You step through the door and something shifts. The old signs on the walls, the photographs of people you never met, the smell of coffee and maple syrup mixing together. This café in Maine sits right on the edge of a pond, and the water views are the kind that make you forget your phone exists.
You can even arrive by boat if you want to feel extra special about it. The breakfast menu keeps things simple with local eggs and real maple syrup. I sat near the window, watched the light hit the water, and felt something I had not felt in a long time.
No rush. No wifi.
Just peace.
A Story Built Into Every Wall
History has a way of making food taste better. At the 1958 Café, that history is literally hanging on the walls.
Family memorabilia, old photographs, and original signs from the Day family fill the space with a warmth that no interior designer could manufacture.
The café was created by Melissa and Kirt Furbush, with Melissa being the great-granddaughter of Jim and Mae Day, who first opened Day’s Store in 1958. That generational thread runs through every detail of the space.
You can feel the love and intention behind it all.
The décor is not just decorative, it is a living family album. Each piece tells a chapter of a story rooted in the Belgrade Lakes community.
Knowing that context makes sitting down for breakfast feel meaningful rather than ordinary.
For anyone who appreciates places with real roots, this café delivers something rare. It is a space that respects its past while welcoming new visitors with open arms.
That combination of heritage and hospitality is what makes the 1958 Café genuinely unforgettable.
The View of Long Pond That Makes You Linger
There is something about eating beside water that makes everything feel more relaxed. The 1958 Café sits right alongside Long Pond, offering views that are genuinely hard to pull yourself away from.
Whether you are sipping morning coffee or settling in for a long lunch, the lake is always right there.
The location itself is part of the experience. Belgrade Lakes is a quiet, beautiful corner of Maine, and Long Pond gives the area a peaceful, unhurried energy.
Sitting at the café with that view in front of you makes even a simple meal feel like a small celebration.
One of the most charming details is that the café is accessible by boat. There are 14 boat parking spots directly behind the store on Long Pond, which means you can arrive by water if you want to make the trip extra special.
That kind of access is rare and genuinely fun.
Whether you drive in or pull up by boat, the setting rewards you. The combination of lake views, fresh Maine air, and good food creates an atmosphere that is very easy to love and very hard to leave behind.
Breakfast Worth Waking Up Early For
Morning meals at the 1958 Café are the kind that make you want to set your alarm earlier than usual. The breakfast menu leans into local ingredients and comfort classics done with real care.
Local eggs, sausage, bacon, and bagels with cream cheese anchor the menu with familiar, satisfying options.
The standout is the Belgrade Benny, the café’s own take on eggs Benedict. It carries the name of the town with obvious pride, and it delivers on that promise with a rich, hearty plate that feels like a proper Maine morning.
French toast with Maine maple syrup rounds out the sweeter side of things beautifully.
Everything on the breakfast menu feels intentional rather than routine. Using local eggs and regional maple syrup means the ingredients themselves carry a sense of place.
That is what separates a good breakfast from a memorable one.
Breakfast here is not rushed. The atmosphere encourages you to linger over your coffee and enjoy the morning light coming off the pond.
Starting a day in Belgrade Lakes this way sets a tone that is genuinely hard to beat, no matter what the rest of the day holds.
Lunch and Dinner Done the Maine Way
When lunchtime rolls around at the 1958 Café, the menu shifts into satisfying, crowd-pleasing territory. Fish and chips is a natural fit for a lakeside spot, and the Reuben sandwich brings that classic deli energy that always hits right on a relaxed afternoon.
The gluten-free turkey melt shows the kitchen is thinking about everyone at the table.
The dinner options expand things further with pizzas, burgers, salads, and hot dogs rounding out a menu that has something for every appetite. None of it feels like an afterthought.
The variety is real, and the portions are built for people who have spent their day outdoors on the lake.
Eating dinner here as the sun starts to lower over Long Pond is a genuinely lovely experience. The café operates Wednesday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and offers Sunday brunch from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m., giving visitors plenty of windows to enjoy a meal.
The food stays connected to the place it is served in. Maine-style comfort food beside a Maine lake just makes sense, and the 1958 Café leans into that combination with confidence and consistency throughout every service.
Day’s Store: The Heart of Belgrade Lakes
The café does not exist in isolation. It lives inside Day’s Store, and that context matters enormously.
Day’s Store has been the heartbeat of Belgrade Lakes since 1958, serving as a general store, community hub, and gathering point for generations of locals and visitors alike.
The store carries groceries, fresh produce, deli items, homemade donuts, whoopie pies, fudge, and a range of local Maine products. Seasonal ice cream is available at Lakeside Scoops, which only adds to the appeal of a summer visit.
The cheese bread, mentioned with almost reverential enthusiasm by regular customers, has its own loyal following.
Shopping at Day’s Store before or after a meal at the café feels like a complete Belgrade Lakes experience. You pick up something local, something sweet, maybe a souvenir sweatshirt, and leave feeling like you genuinely visited rather than just passed through.
Family-owned businesses with this kind of staying power are increasingly rare. Day’s Store has earned its reputation over more than six decades, and the addition of the 1958 Café only deepens what this place means to the community it has served so faithfully for so long.
Homemade Treats That Deserve Their Own Spotlight
Some places earn their reputation one bite at a time, and Day’s Store has been doing exactly that for decades. The homemade donuts alone have inspired loyal customers to make early morning trips a non-negotiable part of their Belgrade Lakes routine.
Fresh, warm, and made with obvious care, they are the kind of treat that ruins supermarket donuts for you forever.
Whoopie pies are another standout, and in Maine, that is saying something. The state takes its whoopie pies seriously, and Day’s Store holds up its end of that tradition with versions that have earned genuine praise from visitors and regulars alike.
The fudge is another item that tends to disappear quickly once people discover it.
These homemade treats are not just snacks. They are souvenirs you can eat, little edible memories of a place that made you feel welcome.
Picking up a box of donuts or a bag of fudge on your way out is practically a tradition for anyone who has visited more than once.
The baked goods connect the café to the broader Day’s Store experience beautifully. Sweet, handmade, and deeply local, they reflect the same values that have kept this family business thriving for over sixty years.
A Seasonal Gem Worth Planning Your Trip Around
Timing matters when it comes to the 1958 Café. The café operates seasonally, closing during the winter months and reopening each spring, which gives every visit a slightly precious quality.
Knowing it will not be there year-round makes you appreciate it more when you are sitting inside with a plate of food and a lake view in front of you.
The café runs Wednesday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Sunday brunch from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Day’s Store itself is open seven days a week from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. throughout the season.
Planning a visit around those hours is easy enough, and the reward is absolutely worth the effort.
Belgrade Lakes is a summer destination that rewards slow travel. Coming here without a packed itinerary, just a plan to eat well and enjoy the pond, is genuinely one of the better ways to spend a Maine summer day.
The 1958 Café fits that pace perfectly.
Whether you arrive by car or pull up by boat, this place offers something that is increasingly hard to find: a real, rooted, family-made experience that feels completely authentic. Address: 182 Main Street, Belgrade, ME 04917.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
