New York State is home to some incredible ice cream shops that fly under the radar. Beyond the famous chains and tourist spots, these hidden gems offer unique flavors and experiences you won’t find anywhere else. Whether you’re looking for unusual flavor combinations or nostalgic settings, these secret ice cream havens are worth seeking out on your next adventure across the Empire State.
1. UES Ice Cream: The Speakeasy Scoop
Behind a bright pink storefront in Manhattan’s Upper East Side hides a delicious secret. UES Ice Cream serves premium Soco Creamery scoops by day, but those in the know can access a hidden cocktail bar through the freezer door.
The contrast between the cheerful ice cream parlor and the sophisticated speakeasy creates an unforgettable experience. Locals love their signature bourbon-infused ice cream that bridges both worlds.
Founded by a former Wall Street banker seeking a sweeter career path, this shop has perfected the art of surprise while maintaining excellence in both frozen treats and mixology.
2. Surprise Scoop: Mystery Flavors in the East Village
Gambling meets dessert at this East Village kiosk where daring customers put their taste buds in the hands of fate. Surprise Scoop’s ‘flavor roulette’ concept eliminates decision paralysis – simply order the mystery flavor and prepare for a taste adventure.
The minimalist kiosk, tucked between two larger storefronts, often goes unnoticed by passersby. What began as a pandemic pivot has become a cult favorite among adventure-seeking New Yorkers.
The mystery flavors change daily, ranging from comforting classics to boundary-pushing combinations like lavender honey sriracha or blackberry balsamic basil.
3. Max & Mina’s: Flushing’s Flavor Laboratory
Since 1997, this quirky kosher ice cream shop in Flushing has been pushing the boundaries of what ice cream can be. The walls are plastered with cereal boxes and pop culture memorabilia, creating a nostalgic backdrop for their experimental flavors.
Brothers Bruce and Mark Becker draw inspiration from unlikely sources – their grandmother’s recipe cards, customer suggestions, and sometimes pure whimsy. Their rotating menu has featured everything from lox to garlic to breakfast cereal-infused creations.
Despite the occasional eyebrow-raising flavor (beer and horseradish, anyone?), the texture remains consistently creamy and delicious, earning them loyal fans who drive hours for a taste.
4. Chinatown Ice Cream Factory: Cultural Scoops Since 1977
Tucked away on Bayard Street, this family-owned gem has been introducing New Yorkers to Asian-inspired ice cream flavors for over four decades. What makes this place special isn’t just its longevity but its clever approach to flavor categories.
‘Regular’ flavors here include red bean, black sesame, and durian, while ‘exotic’ options list vanilla and chocolate. This playful reversal delights visitors while celebrating Asian culinary traditions.
The tiny shop often has lines spilling onto the street, but the wait provides time to admire the countless photos of celebrities who’ve stopped by for a scoop of their handcrafted delights.
5. Parkside Candy: Buffalo’s Time Capsule Treat
Stepping into Parkside Candy feels like traveling back to 1927 when this Buffalo institution first opened its marble counters to eager customers. The preserved Art Deco interior, complete with original soda fountain equipment and ornate light fixtures, creates an authentic vintage experience.
Their famous sponge candy ice cream combines Buffalo’s signature confection with creamy homemade ice cream. Fourth-generation candy makers still use original recipes and techniques passed down through the family.
Once a filming location for ‘The Natural’ starring Robert Redford, this historic shop survived numerous challenges including the Great Depression and nearly closing in 2016 before a successful community-funded restoration.
6. Ray’s Candy Store: East Village’s 24-Hour Sweet Spot
At 89 years young, Ray himself still serves customers at this cramped East Village institution that’s been operating around the clock since 1974. The unassuming storefront on Avenue A might not look special, but locals know it as the neighborhood’s beating heart.
Famous for egg creams, beignets, and soft-serve ice cream, Ray’s has survived gentrification while maintaining affordable prices. The walls are covered with decades of photos, news clippings, and handwritten notes from grateful customers.
During tough times, neighborhood residents have organized fundraisers to keep Ray’s afloat – a testament to how this humble ice cream counter transcends being just a business to become a beloved community anchor.
7. Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory: Scoops with a View
Housed in a converted 1920s fireboat house beneath the Brooklyn Bridge, this charming ice cream shop combines spectacular waterfront views with artisanal frozen treats. The historic brick building stands in stark contrast to Manhattan’s modern skyline visible just across the East River.
Owner Mark Thompson, a former Wall Street executive, abandoned finance to pursue his passion for pure, preservative-free ice cream. His philosophy of quality over quantity means you’ll find only eight classic flavors, each perfected through years of testing.
On summer evenings, the line often stretches along the promenade as sunset-watchers wait patiently for hand-packed pints and cones worth every minute of anticipation.
8. Maple Creamery: Vermont Inspiration in Brooklyn
A taste of New England has found its way to Brooklyn thanks to this plant-based ice cream shop inspired by Vermont’s famous maple creemees. The cozy, wood-paneled interior features vintage maple tapping equipment and photographs of northeastern sugar houses.
Unlike typical vegan ice creams that rely on coconut or nuts, Maple Creamery uses organic maple syrup from a family farm in Vermont as both sweetener and flavor enhancer. Their signature matcha lemonade and strawberry shortcake flavors have developed cult followings among dairy and non-dairy eaters alike.
Founded by a former environmental scientist, the shop maintains strict sustainability practices, including compostable packaging and a discount program for customers who bring reusable containers.
9. Sweet Melissa’s: Ithaca’s Homemade Haven
Nestled among Ithaca’s famous gorges, this unassuming shop has become a mandatory stop for Cornell students and Finger Lakes visitors alike. The cheerful yellow Victorian house-turned-ice-cream-parlor features a wraparound porch where customers savor scoops while watching Cayuga Lake sunsets.
Owner Melissa Richards, a former pastry chef, sources ingredients from surrounding farms, including berries, herbs, and honey. Their rotating seasonal menu reflects the agricultural rhythm of upstate New York, with flavors like summer corn custard and foraged blackberry appearing at peak freshness.
A hidden garden path behind the shop leads to secluded seating areas among herb plants used in their unique flavor creations.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
