I never thought I’d find a seafood spot in the middle of Indiana that could rival coastal favorites, but Slapfish on Massachusetts Avenue proved me completely wrong. Walking past this place dozens of times, I finally stepped inside and discovered what locals have been raving about for years.
From the first glance at the menu, it’s clear they take their sourcing seriously, bringing in fresh catches that don’t feel like an afterthought this far from the ocean.
It’s not fancy or pretentious, just honest-to-goodness seafood served in a bright, welcoming space that feels more California casual than Midwest traditional.
The laid-back vibe makes it easy to settle in, whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or lingering over a basket of fish and chips with friends.
Lobster Rolls That Rival New England’s Best
Forget everything you thought you knew about finding authentic lobster rolls in landlocked Indiana. The lobster roll at Slapfish stands as proof that geography doesn’t determine quality when a restaurant commits to sourcing the freshest ingredients.
Packed with generous chunks of tender lobster meat and served on a perfectly grilled, buttery roll, this signature dish has converted skeptics and satisfied East Coast transplants alike.
What makes these rolls exceptional is the sheer amount of lobster you get for the price. Many customers mention being shocked at how much meat gets stuffed into each sandwich, making the cost feel more than reasonable.
The bread gets toasted to golden perfection on the outside while staying soft enough to hold all that sweet lobster without falling apart.
One lifelong Hoosier spent years searching Indianapolis for a great lobster roll during his quest to replicate vacation favorites. He finally found it here and now considers Slapfish his go-to spot.
The restaurant’s commitment to quality means you’re getting lobster that tastes like it came straight from a Maine fishing dock, not from a freezer bag that’s been sitting around for months.
Whether you prefer yours warm with butter or cold with mayo, the lobster roll alone justifies the trip downtown. It’s become the benchmark other Indiana seafood spots try to match but rarely equal.
Fresh Oysters at Unbeatable Prices
Finding fresh, quality oysters in the Midwest sounds like an impossible task, but Slapfish makes it happen every single day. Their oyster selection brings a taste of both coasts directly to Massachusetts Avenue, with varieties that arrive fresh and get shucked right in front of you.
The restaurant has built a loyal following around their oyster offerings, particularly their special promotions that make trying different varieties accessible to everyone.
What sets these oysters apart is how incredibly fresh they taste. Visitors from Las Vegas and other coastal cities have praised them as being just as good as what they’d find back home.
The oysters come served with traditional accompaniments, but Slapfish adds their own twist with horseradish and cocktail sauce that complement the briny sweetness perfectly.
The counter-service format means you can watch your oysters being prepared, adding to the experience. Staff members are knowledgeable about the different varieties available and happy to make recommendations based on your taste preferences.
Whether you’re an oyster aficionado or trying them for the first time, the team makes sure you feel comfortable with your selection.
Regular customers time their visits around oyster specials, making it a weekly tradition. The combination of freshness, variety, and value has turned casual diners into devoted oyster enthusiasts who wouldn’t dream of going anywhere else in Indianapolis for their shellfish fix.
Clobster Grilled Cheese That Defies Expectations
Some menu items sound too indulgent to be real, and the Clobster Grilled Cheese falls firmly into that category. This creation combines two beloved comfort foods into one unforgettable sandwich that customers describe as requiring a nap afterward.
Chunks of lobster and crab get mixed with gooey melted cheese between perfectly grilled bread, creating something that feels both luxurious and satisfyingly familiar.
The genius of this dish lies in how it balances richness with flavor. You’re getting premium seafood in a format that feels approachable and fun rather than stuffy or pretentious.
One reviewer noted her husband ordered it while she chose a lighter option, giving them the best of both worlds during their meal. The sandwich arrives hot off the grill with cheese still bubbling and seafood perfectly distributed throughout.
What makes it work is the quality of ingredients combined with expert preparation. The bread gets buttered and grilled until it achieves that perfect golden crispness that gives way to the creamy, seafood-packed interior.
It’s messy in the best possible way, the kind of sandwich that requires napkins and zero regrets.
This isn’t your childhood grilled cheese, but it carries that same sense of comfort and satisfaction. It’s become a signature item that showcases Slapfish’s ability to take familiar concepts and elevate them with fresh, quality seafood that transforms something simple into something memorable.
Chowder That Warms the Indiana Soul
Nothing beats a bowl of properly made chowder, and Slapfish delivers one that customers consistently praise as phenomenal. Their clam chowder arrives steaming hot, loaded with seafood, and topped with crispy bacon and fresh chives that add texture and flavor to every spoonful.
The seasoning hits that perfect balance where you taste the ocean without being overwhelmed by salt or cream.
Couples often split a bowl to start their meal, finding it sets the perfect tone for what’s to come. The chowder is hearty enough to satisfy but not so heavy that it ruins your appetite for the main course.
Each spoonful delivers tender clams and potatoes in a creamy base that tastes like it’s been simmering all day, even though everything at Slapfish is made fresh.
The bacon topping deserves special mention because it adds a smoky crunch that contrasts beautifully with the smooth, rich soup. Fresh chives bring a subtle onion flavor that brightens the whole bowl.
It’s the kind of attention to detail that separates good chowder from great chowder.
On a chilly Indiana day, this bowl provides the same comfort you’d find in a New England seaside restaurant. The portion size is generous enough to share or enjoy as a meal on its own.
Regular customers know to order it regardless of season because quality chowder never goes out of style, especially when it’s made this well.
Fast Casual Format With Fine Dining Quality
Slapfish operates on a counter-service model that might surprise first-time visitors expecting traditional table service. You order at the counter, grab a number, and find your own seat while the team prepares your food and brings it out hot.
This format keeps prices reasonable while maintaining the quality you’d expect from a much pricier establishment.
The streamlined service means you’re not waiting around for servers to take orders or bring checks. You get your food quickly, which makes Slapfish perfect for lunch breaks, pre-event dinners, or casual meals when you’re hungry and don’t want to wait.
Despite the casual setup, the staff remains attentive and friendly, checking on tables and making sure everyone has what they need.
This approach also creates a more relaxed atmosphere where you can eat at your own pace without feeling rushed. The space itself is bright, clean, and colorful with a California vibe that feels refreshing compared to typical Midwest restaurant decor.
It’s casual enough for a quick solo lunch but nice enough for date nights or small group gatherings.
The counter-service model works because the food quality never suffers. You’re getting the same fresh seafood and careful preparation as higher-end restaurants but without the markup or formality.
Staff members are knowledgeable about the menu and happy to answer questions or make recommendations, ensuring first-timers feel comfortable navigating the ordering process and trying new dishes they might not have considered.
Diverse Menu That Pleases Every Palate
Walking into Slapfish means confronting choices, wonderful choices that range from guilty pleasure indulgences to light, healthy options packed with flavor. The menu covers everything from classic fish and chips to innovative creations like shrimp burritos and ahi tuna rice bowls.
This variety means groups with different preferences can all find something they’ll love, making it easier to convince that one friend who claims they don’t like seafood.
The fish and chips earn particular praise for featuring perfectly seasoned fish with a light, crispy batter that actually stays attached instead of sliding off. The tartar sauce gets mentioned repeatedly as being exceptional, the kind of accompaniment that elevates the entire dish.
For those seeking lighter fare, the power bowls and rice bowls deliver fresh fish with vegetables and grains that leave you satisfied without feeling weighed down.
Even non-seafood items like the grilled cheese options mean pickier eaters or seafood-averse companions can still enjoy the meal. The surf and turf burger combines land and sea in a way that showcases how versatile the kitchen can be.
Sides range from standard fries to more adventurous options, giving you plenty of ways to customize your meal.
This breadth of options explains why some visitors returned three times in four days during their Indianapolis stay. You could eat here repeatedly without getting bored, always finding something new to try or returning to a favorite that keeps calling you back.
Prime Massachusetts Avenue Location
Slapfish sits at 345 Massachusetts Avenue, right in the heart of one of Indianapolis’s most vibrant neighborhoods. This location puts you within walking distance of countless other attractions, making it perfect for combining your meal with other downtown activities.
The Massachusetts Avenue corridor is known for its arts scene, unique shops, and diverse dining options, and Slapfish fits right into this eclectic mix.
Just a short walk away, you’ll find the Indianapolis Museum of Art at Newfields at 4000 Michigan Road, offering world-class exhibitions and beautiful gardens. The Indiana State Museum at 650 West Washington Street provides fascinating insights into Hoosier history and culture.
For theater lovers, the historic Athenaeum at 401 East Michigan Street hosts performances and events throughout the year in a stunning German Renaissance Revival building.
The Kurt Vonnegut Museum and Library at 543 Indiana Avenue celebrates the famous Indianapolis-born author with exhibits and programs. White River State Park, accessible at 801 West Washington Street, offers green space, trails, and connects to multiple attractions including the NCAA Hall of Champions.
Fountain Square, located at the intersection of Virginia Avenue and Prospect Street, brings even more dining and entertainment options within easy reach.
This central location means you can easily make Slapfish part of a larger downtown adventure. Whether you’re catching a show, exploring museums, or just wandering the vibrant streets, having quality seafood nearby enhances the entire experience of enjoying everything Indianapolis has to offer.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
