I’ve been on a meaty mission across the Golden State, friends, and my taste buds are still thanking me! California’s steakhouse scene isn’t just about fancy cuts and high prices – it’s increasingly about sustainable, local, grass-fed beef that tastes incredible while supporting regional ranchers. These 12 restaurants have mastered the art of preparing beef that’s raised the right way, with flavors that simply can’t be matched by conventional steakhouses.
1. Harris’ Restaurant: San Francisco’s Temple of Beef
If you’ve never experienced Harris’ dry-aged, grass-fed steaks, you’re missing one of life’s great pleasures! This San Francisco institution has been serving exceptional beef since 1984, but their recent shift toward locally sourced, grass-fed options has elevated their menu to new heights.
Their bone-in ribeye, sourced from Stemple Creek Ranch in Marin County, delivers a flavor complexity that makes conventional steaks seem one-dimensional. The restaurant’s dark wood paneling and live jazz create the perfect backdrop for savoring every bite.
Though pricey, Harris’ commitment to quality is evident in each perfectly seared morsel. Their sommeliers expertly pair local wines with your grass-fed selection, creating a truly memorable Northern California dining experience.
2. Bear & Star: Cowboy Luxury in Los Olivos
Hidden in the heart of Santa Barbara wine country, Bear & Star represents ranch-to-table dining at its finest. What makes this place extraordinary? They raise their own grass-fed cattle on the 714-acre Fess Parker Ranch just seven miles away!
Chef John Cox creates magic with these pampered beeves, serving up tomahawk steaks with flavors so distinct you’ll swear you can taste the local terroir. The restaurant’s upscale ranch aesthetic – think leather, wood, and iron – perfectly complements the robust flavors on your plate.
My personal favorite is their grass-fed beef tartare, topped with a quail egg and served with house-made potato crisps. Though Bear & Star closed temporarily during the pandemic, they’ve reopened with an even stronger commitment to showcasing their exceptional ranch-raised beef.
3. The Hitching Post II: Sideways into Steak Heaven
Made famous by the movie “Sideways,” this Santa Barbara County gem has been grilling some of California’s finest grass-fed beef over red oak since 1986. However, unlike the Hollywood spotlight might suggest, the real star here isn’t the wine – it’s the steak!
Owner Frank Ostini sources his grass-fed beef from local ranches throughout the Central Coast, ensuring peak flavor and tenderness. Their Santa Maria-style barbecue technique – cooking over native red oak coals – imparts a distinctive smokiness that perfectly complements the natural richness of grass-fed beef.
While waiting for your steak, enjoy their house-made pinquito beans and grilled garlic bread. The unpretentious roadhouse atmosphere adds to the charm, making this a must-visit for anyone traveling through Buellton.
4. House of Prime Rib: San Francisco’s Beef Institution
Though they’ve been carving prime rib tableside since 1949, House of Prime Rib has evolved with the times by incorporating grass-fed options from California ranches. Walking into this San Francisco landmark feels like stepping into a British gentlemen’s club – all dark wood, brass accents, and the intoxicating aroma of roasting beef.
Their grass-fed prime rib is aged 21 days before being slowly roasted in rock salt, creating a crust that seals in juices while the meat reaches buttery tenderness. The tableside carving ceremony adds theatrical flair to an already special meal.
Despite their traditional approach, they’ve embraced sustainable ranching practices without sacrificing their signature flavor. Reservations are notoriously difficult to secure – I recommend booking weeks in advance for this uniquely San Franciscan experience.
5. Jocko’s Steakhouse: Nipomo’s No-Frills Flavor Bomb
Nothing about Jocko’s screams luxury – the decor hasn’t changed since the 1970s, and you might wait two hours for a table despite your reservation. Yet locals and in-the-know travelers flock here for what might be California’s most intensely flavored grass-fed steaks, cooked over native red oak.
Family-owned since 1925, Jocko’s sources their grass-fed beef from ranches within a 50-mile radius. Their Spencer steak (their name for ribeye) develops a magnificent crust over the oak-fired pit while remaining perfectly pink inside.
Come hungry – portions are enormous, and each entrée includes soup, salad, beans, salsa, garlic bread, and dessert! Though the service can be gruff and the ambiance decidedly casual, the primal satisfaction of their perfectly cooked local beef makes this Central Coast institution worth every minute of the wait.
6. Gwen: Hollywood’s Butcher-to-Table Masterpiece
Celebrity chef Curtis Stone’s Hollywood restaurant Gwen isn’t just a steakhouse – it’s a temple to the entire art of butchery. The front of the restaurant houses a European-style butcher shop where they break down whole, grass-fed animals from California farms.
Unlike conventional steakhouses, Gwen’s menu changes based on what parts of the animal are available, encouraging diners to explore cuts beyond the typical filet or ribeye. Their fire-cooking techniques – from grilling to smoking to roasting – showcase the exceptional flavor of their grass-fed beef.
Though certainly upscale (the tasting menu starts at $145), Gwen offers a rare opportunity to experience nose-to-tail dining at its finest. The restaurant’s stunning Art Deco interior, with its soaring ceilings and open kitchen, provides a theatrical backdrop for this celebration of sustainable California ranching.
7. Cattlemen’s Restaurant: A Petaluma Legacy Since 1968
Nestled in an Anaheim office park, The Ranch Restaurant has an unexpected location, yet what happens inside this elegant space is pure culinary excellence. The restaurant is renowned for its farm-to-table program, which sources much of its produce – including a wide variety of vegetables and herbs – directly from its private farm, Edwards Ranch Estates, in the foothills of the Santa Ana Mountains.
The Ranch’s culinary team is now led by Executive Chef Pedro Garcia and Chef de Cuisine Raul Garcia. While their menu showcases farm-fresh produce, their exceptional beef is sourced from top-quality suppliers. One popular item is their 28-day dry-aged New York Delmonico, which has a concentrated flavor that showcases the restaurant’s commitment to quality.
Despite being surrounded by theme parks, The Ranch feels worlds away with its sophisticated atmosphere and impeccable service. Given the restaurant’s popularity and accolades, including a mention in the MICHELIN Guide, reservations are essential to secure a table at this Orange County destination.
8. The Ranch Restaurant: Orange County’s Hidden Gem
Nestled in an Anaheim office park, The Ranch Restaurant has an unexpected location, yet what happens inside this elegant space is pure culinary excellence. The restaurant is renowned for its farm-to-table program, which sources much of its produce – including a wide variety of vegetables and herbs – directly from its private farm, Edwards Ranch Estates, in the foothills of the Santa Ana Mountains.
The Ranch’s culinary team is now led by Executive Chef Pedro Garcia and Chef de Cuisine Raul Garcia. While their menu showcases farm-fresh produce, their exceptional beef is sourced from top-quality suppliers. One popular item is their 28-day dry-aged New York Delmonico, which has a concentrated flavor that showcases the restaurant’s commitment to quality.
Despite being surrounded by theme parks, The Ranch feels worlds away with its sophisticated atmosphere and impeccable service. Given the restaurant’s popularity and accolades, including a mention in the MICHELIN Guide, reservations are essential to secure a table at this Orange County destination.
9. Cole’s Chop House: Napa Valley’s Beef and Wine Paradise
While Napa Valley might be wine country, Cole’s Chop House proves that exceptional grass-fed beef deserves equal billing with those famous Cabernets. Located in a historic stone building in downtown Napa, this classic steakhouse has embraced the region’s agricultural bounty by featuring beef from nearby ranches.
Their 21-day dry-aged New York strip, sourced from grass-fed cattle raised in Sonoma and Napa counties, develops a concentrated nuttiness that pairs brilliantly with local red wines. The restaurant’s elegant yet comfortable atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between special occasion and relaxed wine country dining.
Beyond steaks, their starters showcase other local producers – don’t miss the Sonoma County foie gras or Point Reyes blue cheese wedge salad. After a day of wine tasting, Cole’s provides the perfect protein-rich ending to your Napa adventure.
10. Buckhorn Steakhouse: Winters’ Historic Beef Destination
Housed in a 19th-century brick building in the charming town of Winters, Buckhorn Steakhouse has been serving exceptional beef since 1980. Though they made their name with their famous tri-tip sandwich, their commitment to locally sourced grass-fed options has made them a destination for sustainable meat enthusiasts.
Their grass-fed ribeye, sourced from nearby Yolo County ranches, spends time in their custom-built aging room before being hand-cut and grilled over almond wood – a distinctly Northern California touch. The restaurant’s historic ambiance, with exposed brick walls and vintage photos, creates a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Beyond beef, they offer spectacular locally sourced sides – their creamed spinach with Point Reyes blue cheese is worth the drive alone! For a true taste of California’s agricultural heritage, Buckhorn delivers both history and forward-thinking sustainability on every plate.
11. Selanne Steak Tavern: Laguna Beach’s Coastal Beef Haven
Owned by Hockey Hall of Famer Teemu Selanne, this upscale Laguna Beach establishment might seem an unlikely champion of sustainable ranching. Yet their grass-fed program, featuring beef from California coastal ranches, has become central to their identity since opening in 2013.
Their 30-day aged grass-fed ribeye develops exceptional flavor while maintaining the nutritional benefits that make grass-fed beef so desirable. The restaurant’s location in a beautifully restored 1934 cottage adds character to an already special dining experience.
Though certainly splurge-worthy, Selanne’s commitment to quality extends beyond the beef to their impressive seafood options and vegetable sides sourced from local farms. The outdoor patio, with its ocean breezes and twinkling lights, provides the perfect Southern California setting for enjoying their sustainable steaks.
12. 1880 Union Hotel Restaurant: Los Alamos’ Historic Beef Journey
Stepping into the 1880 Union Hotel Restaurant feels like traveling back to California’s Wild West days – fitting, since this Los Alamos landmark was once a Wells Fargo stagecoach stop. Today, their kitchen combines that historic atmosphere with thoroughly modern sustainable practices.
Their grass-fed beef comes from ranches throughout Santa Barbara County, including several that have been raising cattle on the same land since the Spanish colonial era. The signature dish – a grass-fed hanger steak with chimichurri – highlights the mineral-rich flavors that develop when cattle graze on native California grasses.
While enjoying your meal in the original 19th-century dining room, you might notice local ranchers at nearby tables – a testament to the restaurant’s deep connections to the agricultural community. Their cocktail program, featuring spirits from local distilleries, provides the perfect complement to their exceptional steaks.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
