Hidden along North College Avenue in Indianapolis sits a treasure that has been serving hungry locals since 1933. The Aristocrat Pub & Oxford Room, located at 5212 N.
College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220, combines old-world charm with modern comfort food excellence. Walking through its doors feels like stepping back in time, with vintage finds decorating every wall and cozy wooden booths inviting you to stay awhile.
What really keeps people coming back is the food, especially their legendary fish and chips. This unassuming eatery has perfected the art of British pub classics while also offering incredible American favorites like their famous pork tenderloin.
With 60 beers on tap and a menu that satisfies every craving, it is no wonder this place has earned a 4.6-star rating from nearly 1,800 reviews. Whether you are a local or just passing through Indianapolis, the Aristocrat Pub deserves a spot on your must-visit list.
Fish and Chips That Set the Standard
Perfectly golden, crispy on the outside, and tender on the inside, the fish and chips at Aristocrat Pub have earned legendary status among Indianapolis diners. The restaurant takes this classic British dish seriously, using fresh ingredients and a time-tested recipe that delivers consistent excellence with every order.
Each piece of fish is coated in a light, flavorful batter that fries up beautifully without being greasy or heavy.
What makes their version stand out is the attention to detail in every component. The fish arrives piping hot with a satisfying crunch that gives way to flaky, moist fish inside.
The chips, or fries as Americans know them, are cut thick and fried to crispy perfection, creating the ideal companion to the fish. Many reviewers specifically mention this dish as a must-try, and it frequently appears in customer feedback alongside other pub favorites.
The portion size is generous without being overwhelming, making it perfect for a satisfying lunch or dinner. Whether you pair it with one of their 60 beers on tap or enjoy it with a soft drink, the fish and chips never disappoint.
The dish represents everything great about traditional pub food done right.
Historic Atmosphere Dating Back to 1933
Stepping into Aristocrat Pub feels like traveling through time to an era when neighborhood pubs were the heart of their communities. The building has housed this beloved establishment since 1933, and the restaurant has carefully preserved its historic character while updating it for modern comfort.
Beautiful woodworking adorns the interior, showcasing craftsmanship from a bygone era that you simply do not find in newer restaurants.
Every wall tells a story through vintage finds and carefully curated decorations that give diners plenty to admire while waiting for their meals. The folksy, welcoming vibe creates an environment where strangers become friends and regulars are treated like family.
Cozy wooden booths provide intimate seating for couples and small groups, while larger tables accommodate families and celebrations.
The bar area itself is a work of art, elegantly designed and perfectly positioned for those who want to enjoy a drink while chatting with the bartender or fellow patrons. Natural light streams through windows during the day, while warm lighting creates a inviting glow in the evening hours.
The restaurant strikes the perfect balance between maintaining its historical roots and providing a comfortable dining experience.
The Famous Hoosier Tenderloin Sandwich
If you want to experience true Indiana cuisine, the Hoosier Tenderloin at Aristocrat Pub is absolutely essential eating. This sandwich has achieved legendary status not just at this restaurant but across the entire state, and for good reason.
The center-cut fresh pork loin is pounded thin, coated in perfectly seasoned breading, and fried to golden perfection, creating a sandwich as big as your face.
Multiple customer reviews mention being shocked by the size of this behemoth sandwich. One enthusiastic diner noted it was large enough to provide two meals in one sitting, while another called it huge and cooked to perfection.
The pork itself is tender and juicy, never dry, with a crispy exterior that provides satisfying texture in every bite. You can also order it grilled if you prefer a lighter option, though most regulars swear by the breaded and fried version.
The sandwich comes on a regular-sized bun, which means the pork extends far beyond the bread on all sides, creating that iconic Indiana tenderloin look that makes for great photos. Diners recommend pairing it with the french fries rather than the house chips for the ultimate experience.
Delightful Outdoor Patio for Street-Side Dining
When the weather cooperates, the outdoor patio at Aristocrat Pub becomes one of the most sought-after dining spots in Indianapolis. This charming space offers street-side seating that lets you enjoy your meal while watching the neighborhood bustle by, creating a European cafe vibe right in the heart of Indiana.
The patio appears in customer reviews 49 times, making it one of the most mentioned features of the restaurant.
Comfortable seating and overhead fans ensure that even on warmer days, the patio remains pleasant and inviting. The space is thoughtfully designed to feel like an extension of the indoor dining area, maintaining the same welcoming atmosphere while offering the added benefit of fresh air and people watching.
Many diners specifically request patio seating when making reservations, especially during spring and fall when Indianapolis weather is at its finest.
The patio provides a more casual, relaxed dining experience that is perfect for weekend brunches, afternoon lunches, or evening dinners with friends. One reviewer specifically mentioned sitting on the very nice patio and having a wonderful experience with their server.
Another described enjoying street-side dining and appreciating the steady stream of people coming and going, adding to the lively atmosphere.
Families appreciate the outdoor space as it provides a bit more room for children to move around, while couples find it romantic for date nights. Groups of friends gathering for drinks and appetizers love the social atmosphere the patio creates.
The space strikes the perfect balance between being part of the restaurant experience and feeling like a separate destination, giving diners options depending on their mood and the occasion.
Outstanding Appetizers from Baked Brie to Brussels Sprouts
Starting your meal with one of the exceptional appetizers at Aristocrat Pub sets the tone for an unforgettable dining experience. The baked brie stands out as a customer favorite, mentioned enthusiastically in multiple reviews for its phenomenal flavor and presentation.
This warm, gooey cheese comes topped with a delightful brown sugar crust and is served with crisp green apple slices that provide the perfect sweet and tart balance.
The Brussels sprouts offer a completely different flavor profile, described by one happy diner as spicy and scrumptious, disappearing from the table in a hot minute. For those who prefer classic pub starters, the beer cheese with pretzel bread delivers rich, creamy satisfaction, though some reviewers noted the pretzel itself could be less chewy.
The bruschetta receives consistent praise for its freshness, served on light, dense French bread slices with perfectly balanced toppings.
Other standout appetizers include the fried green tomato caprese salad, which one visitor called the best they had ever tasted, and the spinach and artichoke dip with nachos for those wanting something hearty. The super nachos are particularly impressive, described as stacked high enough to serve four people as an appetizer.
These come loaded with cheese sauce, pico de gallo, cilantro, and Mexican queso fresco, with options to add avocado, black beans, or chicken.
What makes the appetizer selection truly special is the variety of flavors and styles represented. Whether you want something light and refreshing or rich and indulgent, the menu offers options that appeal to every palate.
Sharing several appetizers has become a popular strategy among regulars, allowing groups to sample multiple dishes before moving on to entrees.
Live Music and Special Events Create Memorable Evenings
Beyond the exceptional food and drinks, Aristocrat Pub offers live music performances that transform regular dining into special occasions worth planning around. The restaurant hosts live music on the first and third Fridays of each month, creating an atmosphere where great food meets entertainment.
One enthusiastic reviewer described how the live music inspired them to order two appetizers instead of one, showing how the performances enhance the entire experience.
The music adds energy and excitement to the evening without overwhelming conversation, striking the perfect balance that lets diners enjoy both the performance and their companions. The type of music varies, but the focus remains on creating an enjoyable atmosphere that complements rather than dominates the dining experience.
Regulars know to make reservations for these special evenings, as the combination of live entertainment and excellent food draws crowds.
The restaurant thoughtfully schedules these events to create anticipation and give guests something to look forward to throughout the month. Making an 8pm reservation for a live music night and arriving early to visit the Red Key Tavern next door has become a popular tradition for some patrons.
This creates an entire evening of entertainment centered around the Aristocrat Pub experience.
Even on nights without live music, the restaurant maintains a welcoming vibe that encourages lingering over meals and enjoying the company of friends and family. Some diners have mentioned wishing for a more active pub atmosphere, though most appreciate the balance between lively and comfortable.
The addition of live music on select nights provides the best of both worlds, offering energetic entertainment for those seeking it while maintaining the relaxed atmosphere on other evenings that makes the restaurant perfect for quiet conversations and intimate meals.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
