Michigan is home to some incredible and often overlooked pizza joints. From classic deep-dish to unique local flavors, these pizzerias have something special to offer.
This list highlights nine hidden gems that are cherished by locals yet remain undiscovered by many. Whether you’re a local resident or a pizza enthusiast looking for your next great bite, these spots promise to deliver a memorable dining experience.
1. Supino Pizzeria in Detroit
Nestled in Detroit’s vibrant Eastern Market, Supino Pizzeria offers a delightful blend of Italian tradition and local flair. Known for its thin-crust pizzas, this spot attracts both loyal locals and curious newcomers. Their signature ‘City Wing Thing’ combines the tantalizing flavors of roasted garlic, smoked turkey, and cherry peppers.
The atmosphere inside is lively and warm, reflecting the cultural richness of the area. Despite its understated appearance, Supino’s pizzas are a culinary masterpiece. Hand-tossed dough and fresh ingredients form the backbone of their creations.
In the bustling market surroundings, Supino stands as a testament to Detroit’s food renaissance. A visit here is a journey into the heart of local pizza innovation.
2. Crispelli’s Bakery and Pizzeria in Berkley
Crispelli’s Bakery and Pizzeria, located in Berkley, offers a unique fusion of traditional baking and modern pizza artistry. Their wood-fired oven produces pizzas with a crisp, golden crust, renowned throughout the community. The ‘Margherita’ pizza, topped with fresh basil and buffalo mozzarella, is a crowd favorite.
Inside, the aroma of freshly baked bread and melting cheese creates an inviting ambiance. Crispelli’s marries the charm of a classic bakery with the allure of a contemporary pizzeria.
The establishment’s commitment to quality ingredients and skilled craftsmanship is evident in every bite. Crispelli’s is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination for those craving an authentic taste of Italy.
3. Buddy’s Pizza in Detroit
Buddy’s Pizza is a Detroit institution known for pioneering the iconic Detroit-style pizza. Characterized by its thick, square crust and caramelized cheese edges, Buddy’s creation is both satisfying and unique. The ‘Detroiter’ pizza, with its ample cheese and pepperoni, exemplifies this style.
The restaurant’s interior sports a retro vibe, reminiscent of its 1946 origins. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere. Buddy’s history is interwoven with the city itself, making it a staple in local dining.
Beyond the pizza, Buddy’s offers a connection to Detroit’s storied past. Each slice is a piece of history, rich in flavor and tradition. It’s more than a meal; it’s a legacy.
4. Silver Beach Pizza in St. Joseph
Perched near the shores of Lake Michigan, Silver Beach Pizza in St. Joseph offers more than just great pizza; it promises a scenic dining experience. Known for their generous toppings and creative combinations, their ‘Train Wreck’ pizza is a must-try.
The location provides stunning views, especially from the bustling patio. Diners can enjoy the beachside ambiance while savoring a slice, making it perfect for a relaxed evening.
Silver Beach Pizza captures the essence of lakeside dining, blending leisure with culinary creativity. Here, the beauty of the surroundings complements the flavors on the plate, creating a memorable outing.
5. Fricano’s Pizza Tavern in Grand Haven
Fricano’s Pizza Tavern in Grand Haven is Michigan’s oldest pizzeria, serving its first pie in 1949. Known for its ultra-thin crust, Fricano’s keeps it simple with classic toppings that have stood the test of time. Their ‘Original’ pizza is a testament to minimalist perfection.
The tavern’s rustic charm and historical significance draw in pizza lovers of all ages. It’s a place where tradition meets taste.
A visit to Fricano’s is like stepping back in time, where the focus remains on quality and authenticity. Those in search of a genuine slice of history and flavor will find it here.
6. The Mitten Brewing Company in Grand Rapids
The Mitten Brewing Company in Grand Rapids offers a unique combination of craft beer and gourmet pizza, all served in a renovated firehouse. Their pizza menu includes innovative options like ‘The Heater,’ which features spicy sausage and jalapeños.
The lively atmosphere is enhanced by the brewery’s engaging events and warm community spirit. It’s a place where pizza enthusiasts and beer lovers unite.
The Mitten’s commitment to quality and creativity sets it apart from other pizzerias. Here, the blend of flavors and the friendly vibe create a dining experience that is both satisfying and unique.
7. PizzaPapalis in Detroit
PizzaPapalis brings the rich tradition of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza to Detroit. Their pies are famous for their thick layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings. The ‘Chicago Deep Dish’ is a hearty choice that exemplifies this style.
The modern, urban setting provides a perfect backdrop for enjoying these indulgent pizzas. Each bite reveals the rich, robust flavors that have made PizzaPapalis a favorite among locals.
Committing to authenticity and flavor, PizzaPapalis offers a slice of Chicago in the heart of Detroit. It’s an experience that satisfies both hunger and nostalgia for the Windy City’s culinary heritage.
8. Coco’s Pizzeria in Flint
Coco’s Pizzeria in Flint is a hidden gem that combines creativity with tradition. Known for its cozy atmosphere and inventive menu, Coco’s offers pizzas that surprise and delight. The ‘Flint Special,’ topped with local favorites, is a highlight.
The warm, inviting interior makes it a perfect spot for family gatherings or casual dinners. The pizzeria embraces a community spirit, reflected in its friendly service and local patronage.
Coco’s commitment to quality and flavor makes it a standout choice in Flint. It’s a place where every pizza tells a story, crafted with love and enjoyed with friends.
9. Roma’s Pizza in Lansing
Roma’s Pizza in Lansing offers a taste of Italy with its authentic Italian-style pizzas. Known for their generous portions and rich flavors, Roma’s serves classics that satisfy all palates. Their ‘Roma Special’ features a delightful mix of meats and vegetables.
The family-friendly environment is bustling with energy, making it ideal for gatherings. Roma’s blends tradition with a welcoming vibe that appeals to all ages.
This pizzeria is more than a dining spot; it’s a celebration of Italian culinary heritage. Each pizza is crafted with passion, bringing a piece of Italy to Michigan’s capital.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
