Halloween in New York brings out the artistic side of pastry chefs across the city. Bakeries transform ordinary treats into spine-chilling masterpieces that are equal parts delicious and disturbing.
If you’re looking to indulge your sweet tooth while embracing the spooky season, these creepy confections will satisfy both cravings perfectly.
1. Milk Bar’s Cereal Milk Skull Cakes
Christina Tosi’s famous Milk Bar takes Halloween seriously with their limited-edition Cereal Milk Skull Cakes. These ghoulish treats maintain the bakery’s signature cereal milk flavor but come shaped like realistic human skulls, complete with eerily detailed eye sockets and teeth marks.
The skulls feature a creamy white exterior that’s airbrushed with subtle gray shadows to enhance the bone-like appearance. Inside, you’ll find layers of their famous cake and filling that create a striking contrast when sliced.
Available at all NYC locations throughout October, these cakes require advance ordering as they sell out quickly. The bakery also offers mini skull cake truffles for those wanting a smaller bite of the macabre.
2. Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery’s Bleeding Heart Cupcakes
The talented team at Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery creates cupcakes that might make you think twice before taking a bite. Their Bleeding Heart Cupcakes feature rich red velvet cake topped with vanilla buttercream that’s been sculpted to resemble anatomically correct hearts.
When you bite into these masterpieces, a surprise awaits; a hidden pocket of tart cherry filling oozes out like fresh blood. The effect is simultaneously gruesome and delicious, making these treats perfect for Halloween parties.
Located in the heart of Brooklyn, Mia’s also offers coffin-shaped cookies with personalized tombstone inscriptions that add a touch of dark humor to any Halloween gathering.
3. Little Cupcake Bakeshop’s Zombie Brain Cakes
Nestled in SoHo and Brooklyn, Little Cupcake Bakeshop transforms their normally cute offerings into something far more sinister each October. Their Zombie Brain Cakes feature intricately piped pink and gray buttercream that mimics the folds and textures of human brains with disturbing accuracy.
The cakes themselves are moist red velvet, creating the perfect base for the gory decoration. Raspberry coulis is drizzled strategically to simulate blood vessels and trauma spots, making these treats both a visual spectacle and conversation starter.
Despite their macabre appearance, these brain cakes taste heavenly with a perfect balance of sweetness and tang. Each cake serves 4-6 people and requires 48-hour advance ordering.
4. Magnolia Bakery’s Eyeball Pudding Cups
Magnolia Bakery puts a terrifying twist on their world-famous banana pudding with Halloween Eyeball Pudding Cups. These individual servings feature their classic creamy pudding base, but the top is decorated with realistic-looking eyeballs made from white chocolate, with vibrant blue or green irises and red veins hand-painted with food coloring.
The eyeballs seem to stare back at you as you dig your spoon into the dessert. When broken, the chocolate eyeballs reveal a surprise center of bright red strawberry sauce that oozes out dramatically.
Available at all NYC locations throughout October, these treats combine the familiar comfort of Magnolia’s pudding with just enough horror to make them perfect Halloween indulgences.
5. Mangia Bakery’s Witch Finger Cookies
Mangia Bakery transforms simple shortbread into nightmare fuel with their Witch Finger Cookies. These elongated treats are carefully sculpted to resemble severed human fingers, complete with knuckle wrinkles, fingernails made of sliced almonds, and strategic “wounds” where raspberry jam peeks through like exposed flesh.
The bakery uses a buttery shortbread base that provides the perfect canvas for these gruesome creations. The cookies maintain a pale, corpse-like color that enhances their disturbing realism, while the texture remains perfectly crumbly and delicious.
Mangia packages these fingers in elegant black boxes tied with orange ribbon, making them a popular gift for Halloween parties across Manhattan. Their seasonal cookie boxes include an assortment of fingers in various states of decay.
6. Martha’s Country Bakery’s Pumpkin Spice Mummy Cakes
Martha’s Country Bakery in Astoria has perfected the art of festive frights with their Pumpkin Spice Mummy Cakes. These individual-sized treats feature moist pumpkin spice cake wrapped in thin strips of white fondant that mimic ancient mummy bandages.
Two candy eyeballs peek out from between the wrappings, giving these desserts an adorably spooky personality. When sliced open, the vibrant orange cake reveals a cream cheese filling studded with candied pumpkin pieces, creating a delicious contrast of textures and flavors.
The bakery’s Queens location becomes a Halloween destination each October, with lines often stretching down the block as New Yorkers clamor for these seasonal specialties. Martha’s also offers ghost-shaped versions for those who prefer their mummies with a different paranormal twist.
7. William Greenberg Desserts’ Spider Infestation Black & Orange Cookies
The iconic William Greenberg Desserts on Madison Avenue gives their famous black and white cookies a Halloween makeover with Spider Infestation Black & Orange Cookies. These oversized treats maintain the bakery’s signature soft texture but feature orange and black icing instead of the traditional colors.
What makes these cookies truly spine-tingling is the addition of incredibly realistic sugar-spun spiders that appear to be crawling across the surface. The bakery uses a special technique to create spiders with delicate legs and detailed bodies that look alarmingly lifelike.
Some cookies even feature tiny “egg sacs” of smaller spiders or intricate webs spun from pulled sugar. Despite their creepy appearance, the cookies maintain the perfect balance of vanilla and chocolate flavors that made the bakery famous.
8. Mia’s Bakery’s Ghost Halloween Cakes
Mia’s Bakery on the Upper East Side creates ethereal Ghost Halloween Cakes that seem to float above their display cases. These supernatural confections feature cloud-like white meringue frosting hand-piped to create ghostly figures with expressions ranging from friendly to frightening.
The ghosts hover above layers of midnight-black chocolate cake infused with espresso, creating a striking contrast when sliced. Some ghosts even contain a surprise; a hollow center filled with edible candy bones or small chocolate skulls that spill out when the cake is cut.
Available by pre-order only, these spectral creations have developed a cult following among Manhattan’s Halloween enthusiasts. The bakery recommends ordering at least a week in advance as they create each ghost cake by hand.
9. Dominique Ansel Bakery’s Bleeding Chocolate Hearts
The culinary genius behind the Cronut, Dominique Ansel, creates anatomically correct Bleeding Chocolate Hearts each Halloween at his SoHo bakery. These palm-sized chocolate sculptures mimic human hearts with incredible detail, showing ventricles, arteries, and textured surfaces that glisten under the bakery lights.
Made from dark chocolate shells, each heart contains a center of raspberry coulis and chocolate ganache. When pierced with a fork, the filling flows out like blood, creating a theatrical dining experience that delights and disturbs in equal measure.
Ansel’s team hand-paints each heart with edible red and blue luster dust to enhance the realism. The hearts come packaged in clear anatomical boxes with black ribbon, making them popular gifts for medical professionals with a dark sense of humor.
10. Levain Bakery’s Monster Claw Cookies
The famously chunky cookies of Levain Bakery transform into Monster Claw Cookies during the Halloween season. These massive treats maintain the bakery’s signature gooey center but come shaped like monstrous claws with pointed fingertips and knuckle ridges.
Available in their classic chocolate chip walnut recipe, these cookies feature green-tinted dough with black chocolate chunks that enhance their otherworldly appearance. Each claw is dusted with a mixture of edible gold powder and “dirt” made from crushed chocolate cookies to give them an aged, just-emerged-from-the-grave look.
Lines at their Upper West Side location grow even longer during October as New Yorkers and tourists alike seek out these limited-edition treats. The bakery produces only a small batch each day, making them a coveted Halloween trophy.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
