Wisconsin’s supper clubs are magical places where food, history, and community come together. Road trippers from all over the country flock to these classic establishments, especially on Friday nights when the legendary fish fry takes center stage. Ishnala Supper Club stands out as a must-visit destination that captures everything wonderful about Wisconsin dining culture, from its stunning lakeside setting to its mouthwatering menu and rich heritage.
Seasonal Operation and Timing
Road trippers need to know that Ishnala operates seasonally, typically opening its doors in April and closing when October ends. This schedule aligns with Wisconsin’s most pleasant weather months, allowing guests to fully appreciate the outdoor setting and scenic drive. Planning your visit requires checking current operating dates, as exact opening and closing times can vary slightly from year to year based on weather conditions.
The restaurant focuses on dinner service, so don’t expect lunch options during your afternoon drive. Timing your arrival for early evening gives you the best chance of shorter waits while still enjoying daylight views of Mirror Lake. Late summer and early fall offer spectacular scenery with changing leaves adding extra color to an already beautiful landscape.
A Hidden Gem on Mirror Lake
Tucked away on the shores of Mirror Lake within Mirror Lake State Park, Ishnala Supper Club feels like a secret waiting to be discovered. The journey to reach this dining destination is part of the adventure, with a winding road that meanders through open meadows and thick forests. Every turn reveals another slice of Wisconsin’s natural beauty, building anticipation for what awaits at the end.
Once you arrive, the view alone is worth the trip. Mirror Lake stretches out before you, reflecting the sky and surrounding trees in its calm waters. The peaceful setting creates an immediate sense of escape from everyday life, making your meal feel like a special occasion no matter what day you visit.
Trees Growing Through the Roof
Walking into Ishnala’s main dining room is like stepping into a storybook. Massive Norway pine trees grow right through the structure, their trunks rising from the floor and disappearing through the ceiling above. The original log walls and stone fireplace add to the rustic charm, creating an atmosphere you simply can’t find anywhere else. This isn’t just decoration – it’s architecture that respects and incorporates nature.
The builders designed the space around these magnificent trees rather than cutting them down, showing respect for the land’s natural beauty. Diners sit surrounded by history and nature simultaneously, enjoying their meals in a space that feels both intimate and grand. The crackling fireplace adds warmth on cool Wisconsin evenings.
Sacred Grounds Turned Supper Club
Before Ishnala became a beloved supper club in 1953, this land held deep significance for the Winnebago people, also known as the Ho-Chunk Nation. They used these grounds for ceremonial gatherings, drawn to the area’s natural beauty and spiritual energy. Early pioneers later settled here, building log structures that would eventually transform into the restaurant we know today.
Understanding this history adds depth to your dining experience. You’re not just eating at a restaurant – you’re sitting in a place where generations have gathered, celebrated, and connected with the land. The name “Ishnala” itself reflects this heritage, chosen to honor the location’s indigenous roots and the peaceful spirit that still permeates the property today.
The Famous Friday Fish Fry
Friday nights at Ishnala mean one thing: the fish fry that locals and travelers alike consider legendary. Crispy, golden-brown fish arrives at your table alongside traditional accompaniments like creamy coleslaw, crispy potato pancakes, tangy rye bread, and homemade tartar sauce. The batter achieves that perfect crunch while keeping the fish inside tender and flaky.
This tradition runs deep in Wisconsin culture, originally serving as a meatless Friday option for Catholic communities during Lent. Now it’s a weekly celebration that brings people together regardless of their background. Arriving early is essential because word has spread far beyond the local community. Road trippers plan entire routes around experiencing this authentic Wisconsin tradition at its finest.
Prime Rib Aged to Perfection
Meat lovers shouldn’t overlook Ishnala’s spectacular prime rib, aged for forty days to develop incredible flavor and tenderness. The aging process breaks down the meat’s fibers while concentrating its natural taste, resulting in a cut that practically melts on your tongue. Seasoned simply to let the beef’s quality shine through, each slice showcases why Wisconsin takes its supper club steaks seriously.
Choosing between the fish fry and prime rib becomes many visitors’ biggest dilemma. Some road trippers solve this problem by planning multiple visits during their Wisconsin adventure. The generous portions mean you’ll leave satisfied, and the reasonable prices make splurging on high-quality beef feel justified. Pair it with classic sides for the full supper club experience.
Roast Duck with Local Flair
Ishnala’s roast Wisconsin duck stands as a signature dish that showcases regional ingredients and traditional cooking techniques. The duck arrives with perfectly crispy skin and tender, flavorful meat underneath, prepared using recipes perfected over decades. Using locally sourced duck connects diners directly to Wisconsin’s agricultural heritage and commitment to quality ingredients.
Not every supper club offers duck on their menu, making this option particularly special for adventurous eaters. The preparation method locks in moisture while developing those crispy exterior textures everyone craves. First-timers often discover a new favorite dish they never expected to love. Regulars know to order it alongside their usual choices, creating a feast that represents the best of what Ishnala offers to hungry travelers.
Plan for Wait Times and Parking
Popularity comes with a price at Ishnala: no reservations means you’ll likely face a wait, especially on weekends and Friday nights. Arriving early helps, but even then you might need patience as crowds gather for their chance to experience this beloved establishment. The restaurant operates on a first-come, first-served basis that keeps things fair but requires flexibility in your schedule.
Parking presents another consideration for visitors. During peak times, the main lot fills quickly, and staff directs cars to overflow areas with shuttle service back to the entrance. This system keeps traffic flowing but adds extra time to your visit. Smart travelers build in buffer time and embrace the wait as part of the adventure, perhaps exploring the lakeside grounds while their table is prepared.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
