This Oklahoma Amish-Style Country Store Still Runs on Homemade Comfort Food

Does a store that bakes its own cinnamon rolls from scratch still exist? Spoiler alert: it does, and locals are lining up before the doors open.

Martin House Country Store in Davis, Oklahoma isn’t trying to be trendy or Instagram-famous. It’s simply doing what it’s always done, serving up genuine homemade comfort food and handcrafted goods in a space that feels like stepping onto your grandmother’s front porch.

This isn’t about fancy plating or celebrity chefs. It’s about real butter, real bread, and real people who know your name by your second visit.

Situated along Highway 77 in southern Oklahoma, this bakery and country market has become a must-stop for anyone traveling between the Arbuckle Mountains and Turner Falls.

The family behind the counter greets every guest with warmth that can’t be faked, and the gospel bluegrass playing softly in the background sets a tone that’s equal parts peaceful and joyful.

Some say it’s overpriced. Others say it’s worth every penny.

What’s your take: is homemade comfort food a luxury or a necessity in today’s world?

Cinnamon Rolls That Deserve Their Own Fan Club

Walk through the door on any given morning and the first thing that hits you is the scent of cinnamon, sugar, and yeast working their magic together. These aren’t your average grocery store cinnamon rolls.

They’re massive, soft, and slathered with a glaze that’s sweet without being cloying.

Customers rave about them in nearly every review, and some folks admit they’ve driven over an hour just to grab a container before they sell out. The rolls stay fresh for days, which is a testament to the quality of ingredients and the care put into every batch.

No preservatives, no shortcuts, just flour, butter, and a recipe that’s been perfected over time.

What makes them so special? It’s the texture.

The dough pulls apart in soft, pillowy layers, and the cinnamon swirl runs all the way through. The icing melts slightly into the warm roll, creating pockets of sweetness that make every bite different from the last.

People have been known to buy multiple containers to freeze for later, though most admit they rarely make it to the freezer. Martin House Country Store has built a loyal following around these rolls alone, and it’s easy to see why once you taste one.

Sourdough Bread That Tastes Like a Tradition

Sourdough isn’t just trendy bread anymore. At Martin House, it’s baked the old way, with a starter that’s been fed and nurtured over time.

The result is a loaf with a crisp crust and a tangy, chewy interior that holds up to butter, jam, or a thick slice of cheese.

Customers mention the sourdough specifically in their reviews, noting that it’s unlike anything they’ve found in Oklahoma. The flavor is complex but not overpowering, and the texture is perfect for sandwiches or toast.

It’s the kind of bread that makes you realize what you’ve been missing.

The bakery also offers other varieties like jalapeno cheddar, honey oat, and plain white, but the sourdough has a dedicated fan base. It’s the kind of loaf that gets finished in one sitting, even when you promise yourself you’ll save some for tomorrow.

Baking real sourdough takes time and patience, two things that seem to be in short supply these days. But here, those values are baked right into every loaf.

The bread is made fresh several times a week, and it’s common to see people leaving with multiple loaves tucked under their arms, planning ahead so they don’t run out before their next visit to Davis.

Fried Pies That Bring Back Childhood Memories

Fried pies are a Southern staple, and Martin House does them justice. These aren’t the mass-produced versions you find at gas stations.

Each pie is hand-crimped, filled with real fruit or cream, and fried to a golden crisp that shatters slightly when you bite into it.

The filling options rotate, but favorites include peach, apple, cherry, and chocolate. Some customers swear by the fruit pies, while others go straight for the cream-filled varieties.

Either way, you’re getting a handheld dessert that’s as satisfying as it is nostalgic.

What sets these apart is the crust. It’s flaky but sturdy, sweet but not sugary, and it holds the filling without falling apart.

The pies are best enjoyed warm, though they’re just as good at room temperature if you’re saving one for the road.

Visitors often grab a few extra to take home, knowing they’ll want another one later. The pies have become one of the store’s signature items, and it’s easy to see why.

They’re simple, delicious, and made with the kind of care that’s hard to find these days. In a world of complicated desserts, sometimes a fried pie is all you need to feel satisfied.

Homemade Fudge in Every Flavor You Can Imagine

The fudge case at Martin House is a sight to behold. Rows of thick, creamy squares in flavors ranging from classic chocolate to peanut butter swirl to seasonal specialties line the display.

Each batch is made in-house, and the texture is smooth and rich without being grainy.

Customers love the variety, noting that the flavors change regularly so there’s always something new to try. The fudge is dense and satisfying, the kind that you cut into small pieces because a little goes a long way.

It’s sweet, but not overwhelmingly so, and the quality of the ingredients shines through.

Some people buy fudge as gifts, while others stock up for themselves. Either way, it’s one of those items that rarely makes it home unopened.

The shop wraps it carefully so it travels well, but most folks end up sneaking a piece before they even leave the parking lot.

What makes the fudge special is the consistency. It’s not too soft, not too hard, just the right balance of creamy and firm.

The flavors are bold and true, whether you’re going for a classic or trying something more adventurous. It’s comfort food in candy form, and it’s become one of the store’s most popular items.

Handcrafted Rocking Chairs Built to Last Generations

Out front, a row of rocking chairs invites weary travelers to sit and rest. These aren’t just for show.

They’re for sale, and they’re built by hand with a level of craftsmanship that’s becoming rare. Made from sturdy hardwood, each chair is designed to withstand years of use without wobbling or weakening.

Customers mention the rockers frequently, noting their comfort and quality. Some are single-seaters, while others are built for two.

The wood is left in its natural state or lightly stained, showcasing the grain and the care that went into each piece.

People stop to try them out, and it’s not uncommon to see someone sitting and rocking while their partner shops inside. The chairs are priced fairly, especially considering the quality and the fact that they’re made to order.

Many customers end up buying one to take home, knowing it will be a piece they’ll use and cherish for years.

There’s something timeless about a rocking chair. It’s a symbol of slowing down, of taking a moment to breathe and enjoy the simple things.

At Martin House, the rockers aren’t just furniture. They’re an invitation to pause, to appreciate the moment, and to remember that not everything has to move at breakneck speed.

Jams and Jellies in Flavors You Didn’t Know Existed

The jam and jelly aisle at Martin House is a rainbow of flavors. From classic strawberry and grape to unexpected combinations like peach jalapeno and blackberry lime, there’s a jar for every taste.

Each one is homemade, packed with real fruit, and sweetened just enough to let the natural flavors shine.

Customers rave about the selection, noting that they’ve found flavors here they’ve never seen anywhere else. The jars are sealed tight and labeled clearly, making them perfect for gifts or for stocking your own pantry.

The consistency is thick and spreadable, ideal for toast, biscuits, or spooning straight out of the jar.

What stands out is the balance of sweetness and fruit. These aren’t overly sugary preserves.

They taste like real fruit, captured at its peak and preserved in a jar. The variety means you can try something new every time you visit, and many customers do exactly that.

Jam-making is a labor of love, and it shows in every jar on the shelf. Martin House sources local fruit when possible, and the care taken in each batch is evident.

It’s the kind of product that makes you appreciate the value of homemade goods, and it’s one more reason this store has earned such a loyal following in southern Oklahoma.

Amish Bologna and Cheese That Elevate a Simple Sandwich

In the refrigerated section, you’ll find Amish bologna and a selection of cheeses that turn an ordinary sandwich into something worth sitting down for. The bologna is thick-sliced, smoky, and rich in flavor.

It’s nothing like the processed lunch meat you find at the grocery store.

Pair it with one of the store’s cheeses, like sharp cheddar or jalapeno cheddar, and you’ve got a meal that’s simple but satisfying. Customers mention these items frequently, often noting that they stock up every time they visit.

The quality is undeniable, and the flavor is bold without being overwhelming.

The cheese selection includes both mild and sharp varieties, as well as flavored options that add a kick to any dish. It’s all locally sourced or made in small batches, ensuring freshness and quality.

The bologna, meanwhile, is a throwback to a time when deli meat actually tasted like meat.

These are the kinds of ingredients that remind you what real food is supposed to taste like. There’s no filler, no artificial flavor, just honest-to-goodness quality.

Whether you’re making a sandwich for lunch or putting together a charcuterie board, the Amish bologna and cheese from Martin House are guaranteed to impress.

Handmade Soaps and Skincare That Smell Like a Garden

Beyond the food, Martin House carries a line of handmade soaps, shampoos, and skincare products that are as gentle as they are effective. Made with natural ingredients and essential oils, these products are free from the harsh chemicals found in most commercial brands.

The scents range from lavender and eucalyptus to citrus and mint.

Customers appreciate the quality and the fact that the products are made in small batches. The soaps lather well and leave skin feeling clean without being stripped.

The shampoos and conditioners are nourishing and work well for a variety of hair types. It’s skincare that feels good and does good.

The selection includes bar soaps, liquid soaps, lotions, and lip balms, so you can build a full routine if you want. The packaging is simple and eco-friendly, and the prices are reasonable for handmade goods.

Many people buy these as gifts, knowing they’re giving something thoughtful and useful.

There’s a growing movement toward natural skincare, and Martin House is part of it. These products are proof that you don’t need a long list of unpronounceable ingredients to take care of your skin.

Sometimes, simple is better, and these handmade goods deliver on that promise every time.

A Store That Feels Like Home from the Moment You Walk In

The atmosphere at Martin House is what keeps people coming back as much as the products themselves. Gospel bluegrass plays softly in the background, setting a tone that’s peaceful and uplifting.

The staff greets you by name if you’ve been there before, and even if you haven’t, they make you feel like a regular.

The layout is open and inviting, with wide aisles and displays that are easy to browse. Everything is clearly labeled, and the store is kept clean and organized.

There’s no pressure to buy, no hard sell, just a genuine invitation to look around and enjoy the experience.

Customers describe it as a warm and welcoming space, a place where you can slow down and take your time. The vibe is nostalgic without being kitschy, and it feels authentic in a way that’s hard to fake.

It’s the kind of store that reminds you what shopping used to be like before everything went online.

The staff is knowledgeable and happy to answer questions or make recommendations. They’re proud of what they sell, and it shows.

Martin House isn’t just a store. It’s a community gathering place, a spot where people connect and share a love for quality, homemade goods.

That sense of community is what makes it truly special.

Locally Sourced Honey in Every Size and Variety

Honey lovers will find plenty to explore at Martin House. The store carries locally sourced honey in a variety of sizes, from small jars perfect for trying a new flavor to large containers for those who use it daily.

The honey is raw and unfiltered, preserving all the natural enzymes and benefits.

The selection includes different floral varieties, each with its own unique flavor profile. Some are light and sweet, while others are darker and more robust.

Customers appreciate the quality and the fact that the honey comes from nearby beekeepers, supporting local agriculture and ensuring freshness.

Raw honey has a depth of flavor that processed honey simply can’t match. It’s thick, golden, and perfect for drizzling over toast, stirring into tea, or eating straight from the spoon.

Many people swear by local honey for its allergy-fighting properties, and the variety at Martin House makes it easy to find the right one.

The store takes pride in sourcing products from local producers whenever possible, and the honey is a perfect example of that commitment. It’s one more way Martin House supports the community while offering customers something they can’t find at the big chain stores.

Real honey from real bees, it doesn’t get much better than that.

Handmade Quilts That Are Works of Art

Tucked in one corner of the store, you’ll find a selection of handmade quilts that are as beautiful as they are functional. Each quilt is stitched by hand, featuring traditional patterns and vibrant colors that make them true works of art.

The craftsmanship is evident in every seam and every carefully chosen fabric.

Customers are often surprised by how affordable the quilts are, especially given the time and skill required to make them. These aren’t mass-produced blankets.

They’re heirloom-quality pieces that can be passed down through generations. The quilts are warm, durable, and made to be used, not just displayed.

The patterns range from classic patchwork to more intricate designs, and the colors are rich and eye-catching. Some are made in muted tones for a more traditional look, while others feature bold, modern combinations.

There’s a quilt for every style and every home.

Buying a handmade quilt is an investment in quality and tradition. It’s a reminder of a time when things were made to last, when craftsmanship mattered more than speed.

At Martin House, these quilts represent the best of that tradition, and they’re one more reason this store has become a beloved destination in Davis, Oklahoma. Address: 1775 US-77, Davis, Oklahoma.