The Florida Keys, a paradise of turquoise waters and fresh seafood, has become a victim of its own success. Once-quiet local haunts now buzz with visitors eager to sample authentic Keys cuisine. While these seafood spots still serve up delicious catches, the experience has changed as tourism booms. Here’s a look at eight beloved Florida Keys seafood joints that locals say have become tourist magnets.
1. The Island Fish Co. Restaurant & Tiki Bar: Sunset Stampede
Thatched umbrellas dot the waterfront deck where patrons jostle for the best sunset views. Marathon’s most photographed tiki bar now serves more tourists than fishermen, with specialty drinks named after local landmarks and served in souvenir glasses.
Blackened mahi tacos remain the star menu item, though the portion size has shrunk as demand increased. Arriving an hour before sunset is mandatory if you want a table with a water view.
Live musicians strum Jimmy Buffett covers while visitors line the railing to photograph the spectacular orange-pink sunsets. A resident manatee occasionally surfaces near the dock, causing a frenzy of camera phones and squeals from delighted tourists.
2. Conch Republic Seafood Company: Historic Seaport Hotspot
Fishing boats once unloaded their daily catch where tourists now snap photos with frozen drinks. This waterfront eatery in Key West’s Historic Seaport draws crowds with its Caribbean-spiced conch fritters and fresh mahi-mahi sandwiches.
Locals shake their heads at the hour-long wait times during sunset, remembering when they could grab a quick meal here after work. The restaurant’s nautical decor and harbor views remain stunning, but prices have doubled as popularity soared.
Their key lime pie still wins awards, though you might need to elbow through a crowd of sunburned visitors to order a slice. Fun fact: The restaurant’s name references the Keys’ mock secession from the US in 1982.
3. Robbie’s of Islamorada: Tarpon-Feeding Frenzy
Massive silver tarpon splash alongside the dock as tourists toss fish from plastic buckets. What started as a local fishing spot has transformed into Islamorada’s most visited attraction, where feeding the famous tarpon costs $5 per bucket.
The open-air restaurant serves decent fried grouper sandwiches and conch salad, but you’ll pay premium prices for the experience. Parking has become a nightmare, with tour buses lining the narrow lot most afternoons.
Pelicans waddle between tables hoping for scraps while souvenir shops sell everything from shell necklaces to tarpon-themed t-shirts. Locals now visit only during off-season weekdays when the cruise ship crowds thin out.
4. Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet: All-You-Can-Eat Attraction
Tour buses regularly disgorge hungry visitors at this massive Islamorada buffet restaurant. Once a fisherman’s breakfast spot, it now features an endless seafood spread that draws cruise excursions and road-trippers alike.
Stone crab claws vanish minutes after being refilled, while the raw bar requires strategic timing to score fresh oysters. The restaurant’s harborside location offers beautiful views, but good luck finding a window seat without a reservation made weeks in advance.
Quality has suffered as quantity increased, according to longtime Keys residents who remember when local fishermen supplied most of the catch. Still, the restaurant’s all-you-can-eat snow crab legs remain a powerful draw for visitors determined to get their money’s worth.
5. Half Shell Raw Bar: From Shucking House to Selfie Central
Dollar bills and polaroid photos blanket the ceiling of this former shrimp warehouse in Key West’s Historic Seaport. Raw oysters slide across the weathered bar top where commercial fishermen once traded stories after long days at sea.
Today, visitors line up for the perfect Instagram shot with the iconic “Half Shell Raw Bar” t-shirt. The peel-and-eat shrimp remain deliciously fresh, though prices have climbed steadily with each travel blog mention.
Bartenders who’ve worked here for decades can tell you exactly when the shift happened – somewhere around 2010 when food TV shows discovered the authentic dive bar atmosphere. Now they serve more rum runners than beer to tourists seeking that authentic “Keys experience” they read about online.
6. Sunset Pier: Duval Street’s Colorful Finale
Rainbow-colored chairs and umbrella-topped tables create a kaleidoscope effect at the end of Key West’s famous Duval Street. Sunset Pier has transformed from a quiet spot to watch the day end into a must-visit destination for every Key West visitor.
Cruise ship passengers flood the pier each afternoon, cameras ready for the celebrated Key West sunset. The conch ceviche remains excellent, but you’ll pay nearly double what it cost five years ago.
Street performers and live bands create a carnival atmosphere as the sun dips toward the horizon. Locals now avoid this once-favorite spot entirely during high season, lamenting how the authentic island vibe has been replaced by what one resident called “a tropical theme park experience.”
7. Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant: Key Largo’s Crustacean Celebration
Bright yellow walls and lobster-themed everything greet visitors to this Key Largo landmark. The restaurant’s famous butter-poached Florida lobster tails have earned it a spot in numerous travel guides, leading to reservation lists that fill weeks in advance during winter months.
Parking overflows onto the highway shoulder most evenings as rental cars and tour vans jockey for spots. Locals remember when they could walk in for dinner on a Friday night without planning ahead.
The quality remains high – the owner still selects seafood personally each morning – but the intimate atmosphere has vanished. “Used to be you knew everyone in the place,” one longtime server confided. “Now I’m lucky if I see two local tables a night.”
8. Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House: Highway Holdout
Positioned perfectly along the Overseas Highway in Marathon, this restaurant captures road-trippers heading south toward Key West. The marquee sign advertising “FRESH CATCH DAILY” hasn’t changed in decades, but nearly everything else has.
Once a quiet dinner spot for locals, the restaurant now processes tourists with assembly-line efficiency. Surf and turf platters fly from the kitchen to tables turned three times each evening during peak season.
The panoramic water views remain spectacular, and the stone crab claws are still harvested locally when in season. Yet longtime residents reminisce about when conversations with the owner were part of the experience, before he needed five hosts just to manage the waiting list that stretches out the door most nights.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
