I almost skipped this stop because it sounded too random to be real. An Amish cheese shop in Montgomery, Texas did not exactly line up with my expectations of a Texas food run.
Then I walked into Slice of Amish and immediately knew I had been wrong. The place smells like fresh cheese and sweet preserves, everything feels unhurried, and suddenly you are sampling things you did not plan on buying but absolutely are taking home.
It feels less like a store and more like stepping into someone’s pantry where everything was made with intention. Slice of Amish has a way of resetting your standards fast.
Stick around, because what people drive across Texas for here might surprise you even more than the shop itself.
An Unexpected Cheese Paradise in Small Town Texas
Finding authentic cheese curds in Texas feels about as likely as stumbling upon snow in July. Yet here they are, sitting in the cooler at Slice of Amish, squeaky fresh and tasting exactly like the ones you’d find in Wisconsin dairy country.
The shop carries an impressive variety of cheeses that would make any cheese lover weak in the knees, from sharp white cheddar to more adventurous options like scorpion cheddar and horseradish varieties. What sets this place apart isn’t just the selection but the willingness to let you sample before you buy.
The staff knows their products inside and out, offering tastes of different cheeses and explaining the subtle differences between each one. You might walk in thinking you know what you want and leave with something completely different after discovering a new favorite through sampling.
The cheese selection goes beyond what you’d find in any regular grocery store. There’s blueberry cheddar that sounds strange until you taste it and realize the sweet-savory combination actually works beautifully.
Amish butter cheese offers a creamy richness that transforms any sandwich or cheese board. Whether you’re planning a party or just want to elevate your weeknight dinner, the quality here makes the drive worthwhile every single time.
Homemade Preserves That Taste Like Grandma’s Kitchen
The preserves section at Slice of Amish looks like something straight out of a country farmhouse pantry. Rows of glass jars line the shelves, each one filled with jewel-toned jams and jellies made from scratch.
These aren’t mass-produced spreads with endless preservatives and artificial flavors. They’re the real deal, made the old-fashioned way with fruit, sugar, and time.
Walking past the display, you’ll find classic flavors like strawberry and blueberry sitting alongside more unique options that showcase seasonal fruits and creative combinations. The jams have that perfect texture where you can still see pieces of fruit, and the flavor is bright and true to what’s written on the label.
Spreading one of these preserves on warm bread or biscuits transforms a simple breakfast into something memorable. Many customers make regular trips just to stock up on their favorite jams, knowing they won’t find this quality anywhere else in the area.
The preserves also make excellent gifts for anyone who appreciates handcrafted food. Once you taste the difference between these and store-bought versions, there’s really no going back to what you used to consider acceptable jam.
Fresh Amish Butter That Changes Everything
Butter might seem like a basic staple, but Amish butter operates on an entirely different level. The moment you spread it on bread, you notice the difference in color, a deeper yellow that hints at its richness.
Then comes the taste, creamy and full-flavored in a way that makes regular butter seem watery and bland by comparison. This isn’t butter churned in massive industrial facilities with milk from hundreds of different farms.
Amish butter comes from smaller-scale operations where traditional methods still matter. The cream is handled differently, cultured in many cases, which gives it a subtle tanginess that enhances rather than overpowers.
Using it for cooking elevates simple dishes, whether you’re making scrambled eggs, sautéing vegetables, or baking cookies. Customers who discover Amish butter at Slice of Amish often become devoted fans, unwilling to settle for conventional options once they know what they’ve been missing.
It’s one of those products that seems indulgent but actually represents how butter should taste when it’s made right. Keep it refrigerated and use it generously, because food this good deserves to be enjoyed without hesitation or guilt about choosing quality over convenience.
Weekend Grilled Cheese That Draws a Crowd
On weekends, something magical happens at Slice of Amish. The shop starts serving grilled cheese sandwiches that have become somewhat legendary among locals and visitors alike.
These aren’t your average grilled cheese made with whatever cheese happens to be on hand. You get to choose from their impressive selection of cheeses, customizing your sandwich with varieties like sharp cheddar, blueberry cheddar, or any other option that catches your fancy.
The sandwiches come out hot with perfectly crispy, buttered bread that gives way to gloriously melted cheese inside. Some weekends they also offer Reuben sandwiches for those wanting something beyond the classic grilled cheese experience.
The combination of quality ingredients and simple preparation creates something far better than you’d expect from such a straightforward dish. People plan their Montgomery visits around these weekend lunch offerings, knowing that fresh grilled cheese paired with browsing the shop’s other products makes for a perfect afternoon outing.
The limited availability adds to the appeal, turning a simple sandwich into a special treat worth anticipating. Grab one while you’re there and enjoy it while exploring downtown Montgomery’s other charming shops and historic buildings.
Ice Cream That Cleanses Your Palate Between Tastings
After sampling multiple cheeses, your palate might need a little reset. That’s where the ice cream comes in, served in generous scoops that provide a sweet contrast to all the savory cheese tasting.
One regular customer swears it’s essential for cleansing the palate between cheese samples, though that might just be a convenient excuse to enjoy dessert in the middle of a shopping trip.
The ice cream selection offers classic flavors that everyone loves, perfect for kids who might not be as excited about cheese as their parents.
It’s creamy and satisfying, the kind of ice cream that reminds you why simple flavors done well never go out of style. Families often make it part of their Slice of Amish ritual, with parents browsing cheeses while children eagerly anticipate their ice cream reward.
Having ice cream available transforms the shop from just a place to buy groceries into more of an experience destination. You can take your time exploring products, sampling cheeses, and treating yourself to something sweet without having to leave and find another spot for dessert.
It’s these thoughtful touches that turn a quick errand into an enjoyable outing worth repeating whenever you’re in the area.
Specialty Coffees and Teas for Every Morning Mood
The coffee and tea selection at Slice of Amish offers more variety than you’d expect from a shop primarily known for cheese. Flavored coffees line the shelves alongside classic roasts, each one promising to transform your morning routine.
Whether you prefer something bold and straightforward or a flavored blend that adds a little excitement to your cup, you’ll find options that appeal to your particular coffee preferences.
Tea drinkers aren’t overlooked either, with a selection of loose teas and tea bags covering everything from traditional black teas to herbal blends perfect for winding down in the evening.
The quality matches what you’d find at dedicated tea and coffee shops, but with the convenience of picking some up while you’re already shopping for cheese and other pantry staples.
Many customers discover these beverages almost by accident, coming in for cheese and noticing the coffee selection on their way out.
Once they try it at home, they add it to their regular shopping list for future visits. Starting your day with quality coffee or tea sets a better tone than settling for whatever’s cheapest at the grocery store, and having good options available at Slice of Amish makes it easy to upgrade your daily routine.
Pickled Goods and Condiments That Add Punch to Any Meal
Tucked among the cheeses and preserves, you’ll find an impressive array of pickled goods that add serious flavor to sandwiches, burgers, and cheese boards. These aren’t boring dill pickles pulled from a mass-produced barrel.
The pickled vegetables here offer variety and quality that makes you reconsider what pickles can be when they’re made with care and creativity. The shop carries various pickled items that go beyond cucumbers, including options that bring tang, crunch, and complexity to your meals.
Condiments and specialty dips round out the selection, giving you everything needed to build an impressive appetizer spread or add interest to everyday meals. The dip mixes are particularly popular, requiring just a simple combination with sour cream or cream cheese to create something guests will ask about.
These supporting players might not get as much attention as the cheese, but they’re essential for anyone who enjoys cooking or entertaining. A jar of quality pickles or a unique relish can completely transform a sandwich from ordinary to outstanding.
Stock up on a few different varieties and keep them in your refrigerator for those moments when you need to add something special to a meal without much effort or planning.
Personal Service That Makes You Feel Like a Regular
What truly sets Slice of Amish apart from larger grocery stores or impersonal shopping experiences is the level of service you receive. The staff genuinely wants you to find products you’ll love, not just make a quick sale.
They offer samples freely, explain the characteristics of different cheeses, and make recommendations based on what you’re planning to make or who you’re shopping for. First-time visitors often comment on how welcomed they feel, even when the shop is busy.
The owners and staff have built a business on relationships and repeat customers rather than one-time transactions.
They remember faces, recall previous purchases, and treat everyone with the kind of friendliness that’s becoming rare in retail environments dominated by self-checkout lanes and minimal human interaction.
This personal touch extends to special orders and party planning, where the staff will help you select the right combination of cheeses and accompaniments for your event.
They understand their products deeply and share that knowledge generously, making every visit feel like you’re shopping with a knowledgeable friend rather than a stranger behind a counter. It’s the kind of service that keeps people coming back even when other options might be more convenient.
Address: 401 College St Suite 170, Montgomery, TX 77356
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
