Northern Indiana holds some of America’s largest Amish communities, but most visitors stick to the same busy highways and tourist spots.
Beyond the crowded main roads lie peaceful country lanes where horse-drawn buggies still outnumber cars, and hand-painted signs point to family farms selling fresh bread and handmade quilts.
These hidden trails offer a genuine glimpse into Amish life that guidebooks rarely mention.
1. The Backroads of LaGrange County
Skip the traffic on US 20 and discover County Roads 100 through 200 instead. These winding lanes cut through some of the prettiest farmland you’ll ever see, where Amish families tend their crops the old-fashioned way.
Small roadside stands appear without warning, selling everything from fresh produce to handcrafted wooden toys. Quilt shops tucked into converted barns display colorful patterns passed down through generations.
The best part? You might drive for miles without seeing another tourist, just endless fields and the occasional buggy clip-clopping past.
2. The Elkhart River Valley Loop
Follow the curves of the Elkhart River through Goshen, Bristol, and New Paris for a completely different experience. Water views mix with traditional farmland, creating landscapes that feel almost magical during sunrise.
Hidden canoeing spots appear along the route where locals launch their kayaks on quiet mornings. Family bakeries sit just off the main path, their parking lots filled with buggies rather than cars.
Bring your appetite because these bakeries serve pies and pastries that will ruin store-bought desserts for you forever.
3. The Nappanee Area Perimeter
Circle Nappanee on the county roads that form a loose perimeter around town. Both Amish and Mennonite families run businesses here, creating an amazing concentration of craftsmanship in one area.
Custom cabinetry shops open their doors to show furniture being built entirely by hand. Craft stores display pottery, baskets, and wooden items that make shopping malls look silly by comparison.
Many shops operate on the honor system, with a simple cash box for payments when the family is working in the fields.
4. The Pumpkinvine Nature Trail Corridor
An old railway line became the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail, and the county roads running alongside it offer fantastic views. Amish families actually use this trail with their buggies, making it feel like stepping back in time.
Watch for children riding scooters along the path while their parents guide horses pulling wagons loaded with supplies. The farms here seem especially well-kept, with gardens bursting with vegetables and flowers.
Spring brings incredible wildflower displays that transform the trail corridor into a natural art gallery.
5. County Road 16 East from Elkhart
County Road 16 heading east from Elkhart toward Bristol doesn’t curve much, but don’t let that fool you. This straight shot passes through incredibly dense Amish farmland where traditional farming methods are still the norm.
You’ll frequently spot horse-drawn plows, seeders, and hay wagons working the fields during planting and harvest seasons. Farmers wave from their equipment, genuinely friendly rather than performing for tourists.
The simplicity of this route makes it perfect for photographers wanting unobstructed views of authentic farm life.
6. The Heritage Trail Connector Roads
Everyone knows about the Heritage Trail, but the tiny spurs and connector roads branching off US 6 and US 33 remain wonderfully quiet. These forgotten lanes lead to the most secluded corners of Amish country.
Laundry flaps on clotheslines stretching across yards where barefoot children play simple games. Vegetable gardens grow right up to the road’s edge, and chickens wander freely around farmhouses.
These connectors show daily life without any tourist polish, which makes them absolutely perfect for understanding how these communities actually function.
7. The Small Lakes Region Drive
Around Syracuse and Lake Wawasee, something unusual happens where Amish agriculture meets lakeside vacation culture. Roads connecting these small towns create a landscape unlike anywhere else in Amish country.
Cornfields suddenly give way to glimpses of sparkling water, then back to traditional farms again. The contrast feels almost surreal but somehow works beautifully together.
Fewer tourists discover this area because it doesn’t fit the typical Amish country image, which means you’ll have these peaceful roads mostly to yourself year-round.
8. State Road 13 North of Syracuse
State Road 13 between Syracuse and Middlebury carries far less traffic than US 20, making it a surprisingly peaceful alternative. This section reveals aspects of community life that faster roads miss completely.
Amish schools appear along the route, their playgrounds filled with children during recess hours. Community gatherings happen in plain sight during daylight, showing the strong social bonds these settlements maintain.
Time your drive for mid-morning or early afternoon to witness the most activity and get a real sense of daily rhythms.
9. The Berne and Adams County Area
Way over in eastern Indiana, Berne gets overlooked by nearly every tourist heading to the more famous northern settlements. This Swiss-Amish community offers something completely different from typical Amish areas.
Swiss architectural influences appear in building styles you won’t see anywhere else in Indiana. The traditions here blend Swiss heritage with Amish practices, creating a unique cultural mix.
Local restaurants serve Swiss-influenced dishes alongside traditional Amish cooking, and the craft shops reflect this interesting cultural combination in their handmade goods.
10. The Topeka and Emma Region
Blink while driving through Topeka or Emma and you’ll completely miss them. These tiny communities represent the quietest corners of Indiana’s Amish country, where tourism hasn’t really arrived yet.
Home-based businesses operate from converted barns and outbuildings, advertised only by hand-painted signs at driveways. Furniture makers, jam producers, and quilt sewers work from these humble locations.
Shopping here requires slowing down, watching carefully, and being willing to knock on doors, but the quality and prices make the effort incredibly worthwhile.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
