I never thought a slice of pie could make me feel so at home until I walked into My Sugar Pie in Zionsville. This charming little shop on Pine Street has become my go-to spot whenever I need something sweet, comforting, or just plain delicious.
The moment you step through the door, you’re greeted by the smell of fresh-baked crusts and the friendliest faces you’ll find in any Indiana bakery. Whether you’re a longtime Hoosier or just passing through, this place deserves a spot on your must-visit list.
Let me share seven reasons why My Sugar Pie has earned its reputation as one of the sweetest stops in the state.
Indiana’s Famous Sugar Cream Pie Done Right
My Sugar Pie takes Indiana’s official state pie seriously, and it shows. The owner spent over six months perfecting the sugar cream pie recipe, tweaking ingredients and ratios until every bite delivered that perfect balance of creamy sweetness and buttery crust.
Customers from as far as Ohio make special trips just to grab one of these pies, and some even have family members smuggle slices across state lines.
What makes this version stand out is the texture. The filling is silky smooth without being too heavy, and the top gets this beautiful caramelized finish that adds just the right amount of crunch.
People who’ve tried sugar cream pies from multiple shops across Indiana consistently rank this one at the top.
You can grab a whole pie for about $43 or try a single slice for $7. The shop serves it fresh daily, so you’ll always get that just-made quality.
If you’re new to sugar cream pie, this is the place to start your education. Return your glass pie dish on your next visit and you’ll even get a discount.
It’s the kind of thoughtful touch that keeps people coming back for more.
Fruit Pies Bursting With Fresh Flavor
Walk into My Sugar Pie on any given day and you’ll find fruit pies that taste like summer no matter the season. The peach blueberry lattice pie has become legendary among regulars, recommended so often by staff that it practically sells itself.
One customer’s mom got assigned permanent pie duty for her friend group after bringing one to a potluck.
The secret is in how they pack the fruit. These aren’t skimpy pies with more crust than filling.
Each slice comes loaded with large, juicy pieces of fruit surrounded by a sauce that tastes like the real deal. The strawberry rhubarb combination hits that perfect sweet-tart balance, while the cherry lattice earned a perfect 10 out of 10 rating from multiple reviewers.
You can choose between lattice-style tops that show off the colorful fruit or Dutch crumb toppings that add extra texture. Staff members are incredibly patient about explaining the differences and helping you pick based on your preferences.
The apple pie holds its own against any grandmother’s recipe, and the peach praline adds a Southern twist that Indiana pie lovers have embraced wholeheartedly.
Cream Pies That Rival Any Dessert
Sometimes you need something richer than fruit, and that’s where My Sugar Pie’s cream pie selection shines. The butterscotch cream pie disappeared so fast during one customer’s visit that they barely got a photo before it vanished.
The peanut butter cream version ranks as a top favorite, combining smooth filling with that unmistakable nutty flavor that peanut butter lovers crave.
Key lime pie brings a tangy brightness to the menu, perfect for cutting through Indiana’s humid summer days. While one detailed reviewer found it good but not extraordinary, most customers appreciate having that citrus option available.
The peanut butter chocolate combination takes two beloved flavors and marries them in a way that makes perfect sense.
These cream pies showcase the quality of the crusts just as much as the fillings. That buttery, flaky base provides the perfect foundation for rich, smooth custards.
Staff will happily explain which pies need whipped cream on top and make sure it’s packaged separately so everything stays fresh. The cream pies tend to sell out faster than fruit varieties, so arriving earlier in the day gives you the best selection.
Crusts That Set The Standard
You can have the best filling in the world, but if the crust fails, the whole pie falls apart. My Sugar Pie understands this fundamental truth, and their crusts have earned specific praise in review after review.
Customers mention the perfect flakiness, the golden color, and that buttery taste that makes you want to eat the edges even before you get to the filling.
The crust-to-filling ratio hits the sweet spot where neither element overwhelms the other. Even the birthday cake pie, which one reviewer felt had too much crust, showcased the quality of the pastry itself.
When you order a Dutch crumb topping, you get generous amounts of that sweet, crumbly mixture that adds texture without making the pie too heavy.
Making consistently great pie crust requires skill and attention to detail. The bakers at My Sugar Pie clearly know their craft, whether they’re creating a traditional bottom crust, a lattice top that shows off colorful fruit, or a full double-crust pie.
Multiple customers specifically called out the crust quality as a reason they’d return. That level of consistency across dozens of pies each day shows real dedication to the fundamentals of great baking.
A Charming Shop In Historic Zionsville
My Sugar Pie sits at 40 East Pine Street in the heart of Zionsville’s charming downtown area. This historic Indiana town gives you that small-town feel while being close enough to Indianapolis for an easy day trip.
The shop itself fits perfectly into the laid-back atmosphere that makes Zionsville special, with seating inside and outside for those who want to enjoy their pie on the spot.
The family-run operation adds to the personal touch. You might meet the owner’s sister during your visit, and staff members take time to explain every pie flavor, ingredient, and baking style without rushing you.
That patience matters when you’re staring at a case full of tempting options trying to make an impossible decision.
After grabbing your pie, you can explore the rest of Zionsville’s downtown. The SullivanMunce Cultural Center at 225 West Hawthorne Street offers art exhibitions and local history just a few blocks away.
Starkey Park at 191 South Ford Street provides green space for a post-pie walk. The shop’s location makes it easy to build a whole afternoon around your visit, turning a simple pie stop into a complete small-town Indiana experience.
Exceptional Customer Service And Kindness
Beyond the pies themselves, My Sugar Pie has built a reputation for genuine kindness that stands out in today’s rushed world. One customer called ahead during a difficult personal loss, hoping to get a slice of sugar cream pie for her father.
When she arrived, the staff had prepared a special bag that moved her to tears and hugs. That kind of compassion can’t be faked or trained into someone.
The staff’s patience shows up repeatedly in reviews. They’ll walk you through the entire menu, explain lattice versus Dutch style, discuss ingredients for those with dietary concerns, and share recommendations based on what other customers love.
When someone picks up a pie, employees make sure they understand heating instructions and include printed information in the box.
Sure, there have been occasional service hiccups mentioned in reviews. One customer felt rushed by a younger employee, and another had whipped cream accidentally left off their order.
The owner responds to every negative review with genuine apologies and offers to make things right. That accountability matters.
The overwhelming majority of experiences involve staff who clearly care about sending customers home happy with amazing pie and warm memories of their visit.
Pies Worth The Investment
Let’s address the elephant in the room. At $43 for a whole pie or $7 for a single slice, My Sugar Pie isn’t the cheapest option around.
Several reviews mention the price point, and it’s fair to wonder if any pie is worth that much. Here’s the thing though: you’re getting a handmade pie in an actual glass pie dish that you can return for a discount on your next purchase.
The quality justifies the cost. These aren’t factory-made pies with preservatives and shortcuts.
Each one gets baked fresh using real ingredients and recipes perfected over months of testing. The generous portions mean a whole pie feeds plenty of people, and that glass dish becomes a bonus kitchen item you can reuse forever.
Customers consistently say the pies are worth every penny. One person drove from Arkansas specifically to visit and plans to return.
Another clears freezer space to stock up during special promotions like the $3.14 per slice deal on Pi Day. When you factor in the quality, the experience, and the reusable dish, the value becomes clear.
Sometimes the best things cost a little more, and My Sugar Pie delivers enough deliciousness to make you forget about the price tag.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
