Corn ice cream sounds like a dare. Queso ice cream sounds like somebody lost a bet.
Tamarindo sounds safer. Then the mango sorbet shows up wearing chamoy, Tajin, and a candy spoon, and suddenly the freezer case becomes the most interesting part of the afternoon.
This Indiana shop serves 32 handcrafted flavors, with combinations that go far beyond the usual chocolate and vanilla lineup.
The flavor list changes with the seasons, and sampling is encouraged, which is probably necessary when the options include things you may have never considered putting in a cone.
The story behind the shop is just as unusual. It started with a young local who used his own savings to turn a family idea into a real storefront.
A Teenager’s Savings Turned Into a Storefront
Most 18-year-olds spend their first savings on a car. Angel Benitez, known to everyone as Danny, spent his on a freezer case and a lease.
Fresh out of Avon High School in 2016, he opened the shop in Avon, Indiana, with money he had set aside himself. His uncle had worked making and distributing Vallarta Mexican popsicles, and that connection planted the idea early.
Rather than wait for the right moment, Danny built it.
The backstory matters once the ice cream arrives, because it explains the personality of the place. Nothing here feels corporate or carefully market-tested.
Flavors rotate because someone wanted to try making them. The counter is small, the vibe is unpolished in the best possible way, and family members are often part of the operation.
Hendricks County has plenty of chain dessert options along the highway. Choosing this one means the money stays with a local business that started as one young person’s very specific idea.
It also makes the whole visit more interesting to talk about afterward. Ice cream tastes better with a story attached, and this one is genuinely an American Dream narrative built in a strip of suburban Indianapolis.
Nearly a decade in, the shop remains a neighborhood fixture rather than a passing trend.
Thirty-Two Flavors and Almost None of Them Are Boring
The flavor board is the main event. More than thirty handcrafted options fill the case at any given time, split between rich Mexican-style ice creams and bright fruit sorbets.
Guanabana, tamarindo, guava, and pina colada sit on the fruit side, tasting closer to fresh produce than to syrup. Horchata brings cinnamon and rice sweetness into scoopable form.
Dulce de leche, avocado, coconut, and sweet cream round out the creamier end of the lineup.
Then come the ones that make first-timers pause. Corn tastes faintly like sweet summer kernels stirred into custard.
Queso is savory and tangy, and somehow it works. Mango chili adds heat on the finish, while seasonal rotations have included hot honey goat cheese and birthday cake.
Classic choices stay available too, which keeps the whole family happy. Chocolate, Oreo, cotton candy, cinnamon toast crunch, and banana pudding all have loyal followings among regulars.
Because the flavors change regularly, no two visits look identical. Something new usually appears, and favorites cycle back through.
Everything is made in-house, which is why the texture leans thicker and creamier than standard scoop shop ice cream. It also holds up better on a warm walk back to the car.
Plan on spending a few minutes reading the board before deciding. Rushing this part would be a mistake.
The Mangonada Is Worth Ordering Even If You Are Unsure
Ask what the signature order is, and the answer keeps coming back to one layered cup. The mangonada is built rather than scooped.
Mango sorbet forms the base, then fresh mango pieces get tucked in between layers. Chamoy sauce runs down the sides in bright red streaks, Tajin seasoning dusts the top, and a tamarind candy stick stands upright like a straw.
The result hits sweet, sour, salty, and spicy all at once. First-timers often expect the chili to overwhelm everything.
It does not. The mango stays front and center while the chamoy and Tajin add a tangy edge that keeps the whole thing from feeling heavy.
Eating one is part of the fun. The candy stick softens as it sits in the sorbet, and biting it releases another wave of sour tamarind flavor.
Warm Indiana afternoons are the ideal setting for this order. It refreshes in a way a plain cone cannot quite match.
For anyone who has never tried the sweet-and-spicy fruit combination common across Mexico, this is a gentle and delicious introduction. Kids who like sour candy usually love it immediately.
Share one if the full size seems like a lot. Splitting also leaves room to sample something else from the case.
Samples Before Commitment, Which Changes Everything
Nobody should have to gamble a whole scoop on queso ice cream sight unseen. Staff here hand out tasting spoons freely, and that generosity is a big part of why people keep returning.
Visitors regularly mention working their way through several samples before settling on an order. Curiosity gets rewarded instead of judged.
The sampling habit also solves the biggest challenge of a thirty-plus flavor board. Reading descriptions only goes so far when the options include corn and goat cheese.
One small spoonful tells the whole story. Suddenly the unusual choices feel approachable rather than risky.
Employees often have opinions worth listening to, and they tend to steer newcomers toward flavors that surprise people in a good way. Blackberry with cheese has converted plenty of skeptics.
Bring kids and the sampling becomes entertainment. Watching a seven-year-old react to savory ice cream is its own small show.
A practical tip for busy evenings is to have a backup plan in mind. Weekend nights can bring a line, so narrow the field to three or four contenders before reaching the counter.
Arriving shortly after opening gives more breathing room. Doors open at 1:30 PM most weekdays and 1 PM on weekends, so early afternoon visits are the calmest.
Churro Sundaes Built Like a Small Architectural Project
There is a reason the churro sundae comes up in conversation more than almost anything else on the menu. It arrives looking like dessert designed by someone who refuses to hold back.
Two scoops of any chosen flavors go into a cup lined with caramel or chocolate sauce. Churros get layered between the scoops and stacked on top, then whipped cream finishes the whole structure.
The churros themselves are soft, chewy, and rolled in cinnamon sugar. Fresh and light rather than dense, they soak up just enough sauce to turn slightly gooey without going soggy.
Flavor pairings are where the creativity comes in. Horchata with dulce de leche leans warm and cinnamon-forward, while horchata with cinnamon toast crunch doubles down on the same idea.
Bolder combinations exist too. Queso paired with avocado sounds strange written down and tastes surprisingly balanced in practice.
Portion size is substantial enough that two people can comfortably share one. Ordering a sundae each usually means someone surrenders halfway through.
Pints offer another smart move for groups or for taking flavors home. A single pint can be filled with three different choices, which settles a lot of arguments.
Consider it the order for a celebration visit rather than a quick cone stop.
Creamier Texture That Behaves Better on a Hot Day
Texture is the quiet reason this ice cream sticks in people’s memory. Mexican-style ice cream runs thicker and denser than most American scoop shop versions, and the difference shows up in the very first bite.
Scoops hold their shape longer, which matters when the walk to the car crosses a sun-baked parking lot. Cones survive the trip without turning into a sticky emergency.
Made in-house with an emphasis on fresh, natural ingredients, the base carries flavor in a fuller way. Fruit sorbets in particular taste vivid rather than watery.
Guava and mango come through with real tartness. Coconut reads like actual coconut instead of suntan lotion.
Creaminess also means a single scoop satisfies more than expected. Generous portions combined with that richness make double scoops a genuine commitment.
Waffle cones are available, including chocolate versions, and they pair especially well with the denser flavors. Cups make more sense for anyone planning to add toppings.
Popsicles round out the offerings for people who want something lighter and more portable. The paleta tradition traces straight back to the family connection that inspired the shop in the first place.
On a humid Indiana July evening, that sturdier texture turns out to be a practical advantage rather than just a technical detail.
An Easy Detour Off Highway 36 With Late Evening Hours
Location works in this shop’s favor. Sitting right along US Highway 36 in Avon, it slots neatly into a day spent exploring Hendricks County without requiring a special trip across town.
The address is 7730 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN 46123, roughly a twenty-minute drive west of downtown Indianapolis. Parking is straightforward, and the stop takes as long or as little as desired.
Hours lean late, which is unusual and useful. Most weekdays run 1:30 PM to 9 PM, with Friday and Saturday stretching from 1 PM until 9:30 PM and Sunday closing at 9 PM.
That means ice cream after a movie, after a ballgame, or after a long drive home still works. Summer evenings are when the shop feels liveliest.
The space itself is modest and unfussy. No marble counters or curated playlists, just a bright case, a short counter, and a steady flow of families and neighbors.
Regulars treat it as a routine treat stop rather than a destination splurge. Newcomers tend to leave already planning which flavor to try next time.
Pair the visit with a stop at nearby parks or a walk through Avon before heading out. Ice cream first is also a perfectly acceptable strategy.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
