A giant elephant statue beside a Pennsylvania highway derailed my schedule the moment I spotted it. A friend had told me about a place where thousands of elephant figurines share a roof with homemade fudge, and I assumed she was exaggerating.
She was not. The moment I opened the door, warm chocolate air hit me and I found myself staring at shelves stacked with elephants made of glass, wood, brass, and things I could not identify.
Somewhere between the PEZ dispensers and the garden path with a teapot-shaped shed, I realized I had walked into one of those rare roadside stops that does not just sell things. It collects joy.
The fudge comes in hundreds of flavors, the peanuts are roasted fresh, and the elephant collection numbers in the thousands, each one a testament to someone’s lifelong obsession.
I ended up spending far longer there than planned, wandering from room to room, and I have been grinning about it ever since.
An Indoor Herd of More Than 12,000 Elephants
My first reaction was simple: I did not know where to look. Elephants fill the shelves, crowd the countertops, and march along the ceiling beams in a display that keeps going long after your eyes give up counting.
The collection tops 12,000 figurines, made from just about every material you can name. Glass, brass, wood, ceramic, cloth, shell, and stone all show up somewhere in the mix.
Some are tiny enough to balance on a fingertip. Others stand tall enough to look you in the eye, which is a strange feeling in a candy shop.
The whole thing started in 1967, when founder Ed Gotwalt received a small wooden elephant as a wedding gift, its trunk raised for luck. That single piece is still on display, tucked into a case like the humble seed of everything around it.
Ed and his wife Pat kept collecting, and friends, relatives, and travelers kept adding to the herd. Little signs called Pachyderm Points are scattered around with facts about real elephants, so you learn something between the giggles.
My favorite oddities included an elephant hair dryer and an elephant potty chair, proof that nothing was too silly to keep. There is also a sculpture Ed bought in Mexico from artist Sergio Bustamante showing a head with elephants pouring out of it.
Visitors sign a guestbook, browse quietly, and point things out to each other. This Pennsylvania museum is not roped off or formal, which is exactly why it works so well.
Fudge Made Fresh, in Flavors You Have to Think About
Chocolate smell reaches you before the counter does. That warm, buttery scent drifts through the whole shop and makes decision-making significantly harder.
Fudge is the headline act here, and the flavor list is genuinely long. Depending on the season, dozens of varieties sit in neat trays behind the glass, from plain chocolate and peanut butter to combinations I had never considered putting in fudge form.
There is also a build-your-own option, where you pick from a rotating lineup of around two dozen flavor choices. I stood there far longer than a grown adult should stand in front of a fudge case.
What I liked most was the texture. It is dense and creamy rather than grainy, the kind that softens slowly instead of crumbling apart in your hand.
Cookie butter gets mentioned often by regulars, and I understand why after one bite. Peanut butter fans will be fine here too, since the shop makes its own peanut butter alongside fresh roasted jumbo peanuts and cinnamon glazed nuts.
My advice: buy smaller pieces of several flavors instead of one big slab of a single kind. It turns the drive home into a tasting session, and you avoid the regret of committing to just one.
Staff behind the counter are patient with indecision, which I tested thoroughly. They will talk you through what is freshest that day if you ask.
A Candy Shop That Runs on Nostalgia
Somewhere between the gummy bins and the licorice wall, I found a candy I had not seen since elementary school. That happens a lot here.
The shop stocks over a thousand kinds of candy, which sounds like marketing until you actually walk the aisles. Retro penny candies sit beside gourmet chocolates, and seasonal items rotate through the year.
Truffles behind the counter come in a long list of flavors and are almost too pretty to unwrap. I did unwrap them, obviously.
One fun quirk is the container system. Pick a souvenir mug or bucket, fill it with loose candy, and the candy comes along with the container, which turns shopping into a low-stakes game of spatial reasoning.
Families seem to love it, and I watched more than one kid carefully calculating how many gummies could balance on top. Parents can set a limit and let kids do the choosing, which keeps everyone happy.
Then there is the PEZ room, described as one of the largest displays on the East Coast, complete with a truck packed full of dispensers. Cartoon characters, holiday editions, and old designs line the shelves in bright rows.
M and M’s are even sorted by color, which felt oddly satisfying. Small cubby rooms branch off the main space, so keep wandering instead of heading straight for the register.
You will leave with more than you planned. Everybody does.
Gardens, Statues, and a Teapot Shed Out Back
Fudge in hand, I headed out the back door expecting a parking lot and found a garden instead. The grounds stretch out behind the shop with paths, statues, and small surprises tucked between the plantings.
Life-sized elephant statues stand among the greenery, some with water flowing from their trunks into a goldfish pond. Out front, an almost life-sized white elephant named Miss Ellie greets arrivals, and she has been known to talk to visitors.
Photo cutouts near the sign make for goofy souvenir pictures. I took one.
No regrets.
The oddest gem out here is Miss Pat’s Teapot Museum, housed inside a garden shed shaped like an actual teapot. More than two hundred smaller teapots crowd the inside, each one different, and the whole thing takes about five quiet minutes to enjoy.
Further along, the Enchanted Forest path winds through campy lawn art and unexpected objects, including an old delivery truck reimagined as artwork. There are Stairs to Nowhere, which is exactly as delightfully pointless as it sounds.
Picnic tables sit nearby, and picnickers are welcome, so bringing lunch is a completely reasonable plan. I ate fudge at a table by the pond and considered it a balanced meal.
Some sections show their age and the trail can get overgrown in summer, but that adds to the homemade charm. Wear comfortable shoes and give yourself twenty extra minutes.
The Story Behind the Herd, Including a Fire and a Comeback
Every collection has an origin story, and this one begins with a general store. Ed and Pat Gotwalt ran a small shop, and the museum officially opened in 1975 as Ed’s elephant hobby slowly took over the place.
Growth happened the way real collections grow, one gift and one lucky find at a time. Customers brought elephants back from trips, and the herd multiplied.
Then came 2010, when a fire tore through the building. It could easily have ended the whole story right there.
What happened next says a lot about how people feel about this spot. Volunteers arrived from seven states, donations of new elephants poured in, and the store was rebuilt in about seven months.
Today the business is run by Ed and Pat’s granddaughter, Nicole, and her husband, Isaac. That family thread is easy to feel when you are inside, since nothing about the place feels corporate or focus-grouped.
Displays get rearranged, so longtime visitors mention spotting something new every trip. Regulars have been coming for twenty years and still find pieces they missed.
I met people browsing who clearly had their own elephant collections at home, comparing notes with the shelves. One review I read described finding the exact concrete garden elephant a family had growing up, and honestly, that is the kind of moment this place invites.
History here is personal rather than academic. It sneaks up on you between the candy and the souvenirs.
Planning Your Stop Along the Lincoln Highway
Timing matters less than you would think, since the doors open daily at 10 AM and stay open until 6 PM. That makes it an easy add-on to a Gettysburg day trip without any careful scheduling.
The shop sits along Route 30, the historic Lincoln Highway, just west of Gettysburg in Adams County. Those big elephant statues out front make it nearly impossible to drive past by accident.
Admission to the museum and gardens is free, which removes any pressure to hurry.
Give yourself at least an hour. I thought thirty minutes would cover it and was still browsing an hour and a half later.
Bring a card or cash, keeping in mind there is a minimum purchase amount for card transactions. Not a big deal, though worth knowing before you get to the register.
Staff here are genuinely friendly and happy to explain how the fill-a-container deals work, which saves you money if you ask. They will also point out what fudge came out of the kitchen most recently.
Combine the visit with nearby stops like Caledonia State Park for a full day of driving, walking, and snacking. The surrounding countryside is lovely in fall, when the orchards around Orrtanna look their best.
Go with a loose plan and let curiosity handle the rest. That is really the spirit of the place.
Address: 6019 Chambersburg Rd, Orrtanna, Pennsylvania 17353
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
