Pennsylvania’s rich culinary heritage offers travelers a chance to take home flavors that tell the story of the state’s diverse cultural influences. From Pennsylvania Dutch classics to Philadelphia favorites, these local treats make perfect souvenirs that will remind you of your journey through the Keystone State.
Before you head home from your Pennsylvania adventure, make room in your luggage for these mouthwatering local specialties that friends and family will thank you for sharing.
1. Shoofly Pie: A Sweet Slice Of Pennsylvania Dutch History
The molasses-rich aroma of Shoofly Pie has been wafting through Pennsylvania Dutch Country for generations. This iconic dessert features a sticky bottom layer of sweet molasses topped with crumbly streusel that creates a unique texture experience with every bite.
Many bakeries throughout Lancaster County sell travel-ready versions that stay fresh for days. The pie originated when the Pennsylvania Dutch settlers created recipes with staple ingredients available during winter months when fresh fruit was scarce.
Modern variations might include chocolate or nuts, but traditionalists insist the classic recipe reigns supreme. Pack this sweet treat carefully in your suitcase, and you’ll bring home an authentic taste of Pennsylvania’s cultural heritage that has delighted residents since the 1880s.
2. Scrapple: The Breakfast Delicacy You’ll Crave Later
Pennsylvania farmers created scrapple as a clever way to use every part of the pig, transforming humble ingredients into a breakfast staple. This savory loaf combines pork scraps with cornmeal and spices, formed into a block that’s sliced and fried until crispy on the outside yet tender inside.
Local butcher shops and farmers markets throughout Pennsylvania sell vacuum-sealed scrapple that travels well. Unlike its fancy cousin bacon, scrapple represents Pennsylvania’s practical, waste-nothing approach to food.
Many visitors initially approach this regional specialty with hesitation but leave as devoted fans. The contrast between the crunchy exterior and soft interior creates a textural masterpiece that pairs perfectly with maple syrup or ketchup, depending on which side of the sweet-versus-savory debate you land.
3. Lebanon Bologna: The Tangy Cured Meat That Defines A County
Named after Lebanon County where it originated, this distinctive smoked beef sausage delivers a tangy, slightly sweet flavor profile unlike any other deli meat. The slow smoking process over hardwood chips gives Lebanon Bologna its characteristic deep red color and rich taste that Pennsylvania natives miss terribly when they move away.
Available in sweet or regular varieties, this cured meat keeps well without refrigeration for short periods, making it perfect for travel. Vacuum-sealed packages from brands like Seltzer’s have been produced since 1902, using the same time-honored techniques.
Locals enjoy it sliced thin on sandwiches, cubed with cheese as a snack, or even fried as a breakfast meat. The fermentation process creates a complex flavor that develops as it ages, similar to a fine wine but in convenient sandwich form.
4. Whoopie Pies: The Handheld Joy Of Amish Country
Legend has it that when Amish farmers found these treats in their lunchboxes, they would shout “Whoopie!” – hence the playful name that perfectly captures the childlike delight they inspire. These sandwich-style desserts feature two soft, cake-like chocolate cookies embracing a cloud of sweet, creamy filling.
Traditional Amish bakeries throughout Lancaster County craft these treats daily, often wrapping them individually for travelers. While chocolate with vanilla filling remains the classic combination, Pennsylvania bakers have expanded the flavor universe to include pumpkin, red velvet, and even maple variations.
The perfect whoopie pie maintains a delicate balance – not too sweet, with cookies that yield gently when bitten but don’t crumble apart. Their portable nature makes them ideal travel companions, though you might find your supply mysteriously diminishing during your journey home.
5. Soft Pretzels: Philadelphia’s Twisted Treasure
Philadelphia soft pretzels bear little resemblance to their shopping mall counterparts found elsewhere in America. These dense, chewy wonders feature a distinctive elongated figure-eight shape and a perfectly browned exterior dotted with coarse salt that provides a satisfying crunch against the pillowy interior.
German immigrants brought pretzel-making techniques to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, and the tradition evolved into the unique style now synonymous with Philadelphia street food. Most pretzel bakeries offer special vacuum-sealed versions that stay fresh for days.
The proper way to enjoy them, according to locals, involves a generous smear of spicy brown mustard, though purists insist they need no accompaniment. These iconic treats connect modern visitors to Pennsylvania’s German heritage while providing a portable, satisfying snack that travels remarkably well.
6. Apple Butter: Autumn In A Jar
The copper kettles used to make traditional Pennsylvania Dutch apple butter have stirred this concentrated apple spread for generations. Unlike applesauce, apple butter undergoes a slow transformation as local apples simmer with cinnamon, cloves, and sugar until they reach a rich mahogany color and spreadable consistency.
Fall harvest festivals throughout Pennsylvania often feature live demonstrations of apple butter making, complete with massive stirring paddles and wood-fired kettles. The slow cooking process caramelizes the natural sugars in the apples, creating deep flavor notes that capture autumn’s essence in shelf-stable form.
Glass jars of this versatile spread make excellent souvenirs since they require no refrigeration until opened. Pennsylvanians spread it on toast, swirl it into yogurt, use it as a condiment for pork dishes, or even incorporate it into baking recipes as a natural sweetener with complex flavor.
7. Tomato Pie: The Pizza Cousin You Never Knew You Needed
Despite its name, Pennsylvania tomato pie bears no resemblance to a dessert. This bakery specialty features a thick, focaccia-like bread base topped with a layer of concentrated tomato sauce and, crucially, little to no cheese – setting it apart from traditional pizza.
Served at room temperature, these rectangular slices have been a Philadelphia-area staple for generations, particularly in Italian-American communities. The sauce develops a slightly sweet intensity as it bakes into the dough, creating a harmony of flavors that doesn’t need cheese to shine.
Bakeries throughout eastern Pennsylvania wrap these portable slices in wax paper or box them for travelers. Unlike regular pizza that suffers when cold, tomato pie actually improves as the flavors meld, making it an ideal souvenir that will taste as good at home as it did in Pennsylvania – if it survives the trip without being devoured.
8. Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie: The Soup That Isn’t Actually Pie
Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie challenges expectations by arriving at the table as a hearty stew rather than a dish with a flaky crust. Square, thick, homemade noodles are the defining feature of this comforting creation, swimming alongside chunks of chicken and vegetables in rich broth.
Country markets throughout central Pennsylvania sell dry pot pie noodles in bags, allowing travelers to recreate this regional comfort food at home. The substantial noodles, traditionally rolled and cut by hand, absorb the savory broth while maintaining their distinctive texture.
This dish reflects the Pennsylvania Dutch commitment to simple, filling meals that sustained farming families through generations. Unlike its more famous crusted cousin, this version travels beautifully in its dried form, making it a practical souvenir that delivers authentic Pennsylvania flavor once reconstituted in your home kitchen with fresh ingredients.
9. Red-Beet Eggs: The Vibrant Picnic Staple
The striking ruby color of red-beet eggs makes them an instant conversation starter at any Pennsylvania picnic table. These vivid creations begin as ordinary hard-boiled eggs before being transformed through a pickling process with beet juice, vinegar, and spices that infuse them with earthy sweetness and tangy brightness.
Farm stands and country markets throughout Pennsylvania sell jars of these colorful treats, which keep well for travel due to their preserved nature. The pickling liquid gradually penetrates the egg white, creating a beautiful color gradient from magenta exterior to white and yellow interior when sliced.
Pennsylvania Dutch families have been making these eggs for generations, traditionally serving them as side dishes at summer gatherings. The natural preservation process makes them an ideal souvenir that connects travelers to Pennsylvania’s agricultural heritage while providing a unique addition to charcuterie boards or salads once you return home.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
