Shipshewana, Indiana is the kind of place that surprises you. Most people come for the Amish quilts, the flea market, and the horse-drawn buggies rolling quietly down country roads.
What they do not always expect is a pizza buffet that genuinely earns its reputation as a family favorite. East of Chicago Pizza has carved out a loyal following in this small Amish Country town, and once you understand what it offers, the reason becomes clear.
Families exploring the area need a place that is filling, affordable, and welcoming to everyone at the table. This spot checks every one of those boxes.
Whether you are passing through on a weekend trip or spending a few days soaking up the local culture, this pizza buffet deserves a spot on your itinerary.
A Buffet Built for Variety Lovers
Walking up to a buffet and finding only two or three pizza options is one of the most deflating dining experiences imaginable. At East of Chicago Pizza in Shipshewana, that is simply not the case.
The buffet rotates through a solid lineup of specialty pizzas that keeps things interesting from the first plate to the last.
Specialty options like 7 Layer Veggie, All Meat, BBQ Chicken, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Hawaiian, and Taco pizza all make regular appearances. Freshness is a real priority here, and the kitchen takes requests for specific pizzas to be added to the rotation during your visit.
That kind of flexibility is rare at a buffet-style restaurant and makes the experience feel more personal.
The deep-dish crust is buttery and crisp along the edges while staying soft and layered inside. Toppings are generous, and the quality shows in each slice.
For anyone who has grown tired of predictable pizza chains, this buffet brings enough variety to keep the whole table happy. Families with picky eaters will especially appreciate having multiple styles available at once, so nobody has to settle for something they do not actually want.
Prices That Make the Whole Family Breathe Easier
Family travel adds up faster than anyone expects. Between gas, lodging, and admission fees at attractions, the cost of feeding a family of four at a sit-down restaurant can feel like the last straw.
East of Chicago Pizza in Shipshewana is one of those places where the price tag actually matches the experience without any unpleasant surprises.
The buffet has been noted by regulars as reasonably priced, with drink options available at rates that are noticeably lower than what most comparable restaurants charge. For a family that wants an all-you-can-eat experience without the guilt of overspending, this hits a sweet spot that is genuinely hard to find in a tourist-heavy area.
One customer noted paying around eleven dollars for the buffet alone and slightly more when adding a soda, which is a strong value by any measure.
Knowing the price before you sit down also reduces the mental math that can take the fun out of dining out. Everyone eats what they want, nobody is counting slices, and the bill at the end does not require a second look.
For families budgeting a multi-day trip through Indiana, having at least one meal where the cost is predictable and low makes the whole trip feel a little more manageable and a lot more enjoyable.
Dessert Pizza That Actually Steals the Show
Most people do not walk into a pizza buffet expecting dessert to be the highlight. At East of Chicago Pizza in Shipshewana, the dessert pizza has a way of changing that expectation quickly.
It comes up repeatedly in conversations about this restaurant, and the enthusiasm people express about it is hard to ignore.
The dessert lineup includes Chocolate Chip Cookie Pizza, Hershey’s Chocolate Brownie Pizza, and Cinna Pops. These are not afterthoughts tossed onto the buffet to fill space.
They are genuinely satisfying sweet options that round out the meal in a way that feels special, especially for kids who have been patient through a long day of sightseeing in Amish Country.
There is something quietly brilliant about ending a savory buffet experience with a warm slice of cookie pizza or a brownie-topped pie. It turns a practical family fuel-up into something that feels like a small celebration.
The dessert options here are the kind of thing that makes kids ask to come back, and honestly, makes adults want to as well. If you visit East of Chicago and skip the dessert tray, you are genuinely missing one of the most talked-about parts of the whole experience.
Save room, because these sweet finishes are worth it.
Beyond Pizza: A Full Spread Worth Exploring
Pizza gets all the attention, but the full menu at East of Chicago Pizza in Shipshewana goes well beyond what you find on the buffet trays. The salad bar features fresh lettuce and a solid selection of toppings, making it a genuinely useful option for anyone who wants something lighter alongside their slices.
Oven-baked subs are available for those who want something different entirely. Wings, garlic cheese bread, Parm Pops, and pizza bowls round out a menu that covers a lot of ground for a single restaurant.
The Parm Pops with marinara sauce have earned particular praise from people who have tried them, and they pair well with just about any pizza on the buffet.
Having these options matters more than it might seem. Not every person at the table wants pizza, and not every appetite is the same size.
A restaurant that offers genuine variety beyond its main attraction earns extra points in a family setting. Parents can load up on deep-dish while younger or lighter eaters find something that suits them without anyone feeling like they have to compromise.
The range of choices here makes East of Chicago feel more like a full dining destination rather than a one-note stop on a road trip through Indiana’s Amish Country.
Genuinely Family-Friendly From the Moment You Arrive
Some restaurants claim to be family-friendly but make you feel rushed the moment kids start being kids. East of Chicago Pizza in Shipshewana has a different energy.
The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, with enough room and the right kind of casual vibe that families feel comfortable settling in for a real meal.
Parents with picky eaters will find this place especially practical. When a buffet offers multiple pizza styles, there is almost always something that even the most selective child will eat without complaint.
The setup removes the usual tension of ordering from a menu and waiting to see if the food arrives in time to prevent a meltdown.
The restaurant also works well for solo diners or small groups. It does not have the chaotic energy of a loud family entertainment chain, but it has enough warmth and activity to feel lively on a busy Friday or Saturday evening.
Families traveling through Shipshewana often spend long days exploring the flea market or visiting local shops, and by dinnertime everyone is genuinely hungry. Having a spot that accommodates different ages, appetites, and energy levels without any fuss makes East of Chicago a reliable anchor for the end of a full day of Amish Country adventures.
Location That Works Perfectly With Your Amish Country Plans
Placement matters when you are planning a full day out. East of Chicago Pizza sits at 350 S Van Buren St, Suite C, in Shipshewana, Indiana, and its location makes it one of the most convenient dining stops in the area.
The restaurant is right next to the Shipshewana Visitors Center and directly across from the famous Shipshewana Flea Market, which draws visitors from across the Midwest every season.
Shipshewana itself is about two hours east of Chicago, making it a natural day-trip or weekend destination for families from Illinois, Michigan, and northern Indiana. The town is known for its deep Amish heritage, handcrafted goods, and slower pace of life.
After spending a morning browsing stalls at the flea market, located at 345 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565, walking over to East of Chicago for a buffet lunch is almost effortless.
Having a filling, affordable meal right in the heart of the action means families do not have to drive around searching for food or settle for something mediocre out of convenience. The proximity to major local attractions gives East of Chicago a practical edge that goes beyond the food itself.
Good location combined with good food is a combination that is hard to beat in any travel scenario, and this spot delivers on both counts.
Flexible Service Options That Fit Any Schedule
Not every family meal happens at a table with everyone seated and relaxed. Travel schedules are unpredictable, kids get tired earlier than expected, and sometimes you just need food that fits around your plans rather than the other way around.
East of Chicago Pizza in Shipshewana understands this, which is why the restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options.
Delivery through services like DoorDash means that even if you are back at your hotel after a long day at the Shipshewana Flea Market or exploring the area’s back roads, a hot pizza can still reach you. The kitchen has shown it can handle off-site orders well, with customers reporting that pizzas arrive in good condition and taste fresh even after the trip.
The restaurant is open Tuesday through Saturday starting at 11 AM, with Friday and Saturday hours extending to 9 PM, and Sunday hours running from 4 to 8 PM. Monday is the only closed day of the week.
For families staying nearby, knowing that a reliable delivery option exists removes a lot of evening stress. You do not have to pile everyone back into the car just to get dinner.
The takeout option works equally well for a quick grab-and-go situation. This kind of flexibility is what separates a truly family-focused restaurant from one that only works under perfect conditions.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
