I used to fall for the biggest-menu-wins idea until I pulled up to County Smoak on Timberlake Road in Lynchburg and realized I had it backwards. This place keeps it simple on purpose, because the whole point is the smoke, the bark, the tenderness, and that first bite that makes you pause like you just got proven wrong in public.
While other barbecue spots bury you in options, County Smoak stays locked in on doing a few things ridiculously well, and that focus shows up on the tray. It also explains the loyal crowd. Locals treat it like a weekly ritual, travelers detour for it, and I have heard more than one person casually mention driving from Richmond just to stock up like brisket is a supply they cannot risk running out of.
You can feel the confidence in the place: no distractions, no filler, just meat smoked the way it should be and served without a bunch of extra noise. The moment I tell you what to order first, the whole “less is more” thing starts making a lot of sense.
The Brisket That Brings People Back
Brisket at County Smoak isn’t just good. It’s the kind that makes grown adults consider moving to Lynchburg.
Customers rave about the perfect bark, the heavy smoke ring, and meat so tender it practically dissolves on your tongue. Some folks claim it’s the best they’ve ever tasted, and judging by the awards hanging on the walls, they’re not alone in that opinion.
What sets this brisket apart is the moisture level. Finding pulled pork that doesn’t need sauce is rare enough, but brisket that stays juicy without drowning in liquid smoke?
That’s genuine craftsmanship. The pitmaster knows exactly how long to let that meat sit in the smoker, and it shows in every single slice.
Order it on a sandwich or grab it by the pound. Either way, you’re getting meat that’s been treated with respect and cooked with serious skill.
The seasoning is bold without being overwhelming, letting the natural beef flavor shine through that gorgeous smoke. People have been known to order extra just to take home, because once you’ve had it, regular brisket just won’t cut it anymore.
Smoked Mac and Cheese Worth the Hype
Forget everything you think you know about macaroni and cheese. County Smoak takes this classic comfort food and elevates it to legendary status.
Regular-sized noodles swimming in super creamy cheese, topped with a layer of baked shredded cheddar that gets crispy in all the right places. One reviewer claimed they’d smack their momma for a bowl of it, and honestly, that tracks.
The smoking process adds an unexpected depth that separates this from every other mac and cheese you’ve tried. It’s rich without being heavy, creamy without being gloppy, and manages to hold its own next to all that incredible smoked meat.
Many customers list it as their favorite side, which says something considering the competition.
This isn’t the kind of mac and cheese you get at a chain restaurant. Each bite delivers that perfect cheese pull, and the slightly smoky undertone reminds you exactly where you are.
People order extra containers to take home, and some have even admitted it changed their entire perspective on what this side dish can be. At County Smoak, even the sides are worth the trip.
Pulled Pork That Needs No Sauce
Pulled pork sandwiches at County Smoak come loaded with enough meat to feed a small village. Seriously, one reviewer described theirs as “the size of a baby pig,” and that’s not much of an exaggeration.
The portion sizes here don’t mess around, and neither does the quality of the pork itself.
Here’s the real test of great barbecue: does the meat need sauce to taste good? At County Smoak, the answer is a resounding no. The pork stays incredibly moist thanks to careful smoking techniques, and the flavor is so well-developed that sauce becomes optional rather than essential.
That said, their original sweet sauce with just a touch of spice makes a great addition if you’re feeling adventurous.
The meat gets piled high on rolls that somehow manage to elevate the whole experience. Multiple reviews mention these buns specifically, noting how they complement rather than compete with the star of the show.
Whether you add their tangy coleslaw or keep it simple, you’re getting a sandwich that delivers exactly what Virginia barbecue should taste like. Juicy, flavorful, and completely satisfying.
Collard Greens That Convert Skeptics
Collard greens often get overlooked on barbecue menus, but not at County Smoak. These aren’t your typical boiled-to-death greens that taste like an afterthought.
Rich, tender, and packed with smoky goodness, they’ve actually converted people who swore they hated collards. One customer admitted these greens single-handedly changed their entire view on the vegetable.
The secret is in the preparation. County Smoak treats their sides with the same care as their meats, and it shows.
The greens come out perfectly tender with just enough saltiness and smoke to cut through the richness of all that barbecue. They’re not just a side dish; they’re an experience unto themselves.
Smart diners know to order these alongside the mac and cheese and brisket for the ultimate flavor combination. The greens provide a savory counterpoint that keeps your palate from getting overwhelmed by all the cheese and meat.
Multiple reviews specifically call out the collards as a must-try, and considering how passionate barbecue fans can be about their sides, that’s high praise indeed. Give them a shot even if you think you don’t like greens.
Fire and Ice Pickles That Pack a Punch
Sometimes the best items on a menu are the ones you don’t expect. Fire and Ice pickles at County Smoak fall into that category.
These aren’t your standard dill chips sitting sadly in a jar. They’re a perfect blend of sweet and spicy that works as both a palate cleanser and a flavor bomb all on its own.
The name tells you everything you need to know. The “fire” brings heat that wakes up your taste buds without destroying them, while the “ice” delivers a cooling sweetness that balances everything out.
Together, they create a pickle experience that’s become a cult favorite among regulars. People mention them specifically in reviews, often with multiple exclamation points.
Try them on a sandwich or eat them straight from the container. Either way works.
They cut through the richness of the smoked meats beautifully, providing a crisp contrast to all that tender barbecue. Some customers order extra containers just to take home, and honestly, that’s a smart move.
These pickles are the kind of detail that shows County Smoak sweats the small stuff just as much as the big stuff.
Smoked Turkey That Steals Thanksgiving
Turkey often plays second fiddle to other barbecue meats, but County Smoak’s version deserves headliner status. Smoked to perfection, this turkey breast is so tender, moist, and flavorful that families have started ordering it for their Thanksgiving dinners instead of roasting their own birds.
That’s not an exaggeration; it’s documented in multiple glowing reviews.
One customer who traditionally prepared a massive spatchcocked turkey every year decided to try County Smoak’s Thanksgiving package. The result?
A new family tradition was born. The smoked turkey breast arrived sliced neatly, bursting with flavor, and tender enough to make even dark meat lovers reconsider their preferences.
The smoking process adds layers of complexity you simply can’t achieve in a regular oven.
Available year-round, not just during holidays, this turkey works beautifully on sandwiches or as part of a platter. The meat stays incredibly juicy thanks to careful temperature control and timing in the smoker.
If you’ve only ever had dry, boring turkey, this version will completely reset your expectations. County Smoak proves that turkey absolutely belongs in the barbecue conversation.
Ribs That Sell Out Fast
Want ribs from County Smoak? Better show up early.
These beauties sell out within an hour of opening on busy days, and for good reason. Tender, sauced just right, and falling off the bone in the best possible way, they’ve earned their reputation as one of the restaurant’s most sought-after items.
The ribs come basted with barbecue sauce that caramelizes beautifully during the smoking process. While some reviewers wish for more smoke flavor, the majority rave about the tenderness and overall taste.
The meat pulls away from the bone effortlessly, and the seasoning hits all the right notes without overwhelming your palate.
County Smoak doesn’t mess around with portion sizes here either. Order a rack and you’re getting serious value for your money.
The quality stays consistent whether you’re there on a Wednesday afternoon or a packed Saturday evening. Pro tip from the regulars: call ahead to reserve your ribs if you’re planning a weekend visit.
These sell out for a reason, and once they’re gone, they’re gone. Virginia knows good ribs when it tastes them.
The Sauce Selection That Satisfies Everyone
County Smoak doesn’t just offer one sauce and call it a day. They’ve developed six different varieties to match whatever mood you’re in.
The original sauce leads the pack with its sweet profile and subtle spice kick. Boss sauce brings more heat for those who like their barbecue with attitude.
Tangy barbecue delivers exactly what the name promises, while Worcestershire-based options add depth and complexity.
What makes this selection special is how well each sauce complements specific meats without overpowering them. The sweet sauce works beautifully with pulled pork, while the tangy option cuts through the richness of brisket.
Angry Boss brings the fire for anyone who wants to feel the burn, and the variety means every member of your group can customize their experience.
Here’s the thing though: the meat at County Smoak is good enough that sauce becomes optional rather than mandatory. Many customers eat their barbecue completely naked, letting the smoke and seasoning speak for themselves.
Still, having options never hurts, and the sauces here are crafted with the same attention to detail as everything else. Sample them all and find your favorite.
Atmosphere That Keeps It Real
County Smoak doesn’t try to be fancy, and that’s exactly why people love it. Located at 7423 Timberlake Road, this place embraces its roadside barbecue joint identity completely.
Limited indoor seating means most folks end up outside at picnic tables, and on nice days, that’s exactly where you want to be anyway. The smell of smoke hanging in the air just adds to the authenticity.
The staff treats customers like family. Multiple reviews mention employees by name, praising their friendliness and genuine enthusiasm for the food they’re serving.
One worker even offered customers a tour of the smokehouse and samples of sides they hadn’t ordered. That kind of hospitality can’t be faked.
Awards and plaques cover the walls inside, testament to the recognition County Smoak has earned over the years. But the real decoration is the constant stream of happy customers walking out with bags full of barbecue.
The atmosphere is casual, welcoming, and refreshingly unpretentious. You’re here for incredible food made by real people who care about their craft, and everything about the space reinforces that mission.
No tablecloths, no attitude, just honest barbecue done right.
Catering That Makes Weddings Memorable
Getting married? County Smoak has catered multiple weddings, and couples consistently rave about the experience.
The food arrives hot, perfectly prepared, and in quantities that ensure nobody goes hungry. Guests at these weddings often mention the barbecue specifically in their congratulations, which tells you everything about the quality.
The catering team handles events with the same professionalism they bring to daily service. They’re organized, friendly, and committed to making your special day stress-free.
One couple mentioned zero glitches during their entire event, which is basically a miracle in the wedding world. The pricing stays fair even for large orders, offering genuine value for the quality you receive.
Barbecue catering can be risky since timing and temperature are so crucial, but County Smoak has it down to a science. The brisket stays tender, the sides remain fresh, and everything arrives exactly when promised.
Multiple couples have said choosing County Smoak for catering was one of their best wedding decisions. When your food gets more compliments than your dress or venue, you know you’ve made the right call.
This is Virginia barbecue at its absolute finest.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
