Finding the entrance here takes a little detective work, nothing obvious marking what’s actually waiting just below street level.
Stepping downstairs feels like slipping into another decade entirely, dim lighting and hidden corners recreating an era that valued discretion over visibility. Italian dishes arrive with real care too, pasta made fresh and sauces layered deep enough to match the intensity of the setting.
Recreating a specific historical mood without turning it into a costume takes real restraint most themed spaces struggle to pull off successfully. This one manages it anyway, letting atmosphere enhance the meal rather than distract from it.
Few dinners transport guests this convincingly into another time. Minnesota hides this particular underground room where history and genuinely good Italian cooking share the same quiet space.
A Former VFW Hall With a Second Life
The building itself is half the fun here. Locals will tell you it was once the town’s VFW hall, and that history still shows in the bones of the place, thick walls, a solid old frame, and a basement that feels like it has stories.
Rather than gutting the character out of it, the space keeps a sense of age while feeling clean and comfortable. Upstairs is bright and social, with sightlines toward the kitchen and street. Downstairs is a different world entirely.
What struck me most was how natural the transition feels. You do not get the sense that someone bolted a theme onto a room. It reads as a building that simply grew into a new purpose.
For a town the size of Waconia, having a restaurant inside a landmark like this feels like a small win. Arrive a few minutes early and look around before sitting down.
Finding The Brass Hat Downstairs
Down a staircase from the main dining room sits The Brass Hat, and honestly, it is the reason half the visitors come. The lighting drops. The noise softens. Suddenly you are in a room that feels a century removed from the street above.
Brass accents, dark finishes, and low seating give it that classic hidden-lounge mood without tipping into costume territory. It is moody but still friendly, which is a tricky balance to pull off.
Groups seem to love it. There is enough room downstairs to seat a table of eight comfortably, and midweek evenings tend to be quieter, so you can actually hear each other talk.
Small tip from experience. If your whole plan is the underground room, mention it when you arrive or when booking, since seating upstairs and downstairs works a little differently.
Wood-Fired Pizza That Locals Talk About
Pizza is the single most mentioned thing about this place, and it earns the attention. Crusts come out of the wood-fired oven with blistered edges, a little char, and a chew that holds up under toppings instead of collapsing.
Options range from a simple bianca to bolder builds like harissa lamb sausage, prosciutto, or a mushroom-forward version with whipped cheese and a runny egg on top. There is a meatball one that tends to win over younger diners.
Portions run generous. Two people sharing one pizza plus a starter will usually leave full, which makes the pricing feel fairer than it first looks on the menu.
Kids sitting near the kitchen often end up watching the pies get stretched and loaded into the oven. It is a small detail, but it turns dinner into a bit of a show.
Smoked Duck and the Shares Menu
If one dish keeps coming up in conversation around here, it is the smoked duck. Served as a shareable plate, it pairs the smoky richness of the meat with tangy cheese and sweet cherries, and the combination somehow works better than it sounds on paper.
The Shares section in general is built for grazing. Duck focaccia, burrata, roasted cauliflower, and cheese bread with a basil-flecked marinara all show up regularly on tables.
Ordering strategy matters. Two or three shares split across a group gives you a wider taste of the kitchen than committing to one big entree each. Fun detail worth knowing. Desserts are made in house, so leaving room is genuinely a good idea.
Cheesecake, tiramisu, and a very moist chocolate cake all get repeat mentions from regulars who claim they were not planning on dessert.
Upstairs Dining With Street Views
The main floor plays a completely different role than the basement. Big windows face First Street, tables are spaced so you are not eating in someone’s elbow, and there is a calm, open feel to the room.
Some seats look out toward the sidewalk, others face the kitchen and oven area. Both have their appeal, though the kitchen-side tables tend to be more entertaining if you like watching food come together.
Design-wise, it leans warm and modern without feeling cold or overly designed. Nothing here shouts for attention.
Music is another quiet surprise. Nineties rock has turned up in the playlist more than once, which is not what most people expect from an upscale Italian menu, and somehow it fits.
Families, couples, and small groups all seem comfortable in the same room, which says a lot about how the space is arranged.
Service That Keeps Things Easy
Something that shows up again and again in talk about this restaurant is how smoothly the floor runs, even on packed nights. Plates arrive without long gaps, water glasses stay filled, and servers actually know the menu well enough to steer you.
Recommendations tend to be genuine rather than upsells. Ask what is working best that week and you will usually get a straight answer. Flexibility is part of the culture here too. Staff have been known to swap out a dish or drink that did not land right for a guest, no fuss involved.
Timing note for planners. Doors open at 11 AM Tuesday through Saturday with a 9 PM close, Sunday runs until 8 PM, and Monday is a day off. Weekend evenings fill up fast, so a reservation saves you a wait.
Seasonal Themes Like the Spookeasy
Come around October and the downstairs room gets a playful makeover known as the Spookeasy. Nothing over the top, just enough decoration to shift the mood a few degrees toward spooky.
Seasonal menu items rotate in alongside it, which gives regulars a reason to keep checking back. The kitchen seems to enjoy leaning into whatever time of year it is.
Quieter weeknights during these seasonal runs can be the sweet spot. Fewer people downstairs means the room feels almost private, and you get a better sense of the atmosphere without competing conversations.
Brunch Is the Underrated Visit
Most people show up here for dinner, which means brunch flies under the radar. Longtime visitors keep pointing newcomers toward it, and the daytime light in the upstairs room makes the whole space feel different.
Morning and midday visits also come with easier parking and a slower pace. No rush, no waiting list, just a relaxed table near the window. The same scratch kitchen approach carries over, so the quality does not drop just because the clock says eleven instead of seven.
Pairing a late brunch with a walk around Lake Waconia turns it into a proper half-day outing. The lake is minutes away, and the downtown blocks nearby are easy to wander on foot.
If you have only one shot at visiting, dinner still wins for atmosphere. But brunch is the version regulars quietly recommend to friends.
Pairing the Visit With Waconia
Plenty of travelers land here after spending an afternoon exploring the vineyards scattered around Carver County. Waconia sits in the middle of that little belt, and the restaurant makes an easy final stop before heading home.
Timing works nicely. Vineyard tours tend to wrap by late afternoon, and the kitchen stays open into the evening. Locals often point visitors straight to this address when asked where to eat, which is how a lot of out-of-towners end up discovering the underground lounge in the first place.
Parking rarely becomes a headache. Street spots nearby are usually available, even on busier nights, and the building is simple to find once you know the block.
Roughly forty minutes west of Minneapolis, it is close enough for a spontaneous drive and far enough to feel like an actual trip somewhere.
Planning the Trip and Getting There
Getting the details right makes this visit much smoother. Reservations help on Friday and Saturday nights, especially if a group is hoping for the downstairs room, and the website at bodegrays.com lays out current hours and menus.
Prices land where you would expect for a scratch kitchen doing wagyu steak, house pasta, and fresh desserts. Many people treat it as a special-occasion stop rather than a weekly habit.
Dress code is relaxed. Jeans fit in fine, though the basement lounge does invite dressing up a little if you feel like it. Come hungry, share a few plates, and give yourself time to explore both levels instead of rushing through one.
You will find it at 125 W 1st St, Waconia, MN 55387, closed Mondays, and easily one of the more memorable small-town dining rooms in the western metro.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
