There are moments in life when a bowl of soup genuinely changes your afternoon, and honestly, I was not prepared for that to happen to me.
My expectations were modest, maybe a decent broth, a passable matzo ball, the kind of thing you eat and forget.
What showed up in front of me was something else entirely.
The matzo ball was the size of a small planet, the broth smelled like someone’s grandmother had been cooking it since dawn, and the whole thing made me want to cancel my plans and just sit there forever.
If a bowl of soup can make you emotional, this New Jersey creation will stir both heart and spoon.
The Matzo Ball Soup That Started It All
Some bowls of soup feel like a hug from someone who really means it. The matzo ball soup at The Pickled Herring is exactly that kind of bowl.
The broth is golden and deeply savory, the kind that takes time and patience to build, and you can taste every bit of that effort in the first sip.
The matzo balls themselves are soft, pillowy, and light without being mushy. They hold together perfectly and soak up the broth in the best possible way.
Pieces of tender chicken and sweet carrots round out the whole experience, making each spoonful feel complete.
This is not the watery, forgettable soup you might find at a diner. Every element feels intentional and made with real care.
Whether you are stopping in on a cold afternoon or just craving something genuinely comforting, this soup delivers every single time. It is the kind of dish that keeps people driving an hour just to get a cup.
A Deli With Old-School Roots and Real Character
Walking into The Pickled Herring feels like stepping back into an era when delis were community gathering spots, not just places to grab a quick bite. The atmosphere is warm and unpretentious, with a glass display case showing off the day’s deli offerings and the kind of friendly energy that makes you feel at home immediately.
Located at Marlboro Plaza in Englishtown, New Jersey, the place has a small-diner feel that works completely in its favor. It is never trying to be trendy.
The focus here is entirely on the food and the people enjoying it.
There is something refreshing about a spot that sticks to what it does well without chasing any food trends. The Pickled Herring has clearly earned its loyal following the old-fashioned way, through consistency, quality, and a genuinely welcoming vibe.
First-timers often leave already planning their next visit, which says everything you need to know about the place.
Pastrami That Melts Before You Even Take a Bite
Hot pastrami at The Pickled Herring is the kind of thing people talk about on the drive home. It comes out lean, moist, and stacked generously on fresh rye bread, with coleslaw and a pile of kosher pickles waiting on the side.
The pastrami has real flavor without being overly fatty or stringy.
Each slice is tender enough to pull apart gently, and the seasoning is spot-on. It hits that perfect balance between smoky and savory that makes a great pastrami sandwich so hard to find outside of a true deli.
The rye bread is fresh and sturdy enough to hold everything together without falling apart.
Pairing it with the kosher pickles is non-negotiable. Those pickles are sharp and crunchy in exactly the right way, cutting through the richness of the meat like they were made for each other.
This sandwich alone is worth the trip, and a lot of regulars would back that up without hesitation.
Knishes Worth Writing Home About
Not every deli does knishes well, but The Pickled Herring takes them seriously. The square knish here has that perfectly baked exterior, golden and slightly crisp, with a soft, well-seasoned potato filling inside that feels deeply satisfying.
It is comfort food in the most honest sense of the word.
Some regulars go the extra mile and order the Knish-wich, which is pastrami or corned beef tucked between two halves of a knish instead of bread. It sounds like something invented out of pure joy, and eating it confirms that theory completely.
The combination of textures and flavors is genuinely surprising in the best way.
Even on its own, the knish holds its own against anything else on the menu. Served with a side of gravy, it becomes something you will think about for days.
Simple ingredients, real technique, and the kind of result that makes you appreciate classic deli cooking all over again.
Corned Beef Done the Right Way
Corned beef gets a lot of attention at The Pickled Herring, and rightfully so. The beef is slow-cooked until it reaches that ideal point of tenderness, sliced thick, and piled onto bread in portions that feel almost absurdly generous.
It is the kind of sandwich that requires both hands and zero distractions.
The flavor is clean and well-balanced, with the natural saltiness of the beef complemented by whatever you choose to pair it with. Russian dressing, mustard, or just the pickles on the side, every combination works.
The corned beef stands on its own without needing anything to prop it up.
For those who want to go all in, the overstuffed combo with pastrami and corned beef together is a legendary option. The sandwich is literally bursting at the seams, and finishing it feels like a personal achievement.
It is the kind of meal that earns its reputation one satisfied customer at a time.
The Pickles That Steal the Show
Pickles at most delis are an afterthought, a little garnish that shows up on the plate and gets ignored. The pickles at The Pickled Herring are a completely different situation.
They arrive crisp, briny, and full of flavor, and more than a few people have said these are the best pickles they have ever had, full stop.
Both the half-sour and full-sour versions are available, and each one has its own distinct personality. The half-sour is lighter and fresh-tasting, almost cucumber-like.
The full-sour is bold and punchy, the kind of pickle that wakes up your whole palate.
They are the kind of side detail that tells you a lot about how seriously a deli takes its craft. Getting the pickles right is not glamorous work, but it matters enormously to the overall experience.
At The Pickled Herring, every element of the meal gets the same level of attention, and the pickles are proof of that commitment in the most delicious way possible.
A Menu That Covers Every Comfort Food Base
Beyond the soup and sandwiches, the menu at The Pickled Herring stretches out in all the right directions. Mushroom barley soup, thick and hearty, shows up as a serious contender alongside the matzo ball version.
Latkes come out crispy and golden. The Reuben is supersized and stacked in a way that demands respect.
Homemade pot pies, stuffed derma with kishka, and a rotating selection of salads round out the menu in ways that feel both nostalgic and genuinely satisfying. There is always something new to try, even for regulars who have been coming for years.
The variety keeps things interesting without ever losing focus on what the kitchen does best.
Every dish on the menu feels like it belongs there, not filler added to pad out the options. The Pickled Herring has clearly thought carefully about what a great deli menu should look like, and the result is a list of dishes that could each anchor a meal on their own.
Choosing just one thing is the hardest part.
The Kind of Place That Handles the Big Moments
Some restaurants are great for a quick lunch but fall apart when things get serious. The Pickled Herring is the opposite.
The deli has handled catered engagement parties, holiday dinners, and private birthday celebrations with the same energy it brings to a regular Tuesday afternoon service. The back room is available for private events, and the setup is comfortable and genuinely welcoming.
People who have trusted the deli with their special occasions consistently come away impressed. The food arrives hot, the portions are generous, and the staff makes sure everything runs smoothly without rushing anyone.
That kind of attentiveness during a big event is not something you can fake.
For the holidays especially, having The Pickled Herring cater takes a significant amount of stress off the table, literally and figuratively. Families have used the catering service for Christmas dinners, Thanksgiving spreads, and milestone celebrations, and the feedback has been consistently enthusiastic.
When a deli can handle your most important meals, that is a level of trust that takes years to earn.
Why The Pickled Herring Keeps Pulling People Back
People drive more than three hours to eat here. That fact alone says something that no amount of description can fully capture.
The Pickled Herring has built a reputation that extends well beyond Englishtown, drawing in food lovers from across New Jersey and beyond who are chasing something real and consistent.
Open every day from 8 AM to 8 PM, the deli keeps hours that make it easy to stop in for breakfast, lunch, or an early dinner. The steady stream of regulars mixed with first-timers creates an energy that feels alive without being overwhelming.
It is the kind of place where everyone seems happy to be there.
What keeps people coming back is not just the food, though the food is exceptional. It is the whole experience, the familiar atmosphere, the generous portions, the sense that someone genuinely cared about every dish that left the kitchen.
The Pickled Herring is the real thing, and in a world full of imitations, that matters more than ever.
Address: 96 U.S. 9 & Rt 520 Marlboro Plaza, Englishtown, NJ
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
