Discover the heart of Midwest culinary culture through these cherished Wisconsin establishments, each serving up a Friday fish fry that locals and visitors alike treasure.
From classic supper clubs to bustling breweries, these venues offer more than just a meal—they provide a slice of Wisconsin tradition. Dive into the details of what makes each spot unique and why their fish fries are must-tries.
1. The Old Fashioned in Madison
The Old Fashioned in Madison is a tribute to Wisconsin’s rich culinary heritage. Known for its generous servings of lake perch, the restaurant pairs this staple with house-made tartar sauce and freshly-cut fries. Patrons enjoy the nostalgic decor, which echoes the classic supper club ambiance.
A historical tidbit: The Old Fashioned prides itself on sourcing local ingredients, preserving the traditional taste of the region. For those seeking a genuine Wisconsin experience, this venue offers a delightful mix of history and flavor, making it a top choice for a Friday fish fry outing.
2. Wendt’s on the Lake in Van Dyne
Nestled on the shores of Lake Winnebago, Wendt’s on the Lake delivers a serene dining experience with its famous perch dinners. Guests adore the lightly battered fish, served with a side of potato pancakes and applesauce.
Known for its picturesque views, Wendt’s is a favorite among those who appreciate dining with a view. The establishment has been serving the community since the 1920s, offering a slice of history along with its meal. For a tranquil and delicious escape, Wendt’s provides both culinary delight and a touch of nostalgia.
3. Kroll’s West in Green Bay
Kroll’s West, a Green Bay fixture, captures the vibrant spirit of Wisconsin’s fish fry tradition. This beloved tavern serves up crispy perch and walleye, attracting locals who savor every bite. The fish is perfectly fried, accompanied by classic sides like coleslaw and buttered rye bread.
With its cozy interior and friendly service, Kroll’s offers a quintessential Friday night experience. Kroll’s has been a family-run establishment since 1931, making it a cornerstone of the community. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, the welcoming atmosphere and delicious fare make it a must-visit for any fish fry enthusiast.
4. Lakefront Brewery in Milwaukee
At Lakefront Brewery, fish fry nights are as lively as the craft beers they brew. Located in Milwaukee’s bustling beer district, this venue is famed for its beer-battered cod served alongside creamy coleslaw and fries. The communal seating encourages a social atmosphere, turning meals into festive gatherings.
Lakefront Brewery was the first in the nation to brew a certified organic beer. For those who love pairing great food with craft beer, this brewery offers an unmissable Friday night experience with a side of local flair.
5. Toby’s Supper Club in Madison
Toby’s Supper Club, a Madison institution, offers a nostalgic glimpse into Wisconsin’s dining past. Renowned for its fried haddock, Toby’s serves fish with a side of potato salad and homemade rye bread. The cozy, dimly lit ambiance, complete with wood-paneled walls, is reminiscent of classic supper clubs.
Toby’s has been delighting diners since the 1960s, maintaining its charm and quality over the decades. For those seeking a taste of tradition, Toby’s Supper Club is a must-visit, blending history with hearty, delicious meals.
6. Al’s Hamburgers and Fish Fry in Green Bay
Al’s Hamburgers and Fish Fry combines the best of both worlds in Green Bay. Known for its dual offering of classic burgers and fish fry, this diner attracts a diverse crowd. The fish, typically haddock, is fried to perfection and complemented by fresh fries and tangy tartar sauce.
The retro diner decor adds to the charm, making it a beloved spot for locals. Al’s has been feeding the community since the 1930s, adapting its menu to suit changing tastes while keeping tradition alive. It’s a delightful spot for a casual and satisfying meal.
7. Fritz’s Wooden Nickel in Monona
Fritz’s Wooden Nickel in Monona is where hearty meals meet friendly service. Famous for its Friday fish fry featuring bluegill, Fritz’s offers generous portions paired with creamy coleslaw and potato wedges. The rustic pub feel and welcoming staff make it a go-to for families and friends.
Fritz’s has been a community favorite since the 1970s, known for its consistency in quality and service. For those seeking a comfortable and satisfying dining experience, Fritz’s delivers with charm and taste.
8. Randy’s Supper Club in New London
Randy’s Supper Club in New London sets the stage for an elegant dining experience. Known for its exquisite fish fry featuring haddock, Randy’s pairs its dishes with homemade sides like German potato salad. The sophisticated ambiance, complete with white tablecloths and attentive service, elevates the meal to a fine dining affair.
Randy’s has been serving the New London community since the 1950s, building a reputation for excellence and tradition. For those looking to indulge in a refined meal, Randy’s Supper Club is the perfect destination.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
