Tucked away in the heart of Middlebury, Indiana, sits a bakery that has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and travelers alike. Rise’n Roll Bakery & Deli started as a humble shed in someone’s front yard and has blossomed into a beloved destination known far and wide for its heavenly baked goods. The establishment is located at 1065 N US Highway 20, Middlebury, IN 46123.
With a 4.8-star rating from over 2,300 reviews, this tiny donut shop has earned its reputation as one of the best bakeries in the Midwest. The aroma of freshly baked cinnamon caramel donuts greets you the moment you walk through the door.
Whether you’re passing through Amish country or planning a special trip just for the donuts, Rise’n Roll delivers an experience worth traveling for. People drive hours just to get their hands on these treats, and once you taste them, you’ll understand why.
The Famous Cinnamon Caramel Donuts Are Absolutely Addictive
Picture biting into a cloud of pillowy soft dough that practically melts on your tongue. That’s exactly what happens when you try Rise’n Roll’s signature cinnamon caramel donuts.
These aren’t your average grocery store donuts covered in generic glaze. Each one is dusted with a magical combination of cinnamon and caramel that creates a flavor profile so perfect, customers use words like “addictive” and “obsessed” to describe them.
The secret lies in the freshness and quality of ingredients. Every donut is made from scratch daily, ensuring that soft, airy texture that makes them stand out from the competition.
The cinnamon caramel coating isn’t too sweet or overpowering. Instead, it strikes that perfect balance where you can taste both the warm spice of cinnamon and the rich butterscotch notes of caramel working together in harmony.
Customer reviews consistently mention these donuts as life-changing experiences. One visitor drove several hours just to get them again after their first taste.
Another rated the cinnamon caramel Bavarian a perfect 20 out of 10. The popularity is so intense that the bakery recommends calling ahead to reserve your box because they frequently sell out before closing time at 4 PM.
What makes these donuts truly special is how they’ve become a regional treasure.
Free Samples Let You Taste Before You Buy
Walking into Rise’n Roll Bakery feels like stepping into a wonderland of sweet possibilities, and the best part is you don’t have to guess which treats to try. Throughout the store, you’ll find little sample stations offering bite-sized tastes of various products.
This generous approach to customer service sets Rise’n Roll apart from typical bakeries where you’re expected to buy blind and hope for the best.
First-time visitors especially appreciate this thoughtful touch. Imagine standing in front of a display case filled with dozens of different donut varieties, cookies, and pastries, feeling overwhelmed by choices.
The free samples solve this problem beautifully. You can try a donut hole with that famous cinnamon caramel coating, taste a piece of cashew crunch, or sample some of their homemade jams before committing to full-sized purchases.
The sampling strategy also introduces customers to products they might not have considered otherwise. Maybe you came specifically for donuts but discovered their incredible cashew crunch brittle through a sample.
One reviewer described it as the best they’d ever tasted, with just the right amount of hardness and a satisfying crunch that delivered crispy, buttery goodness in every bite.
This approach shows confidence in their products. Rise’n Roll knows that once you taste their baked goods, you’ll want to buy them.
The samples aren’t stingy either. They’re substantial enough to give you a real sense of flavor and texture.
Beyond Donuts: Incredible Variety of Baked Goods
While the donuts steal most of the spotlight, Rise’n Roll Bakery offers an impressive array of other baked treasures that deserve equal attention. Step past the donut display and you’ll discover cinnamon rolls that rival the donuts in popularity, pies that have earned their own loyal following, and cookies that customers rave about in reviews.
This isn’t a one-trick bakery coasting on donut fame alone.
The mocha cinnamon rolls and pecan sticky buns receive particularly enthusiastic praise from visitors. These pastries are substantial, generously sized, and packed with flavor.
The pecan sticky buns feature that same attention to quality ingredients and perfect texture that makes the donuts famous. They’re gooey without being messy, sweet without being cloying, and the pecans add a delightful crunch that contrasts beautifully with the soft dough.
Fruit pizzas offer a creative twist on traditional bakery offerings. These treats combine a cookie-like crust with cream cheese frosting and fresh fruit toppings, creating something that’s part dessert, part artwork.
Pies come in various flavors including classic peach, and while one reviewer noted inconsistency in retail distribution, the pies sold directly from the Middlebury location maintain the high quality standards the bakery is known for.
Don’t overlook the cookies either. They’re baked fresh daily and come in multiple varieties to satisfy different cravings.
Delicious Deli Options for a Complete Meal
Rise’n Roll isn’t just about satisfying your sweet tooth. The deli side of the operation serves up hearty, delicious meals that make this bakery a perfect stop for breakfast or lunch.
Customers consistently praise the food quality, with items like biscuits and gravy, egg biscuits, and various sandwiches earning high marks in reviews. This dual nature means you can enjoy a proper meal before indulging in dessert, all under one roof.
The biscuits and gravy stand out as a customer favorite. Made with flaky, buttery biscuits and rich, savory gravy, this classic comfort food dish gets executed perfectly at Rise’n Roll.
One visitor from Idaho was so impressed they said it would be worth the long trip back just for this dish alone. The egg biscuits offer another satisfying breakfast option, described as very delicious and filling by those who’ve tried them.
Lunch options include sandwiches like sloppy joes and chicken clubs served as combo meals with sides and drinks. The portions are generous and the quality matches what you’d expect from a place that takes pride in everything they make.
While one reviewer noted that buying items separately might sometimes be more economical than combo deals, the convenience and quality still make the deli offerings worthwhile.
The deli menu provides practical value for travelers passing through Middlebury. Instead of stopping at a fast food chain and then hunting for dessert elsewhere, you can get everything in one visit.
Families appreciate this convenience, especially when traveling with kids who need real food before loading up on sweets.
Authentic Amish Country Experience and Local Products
Visiting Rise’n Roll connects you to the rich traditions of Indiana’s Amish country in a genuine and meaningful way. The bakery’s origin story itself reflects this heritage, starting as a small shed operation and growing through hard work and dedication to quality.
This isn’t a corporate chain trying to capitalize on Amish themes. It’s a real business rooted in the community and values that make this region special.
Throughout the store, you’ll find jarred Amish goods that showcase local craftsmanship and traditional recipes. Homemade jams in flavors like black raspberry offer tastes you won’t find in typical grocery stores.
These preserves are made with real fruit and traditional methods, resulting in intense flavors that remind you of simpler times. Customers often stock up on multiple jars to bring home or give as gifts to friends and family.
The applesauce, flavored popcorn, and other specialty items available at Rise’n Roll represent the broader Amish community’s commitment to quality food products. These aren’t mass-produced items with long lists of unpronounceable ingredients.
They’re made with care using recipes passed down through generations, emphasizing natural flavors and quality over convenience and shelf life. Shopping here supports local producers and keeps traditional food crafts alive.
Even practical details reflect the Amish connection. The bakery provides a place to tie up horses for Amish customers who arrive by buggy, a charming reminder that this business serves its local community first.
The parking lot accommodates both cars and buggies, creating an interesting mix of old and new that defines modern Amish country.
Worth the Drive: A Destination Bakery
Some bakeries serve their immediate neighborhood. Rise’n Roll has become something bigger, a destination that draws people from across state lines and inspires road trips planned specifically around visiting.
Multiple reviews mention customers driving one, two, or even several hours just to get these donuts and baked goods. That level of dedication speaks volumes about the quality and uniqueness of what Rise’n Roll offers.
The bakery’s reputation has spread far beyond Middlebury through word of mouth and social media. Friends tell friends about these incredible donuts, and those friends plan weekend getaways to Amish country with Rise’n Roll as a must-visit stop.
One reviewer who tried the donuts while traveling admitted they’d seriously consider driving a few hours just for this bakery, even though they don’t live nearby. That’s not typical bakery behavior.
That’s destination-worthy food.
What makes a bakery worth such effort? It’s the combination of exceptional quality, unique flavors, and an experience you genuinely can’t replicate elsewhere.
Sure, your hometown probably has donut shops, but they don’t have these specific cinnamon caramel creations. They don’t have the same fresh-made-daily commitment or the variety of Amish country products.
Rise’n Roll offers something special enough to justify the drive, the planning, and the anticipation.
The bakery has even topped charts as having some of the best donuts in the entire United States according to various rankings and reviews. Being recognized at that level puts Rise’n Roll in rare company among American bakeries.
This isn’t just local pride talking. National attention has confirmed what regular customers have known for years: this place serves something extraordinary.
Exceptional Service and Clean, Welcoming Atmosphere
Great food matters, but the overall experience determines whether customers become loyal fans or one-time visitors. Rise’n Roll excels in creating an atmosphere that makes people want to return.
From the moment you walk in, the cleanliness strikes you immediately. This isn’t a cluttered, chaotic bakery with flour dust everywhere.
Everything is organized, well-maintained, and spotlessly clean, which matters tremendously when you’re buying food.
The staff receives consistent praise across hundreds of reviews for being extremely friendly and helpful. They don’t just take orders and move you along.
Cashiers offer suggestions, answer questions about products, and genuinely seem happy to help you find exactly what you’re looking for. This friendliness isn’t forced or scripted.
It feels authentic, like the employees take pride in their workplace and enjoy sharing it with customers.
Even during busy periods, which happen frequently given the bakery’s popularity, the staff manages to keep things moving efficiently. One customer mentioned arriving when it was really busy but noted it didn’t take long to get through the line.
That kind of operational efficiency combined with maintained friendliness shows good training and management. Nobody wants to stand in a long, slow-moving line, especially when delicious donuts are so close yet so far.
The interior design balances functionality with charm. Handmade benches and chairs provide comfortable seating areas where you can relax and enjoy your purchases.
The layout allows easy browsing of all the different product sections without feeling cramped or overwhelmed.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
