I’ve visited plenty of coffee shops around Lafayette, but nothing prepared me for what I found at Maddy Hatter’s 10/6 Tea. Walking through that door feels like tumbling down the rabbit hole into a world where every sip comes with a side of wonder.
This isn’t just another place to grab your morning caffeine fix. It’s a full-blown adventure that brings Alice’s Wonderland to life right here in Tippecanoe County.
The owners have created something truly special, a spot that makes you feel like a kid again while serving up seriously good drinks and treats.
Whether you’re a lifelong Lewis Carroll fan or just someone who appreciates a cafe with personality, this whimsical wonderland delivers an experience you won’t find anywhere else in Indiana.
From the moment you step inside until your last bite of cookie, everything about this place feels like pure magic.
Immersive Wonderland Decor That Transports You
Every corner of this cafe at 991 S. Creasy Lane tells a story straight from the pages of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.
The owners didn’t just slap up a few themed posters and call it a day. They went all in, creating an environment where oversized teacups, vintage clocks frozen at 10:6, and playing cards seem to float through the air.
The attention to detail is what really sets this Lafayette spot apart from typical themed restaurants. You’ll spot references to the Mad Hatter’s tea party, the Cheshire Cat’s grin, and the Queen of Hearts’ garden woven throughout the space.
The color palette mixes deep purples and bright teals that make you feel like you’ve stepped through the looking glass in Tippecanoe County.
Kids absolutely love exploring all the little hidden details tucked into every nook. Parents appreciate that the whimsy doesn’t sacrifice comfort or functionality.
The seating is actually cozy, the lighting is perfect for photos, and there’s enough visual interest to keep everyone entertained while waiting for their order.
This isn’t just decoration for decoration’s sake. The themed environment at this Indiana gem enhances the entire experience, making your visit feel like an event rather than just a coffee run.
Themed Drinks With Creative Names and Flavors
The Mock Turtle iced drink has become a fan favorite for good reason. Each beverage on the menu carries a name pulled from Carroll’s classic tale, but these aren’t just gimmicks.
The flavors back up the creativity with combinations that actually work.
You’ll find everything from classic espresso drinks reimagined with a Wonderland twist to specialty teas that would make the Mad Hatter proud. The baristas clearly know their craft, balancing innovative flavor profiles with the quality you’d expect from any serious coffee shop.
What makes it special is how they’ve managed to make themed drinks that don’t sacrifice taste for novelty.
The dairy alternatives available mean everyone can find something that works for their dietary needs. Whether you’re into bold coffee flavors or prefer something lighter and tea-based, the menu offers enough variety to keep you coming back to try new combinations.
Regular customers rave about discovering new favorites with each visit.
The presentation matches the quality of what’s inside your cup. Drinks arrive looking Instagram-worthy without trying too hard, and the taste delivers on the visual promise.
It’s this combination of creativity, quality, and attention to detail that keeps locals making Maddy Hatter’s their regular spot for their caffeine fix.
Crumbl-Sized Cookies That Actually Taste Better
Let’s talk about these cookies because they deserve their own spotlight. Multiple reviewers have compared them to Crumbl in size, but then they go further and say these taste even better.
That’s a bold claim in today’s cookie-obsessed culture, yet the five-star reviews back it up consistently.
The cookies come in a three-pack that makes for a perfect treat to share or take home. Each one is substantial enough to satisfy your sweet tooth without being so overwhelming that you can’t finish it.
The texture hits that ideal balance between crispy edges and a soft, almost gooey center that cookie lovers dream about.
What sets these apart from chain cookie shops is the freshness and quality of ingredients you can actually taste. There’s no corporate recipe being replicated here.
These are crafted with care, and it shows in every bite. The flavors rotate, giving you reasons to keep coming back to try whatever new creation the kitchen has dreamed up.
Pair one with your themed drink and you’ve got yourself a perfect afternoon pick-me-up. The lemon bars also get special mentions in reviews, offering a tangy alternative if you’re not in a chocolate mood.
Either way, you’re leaving with something delicious that rivals anything you’d find at bigger-name bakeries.
Genuinely Friendly Staff Who Enhance the Experience
Quick service matters, but the warmth of the people serving you makes all the difference. Every single review mentions how friendly and welcoming the staff is at Maddy Hatter’s.
This isn’t the kind of forced cheerfulness you sometimes get at chain restaurants.
The owners clearly care about creating a positive experience for everyone who walks through their door. They respond personally to reviews, thanking customers by name and showing genuine appreciation for the feedback.
That personal touch extends to how they train their team and run the daily operations.
Even when you bring three kids under four, as one reviewer did, the staff makes everyone feel comfortable and welcome. They’re patient with questions about the menu, happy to explain the themed drinks, and quick to accommodate special requests.
The service feels less like a transaction and more like being welcomed into someone’s creative passion project.
First-time visitors consistently comment on how the friendly atmosphere made them want to return immediately. The staff’s knowledge about the menu helps you navigate the options without feeling overwhelmed.
They seem to genuinely enjoy working in this whimsical environment, and that positive energy is contagious when you’re placing your order or picking up your treats.
Perfect Family-Friendly Atmosphere for All Ages
Finding a spot that works equally well for adults and children can be tricky. Maddy Hatter’s nails this balance by creating an environment that enchants kids while still offering the quality and atmosphere adults appreciate.
The Wonderland theme naturally appeals to younger visitors who recognize the story or just love the colorful, magical setting.
Parents don’t have to worry about their kids getting bored while waiting for food and drinks. There’s so much to look at and discover that the wait time flies by.
The space accommodates strollers and little ones without feeling cramped or unwelcoming to other customers seeking a quieter experience.
The menu offers options that work for different taste preferences and dietary restrictions. Having dairy alternatives means families with various needs can all find something they’ll enjoy.
The portions are generous enough to share, making it easy to let kids sample different treats without ordering too much.
This makes it an ideal spot for birthday celebrations, after-school treats, or weekend family outings. You’re not just grabbing food and leaving.
You’re creating a memory in a space designed to spark imagination and wonder. Grandparents bringing grandkids, parents with toddlers, and teenagers with friends all find something to love about the experience Maddy Hatter’s provides.
A Local Gem That Fills a Unique Niche
Lafayette finally has something different, something that breaks the mold of typical chain coffee shops. Reviewers keep mentioning how excited they are to have a cool new place like this in their community.
That excitement speaks to how Maddy Hatter’s fills a gap in the local dining and cafe scene.
Independent businesses with this level of theming and commitment to an experience are rare anywhere, let alone in mid-sized Indiana cities. The owners took a risk creating something so specific and whimsical rather than playing it safe with a generic cafe concept.
That risk is paying off as word spreads throughout Tippecanoe County and beyond.
The location at 991 S Creasy Ln makes it accessible for locals without being lost in a crowded downtown area. You can actually find parking and get in and out relatively easily, which matters when you’re trying to fit a visit into a busy day.
Yet it’s close enough to other Lafayette attractions that you can make it part of a larger outing.
After visiting, you’ll find yourself recommending it to friends and out-of-town visitors. It’s become the kind of place people are proud to have in their community, a spot that adds character and charm to Lafayette’s growing food and beverage scene.
Convenient Hours and Quick Service for Busy Schedules
Open Tuesday through Saturday from 8:30 AM to 5 PM means you can catch breakfast, lunch, or an afternoon treat. The hours work well for people who want a morning coffee before work or a midday break from their routine.
Being closed Sunday and Monday gives the owners and staff time to recharge while still serving customers most of the week.
The quick service repeatedly mentioned in reviews matters when you’re on a tight schedule. Nobody wants to wait forever for their order, especially at a cafe.
Maddy Hatter’s has figured out how to deliver fast service without sacrificing quality or making you feel rushed through the experience.
You can call ahead at 765-297-0729 if you want to place an order for pickup. This makes it easy to grab treats on your way somewhere else or pick up cookies for a gathering without waiting.
The efficiency doesn’t diminish the charm or attention to detail that makes this place special.
The combination of reasonable hours, quick turnaround times, and consistent quality means you can make Maddy Hatter’s a regular part of your routine. Whether it’s a weekly coffee date with friends or a monthly family outing, the reliability and convenience factor into why people keep coming back.
You know you’ll get great service without sacrificing your entire afternoon.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
