Twenty inches of pizza is no longer lunch. It is a group project.
The crust folds. The cheese stretches.
The slice bends under its own weight while everyone at the table starts quietly calculating how many pieces count as “just one.”
This Alabama pizzeria built its menu around thin New York-style pies, but the real attention arrived when Dave Portnoy stopped by for one of his famously unforgiving pizza reviews. His score gave the place a much bigger audience and turned an already popular slice into a destination.
The funny part is that the pizza still has to survive the same test. Can you fold it?
Can you eat it without dropping anything? And, most importantly, can you stop at one slice?
A Score That Put Tuscaloosa Pizza on the Map
One bite can change everything. Dave Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports, travels the country tasting pizza and giving honest scores in his One Bite videos.
His visit to The Standard landed a 7.3, a number that counts as a big win in his tough grading system.
That score matters because Portnoy rarely hands out praise for free. He judges the crust, the cheese, the sauce, and even how the bottom of the slice looks when flipped over.
A strong result from him tells pizza fans that the basics are done right. Guests still mention the One Bite connection when they stop in, so the buzz has clearly stuck around.
The owners have openly shared that his reviews shaped how they think about pizza. In a way, the pie was built with tough critics in mind.
The restaurant even features the review on its website, which makes sense given how many travelers plan road trips around his rankings.
Visitors who follow the One Bite series can treat this stop like checking off a box on a pizza bucket list. Order a plain cheese slice first, since that is what Portnoy usually tastes.
Then compare notes and decide whether the score was fair. Snapping a photo of the slice from below, crust side up, is a fun nod to his famous review style.
It also makes a great story to share later with friends.
Twenty Inches of Fold and Go
Bring friends. Seriously, the pies here are huge, stretching a full 20 inches across the tray.
Diners often joke about needing a whole team to finish one, and they are not far off.
The style follows the New York tradition, with a thin crust that bends without breaking. Each wide slice is meant to be folded down the middle, almost like a taco, so the cheese and sauce stay put.
Many fans also love the slightly charred bottom, which adds a toasty crunch under all that soft, chewy dough.
Behind that texture is real patience in the kitchen. The dough is made in-house and rests for one to two days before it ever meets the oven.
That slow proofing gives the crust more flavor and a better chew, something quick dough simply cannot copy.
For a first visit, a plain cheese or classic pepperoni pie shows off the crust best. The pepperoni gets plenty of love from regulars, with little cups of crispy edges on top.
Groups of three or four can usually share one pie with slices left over, which makes cold pizza breakfast the next morning a real possibility. Travelers from New York and New Jersey sometimes say it tastes just like home.
That is a pretty big compliment for a pizza shop sitting deep in the South.
Boom Boom, Hot Honey, and Other Wild Pies
Plain cheese has its fans, but the specialty list is where things get playful. The Boom Boom pie piles breaded chicken tossed in a zesty boom boom sauce, then finishes it with a swirl of ranch.
Even people who usually skip spicy food have said it hits just right.
Then there is the Hot Honey Pepperoni Pie, a sweet and spicy mix that keeps showing up in conversations about the menu. The honey drips into the crispy pepperoni cups and creates a flavor that is hard to forget.
Some families who hunt for great pizza everywhere they travel call it an all-time favorite.
Craving comfort food? The Chicken Parmesan Pie turns the classic Italian-American dinner into a pizza.
The Buffalo Wing Pie brings chopped breaded tenders tossed in a signature sauce over melted mozzarella. A BBQ chicken pie also has its own loyal crowd.
One of the more fun creations is the Holly Wood Pie, credited to Ryan Williams. It starts as cheesy bread and gets loaded with bacon, sausage, and pepperoni, plus a ranch swirl on top.
For something heartier, the thick square Sicilian slice offers a soft, deep bite that feels completely different from the thin pies. A smart plan is to split one classic and one specialty pie.
That way everyone gets a taste of both worlds.
Disco Fries Deserve Their Own Fan Club
Disco fries are a Jersey diner legend, and they found a happy home in Tuscaloosa. These hand-cut fries come smothered in cheese and savory brown gravy.
Fork recommended, napkins required.
The fry lineup does not stop there. Loaded fries arrive topped with cheese, bacon, sour cream, and ranch.
Truffle parmesan fries bring a fancier, earthy twist, while Old Bay fries add a peppery seasoning that East Coast seafood lovers will recognize right away.
Wings are another big reason people keep coming back. They come with a long list of sauces and dry rubs made in-house, so guests can choose mild, smoky, or fiery.
Plant-based eaters are not left out either, since the cauliflower wings have earned plenty of praise for their flavor.
Small bites round out the table nicely. Frickles, which are fried pickles with ranch, give a tangy crunch to start the meal.
Garlic knots with marinara are buttery and soft, and the mega mozzarella sticks live up to their name. Pierogies, little potato and cheese dumplings, are a sweet nod to the owners Pennsylvania roots.
The homemade ranch also gets lots of shoutouts, so grab extra for dipping crusts. Wraps are on the menu too for anyone taking a pizza break.
Ordering a few sides for the table turns a quick slice into a full feast.
Right in the Middle of the Strip
Location is a huge part of the charm. The Standard sits at 1217 University Blvd, Tuscaloosa, AL 35401, right on the stretch locals call the Strip.
Campus at the University of Alabama is just steps away.
On a regular weeknight, the Strip hums with students heading to dinner, study groups, and late hangouts. Game days are a whole different story.
Crimson shirts flood the sidewalks, music drifts out of doorways, and the energy feels like a giant tailgate party.
Fun fact. The whole idea for this pizzeria came from a game-day visit, when co-owner Billy Cornish noticed nobody on the Strip was selling slices to the hungry crowds.
That simple gap became the spark for the business.
A practical tip goes a long way here. Parking is famously tight on the Strip, especially on weekends and before kickoff.
Walking from campus, catching a ride, or parking farther out and strolling in makes life much easier. Folks picking up takeout should plan a few extra minutes for finding a spot.
Even when it gets busy, service tends to move fast. Ordering at the counter keeps things flowing, and food often comes out quicker than expected.
Grabbing a pie before the game and then joining the crowd heading toward the stadium is a classic Tuscaloosa move worth trying at least once.
Late Night Slices After the Lights Go Down
Midnight hunger hits hard in a college town. Luckily, The Standard keeps its ovens warm long after most kitchens close.
Most nights it runs from 4 PM until 2 AM, and Sunday hours wrap up at 11 PM.
That schedule makes it a go-to stop after concerts, study sessions, or a big win at the stadium. Slices sit in the display case ready to grab, so there is no waiting around for a whole pie.
Point, pick, and eat. Simple.
Pizza by the slice is one of the things people mention most. It suits solo visitors who just want a quick bite, and it lets groups mix flavors without committing to a full 20-inch pie.
A slice of pepperoni and a square of Sicilian make a great late snack combo.
The room itself has a relaxed, casual pizza-joint feel. Friends lean over tables, swap stories, and catch games on the screens.
Sports fans have even stopped in to watch big tournament matchups while sharing wings and fries.
For an easy plan, check the hours before heading out, since opening time starts in the late afternoon rather than at lunch.A
Northeast Roots Meet Southern Hospitality
Good pizza starts with people who care about it. Co-owner Billy Cornish spent years running restaurants and nightlife spots in Pennsylvania’s Lehigh Valley, not far from the pizza traditions of New York and New Jersey.
He brought that know-how south.
He teamed up with Greg Melhem and his brothers, Johnny and Maynard, to build The Standard. Together they focused on doing a few things really well, mainly pizza, wings, and fries.
That tight focus shows in how the core menu keeps winning fans.
Staff members get plenty of love too. Guests often call out workers by name for going above and beyond, like replacing a dropped pizza without fuss.
The owners are frequently described as friendly, and regulars say the team likes getting to know familiar faces.
That mix creates a nice balance. The food has Northeast attitude, while the welcome feels warm and easygoing in true Alabama style.
Specials pop up often, so asking about the deal of the day is a smart habit.
Families on campus visits, alumni back for a game, and locals craving comfort food all fit right in here. Nobody needs to dress up or plan far ahead.
Just walk in hungry, grab a seat or a slice, and enjoy a place built by people who clearly love feeding a crowd. It is a little slice of the Northeast with a big Southern smile.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
