This Tiny Indiana General Store Hides a 10-Pound Pizza Locals Call the Best in the State

One pizza at this little shop weighs 10 pounds. It carries six meats and seven vegetables, which sounds less like dinner and more like a weightlifting plan.

The pizza counter sits in the back of an old-school general store. Up front, you can still grab milk, bread, and eggs like it’s a normal errand day.

I have a soft spot for businesses that serve as the heart of a small town rather than just another place to grab a meal. This one serves an Indiana community of only a few hundred people.

It also beat a crowd of rivals to earn a best pizza title from an Indianapolis TV station.

I’d be curious to see how anyone manages to finish a 10-pound pizza, let alone carry one out the door. A store where you can buy eggs in the morning and pick up a pizza that evening?

That’s quite a combination.

You Will Need Both Arms For The Around The World Pizza

You Will Need Both Arms For The Around The World Pizza
© Amo Pizza & General Store

Ten pounds. That’s the weight of the Around the World pizza at Amo Pizza & General Store, and it’s the reason many people first hear about this place.

The topping list reads like a group project where everyone said yes. This pizza carries six different meats and seven different vegetables.

That combination is what pushes it to such a heavy number. A regular pizza box suddenly feels like it has a job to do.

For a sense of scale, 10 pounds is about the weight of a big bag of potatoes. Now picture that bag covered in cheese and sausage.

I believe this is a pizza best saved for a crowd. Family nights, game days, and team parties all make sense here.

Ordering one for two people is possible, of course. Just plan on cold pizza for breakfast, maybe for a couple of days.

The pizza also shows what this shop does best. It doesn’t try to be fancy or trendy with tiny portions.

Instead, it leans into big, generous, hometown-style food. That approach fits a little Indiana general store perfectly.

So if you go only once, this is the order to talk about later. Your arms will remember the trip to the car too.

A Tiny Town Shop Took Home A Big-City Pizza Title

A Tiny Town Shop Took Home A Big-City Pizza Title
© Amo Pizza & General Store

Winning a pizza contest against Indianapolis is a bold move for a town this small. Amo Pizza & General Store pulled it off anyway.

The shop earned the title of Indy’s Best Pizza through a contest featured on Fox 59. That’s a big win for a place with only a few tables.

It didn’t stop there either. The shop also won a Pizza Playoffs promotion in Hendricks County.

That bracket pitted it against 16 other local pizza places. Plenty of those spots sit in much bigger towns with much bigger buildings.

I love a good underdog story, and this one checks every box. A general store pizza counter beating the competition feels like a sports movie with pepperoni.

The title in the headline comes from moments like these. Wins like that turn a small shop into a road-trip stop.

The TV attention brought new faces from around central Indiana. Some drove past several other pizza shops just to see what the fuss was about.

That’s quite a compliment in a state full of pizza options. Still, the best part is that the shop stayed small and familiar after the spotlight.

Awards come and go. A place that keeps its hometown feel is harder to find.

Grab Some Eggs, Then Order A Pizza Out Back

Grab Some Eggs, Then Order A Pizza Out Back
© Amo Pizza & General Store in Amo, Indiana, 4964 N Pearl St, Amo, IN 46103

Most pizza places don’t sell a carton of milk. This one does, and that’s half the charm.

Amo Pizza & General Store works as two businesses under one roof. It’s a working general store and a pizza shop at the same time.

Everyday basics like milk, bread, and eggs are usually on hand. That makes it handy for folks in a town with few other shopping choices.

The space has an old-school convenience store feel. Think simple shelves and a casual, come-as-you-are mood rather than polished decor.

I like that the store side hasn’t been pushed aside. It still plays a real role in daily life for the neighborhood.

In a town of roughly 400 to 450 people, a place like this matters. It becomes the spot where errands and dinner plans meet.

The building itself is a classic small-town general store. Nothing about it shouts that award-winning pizza is waiting inside.

That quiet setup makes the first visit more fun. You come for a 10-pound pizza and leave with bread for tomorrow’s sandwiches too.

Honestly, it’s the most efficient grocery run in Indiana. Pizza and eggs, one stop, zero regrets.

Snag One Of The Few Tables Or Plan To Carry Out

Snag One Of The Few Tables Or Plan To Carry Out
© Amo Pizza & General Store

Seating here is cozy in the most literal way. The pizza shop sits in the back of the general store, with just a few tables for dining in.

That small setup shapes the whole visit. Most people order their food to go, though eating on site is an option.

Tables work on a first-come, first-served basis. During busy dinner hours, seats can fill up because the room is shared with the store.

My advice is simple. If you want to eat there, aim for lunch or an off-peak time.

Weekend evenings tend to get busier, especially around dinner. A call-ahead carry-out order is the easy move on those nights.

The mood inside feels relaxed and neighborly. It’s the kind of place where muddy boots and Sunday clothes both fit right in.

I like that the back counter keeps things personal. You’re close to the kitchen, not hidden away in a giant dining hall.

Families with kids will find it easygoing and unfussy. Just keep your group size reasonable if you hope to sit together.

And if every table is taken, don’t worry. A pizza that big makes any picnic table or kitchen counter feel like a party.

Three Decades Of Pizza In One Small-Town Storefront

Three Decades Of Pizza In One Small-Town Storefront
© Amo Pizza & General Store in Amo, Indiana, 4964 N Pearl St, Amo, IN 46103

Back in 1994, this little shop started serving pizza in Amo. That gives it about three decades of history in the same small town.

Plenty of restaurants open and close within a few years. Lasting this long in a town of a few hundred people says a lot.

Today, Amo Pizza & General Store is owned by Mark and Gina Wicks. They took over around 2018, keeping the family-owned spirit going.

New owners can change a place a lot. Here, the couple kept the general store and pizza combo that folks already loved.

Gina’s name pops up often in the shop’s replies to customers. That hands-on style matches the feel of a true family business.

I believe that personal touch is part of why the place still works. People know who runs it, and that builds trust over time.

The award wins came under the current owners too. It’s a nice reminder that old places can still grow and get better.

Long-running shops carry a town’s memories. Birthdays, ball games, and Friday nights likely ended with a pizza from here for years.

That kind of history can’t be built overnight. It takes decades of showing up and turning on the oven.

Save Room For Breadsticks That Act Like A Pizza

Save Room For Breadsticks That Act Like A Pizza
© Amo Pizza & General Store

Breadsticks usually play a supporting role. At this shop, the ultimate breadsticks try very hard to steal the show.

They come topped with mozzarella, cheddar, pepperoni, and sausage. So yes, they’re basically a pizza pretending to be a side dish.

Breadsticks are among the most talked-about items here. That’s impressive when a 10-pound pizza is sitting on the same menu.

Bosco sticks are another fun pick. They’re stuffed with cheese, then topped with pepperoni and mozzarella for good measure.

Sandwich fans have options as well. Subs include chicken bacon ranch and a classic ham and cheese.

Then there’s the super stromboli, which is loaded with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Pizza sauce and cheese pull it all together.

Wings show up on the menu too, including a BBQ option. Pair them with a pizza and you’ve got a full spread for movie night.

I’d suggest ordering one side to share at first. The portions here lean generous, and your table space might be limited.

Of course, nobody will judge a second order of breadsticks. Some cravings simply deserve a sequel.

Breakfast Pizza And Coffee Start Early Here

Breakfast Pizza And Coffee Start Early Here
© Amo Pizza & General Store in Amo, Indiana, 4964 N Pearl St, Amo, IN 46103

Early birds get a better deal than worms in Amo. The general store side usually opens around 7 AM on weekdays.

Breakfast pizza is part of the lineup too. That’s a strong case for skipping cereal at least once a week.

Weekend hours shift a bit later, so plan ahead. Friday and Saturday nights also run later than the rest of the week.

Right next door, the same owners run The Cup and the Cone. It opens very early, around 5 AM, for breakfast and coffee.

That neighbor spot also serves ice cream. So one corner of town can handle your coffee, your pizza, and your dessert.

I can’t think of many tiny towns with that kind of all-day lineup. Most places this size are happy to have one diner.

Gourmet coffee pairs nicely with an early drive through the countryside. Ice cream works better on the way home after a pizza feast.

A smart plan is to visit The Cup and the Cone after dinner. Even a full stomach usually finds space for a cone.

Yes, that counts as a balanced meal. Pizza, ice cream, and a little sunshine cover most of the important food groups.

Gluten-Free And Low-Carb Eaters Get A Seat At The Table

Gluten-Free And Low-Carb Eaters Get A Seat At The Table
© Amo Pizza & General Store

Special diets can make pizza night tricky. This shop makes it a little easier for more people to join the fun.

Gluten-free crust is available here. One out-of-state family even ordered a gluten-free version of the Around the World pizza.

That means the famous 10-pound pie doesn’t have to leave anyone out. It’s a thoughtful touch for a small-town kitchen.

There’s also a crustless pizza option. It’s a good fit for folks following a keto or low-carb eating plan.

I like that these choices exist in such a small place. Big chains often get credit for options that hometown shops quietly offer too.

Gluten-free crusts usually have a different texture than regular dough. If you’re new to them, go in curious and open-minded.

For anyone with serious allergies, it’s always wise to ask questions when ordering. The staff can explain how they handle special requests.

Mixed groups benefit the most from this flexibility. One person can grab the loaded classic while another goes crustless.

Nobody has to sit out with a sad side salad. Everyone gets pizza, which is exactly how it should be.

Plan A Back-Roads Drive Into Hendricks County

Plan A Back-Roads Drive Into Hendricks County
© Amo Pizza & General Store in Amo, Indiana, 4964 N Pearl St, Amo, IN 46103

Getting there is part of the adventure. Amo Pizza & General Store sits at 4964 N Pearl St, Amo, IN 46103.

That puts it right in the heart of tiny downtown Amo. The town sits in Hendricks County, west of Indianapolis.

With only about 400 to 450 residents, Amo is wonderfully small. You won’t need a map app to find the main street once you arrive.

Drivers from Avon and other nearby towns make the trip for pizza. It’s an easy country drive for anyone around central Indiana.

I believe the best visits mix food with a slow drive. Roll down the windows and enjoy the farm views on the way in.

Hours run from morning into the evening most days. Friday and Saturday stay open later, which helps if you’re coming from farther away.

Calling ahead for big orders makes life easier. A 10-pound pizza is worth a little planning.

Bring a sturdy spot in your car for the boxes too. Nobody wants a sliding pizza on a curvy road.

Small towns like Amo remind us that great food can live anywhere. Sometimes it just lives behind the bread aisle.