing up and serving good food to good people.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
