New York State hides more than just bustling cities and beautiful landscapes – it’s home to some truly spine-chilling forgotten places. Abandoned asylums, haunted mansions, and eerie historical sites dot the countryside, waiting for brave road-trippers to discover their secrets. Pack your courage and gas up the car as we explore nine road trips that will take you through New York’s most unsettling and fascinating forgotten attractions.
1. Rolling Hills Asylum: Voices from the Past
Shadowy figures dart between doorways in this former poorhouse built in 1827. Once home to the mentally ill, orphans, and criminals, Rolling Hills Asylum now houses only their restless spirits.
Paranormal investigators flock here for the frequent EVP recordings and unexplained temperature drops. The most active spots include the basement morgue and third-floor solitary confinement cells where visitors report being touched by unseen hands.
Located in East Bethany, this massive brick structure sits isolated among rolling farmlands, making the drive there almost as unsettling as the destination itself.
2. Sleepy Hollow’s Forgotten Burial Grounds
Misty pathways wind through ancient tombstones where legends refuse to die. Beyond the famous cemetery immortalized by Washington Irving lies a network of lesser-known burial grounds dating back to the Revolutionary War.
Local folklore speaks of phantom soldiers still marching along the Hudson River banks, especially during autumn’s early twilight hours. The Old Dutch Church burying ground contains graves of prominent families whose descendants claim to see ancestral apparitions during certain moon phases.
The scenic drive through the Hudson Valley’s colorful foliage makes this autumn journey both beautiful and bone-chilling.
3. Fort Ontario’s Phantom Soldiers
Cannon fire echoes across time at this historic military outpost overlooking Lake Ontario. Built in 1755 and rebuilt multiple times after various conflicts, Fort Ontario has witnessed countless deaths from war, disease, and harsh winters.
Visitors report encountering uniformed soldiers who vanish when approached. The officer’s quarters seem particularly active, with tales of footsteps pacing above empty rooms and doors that lock themselves.
The drive along Lake Ontario’s shoreline offers breathtaking views, creating a stark contrast to the fort’s dark history of suffering that seems unwilling to fade into the past.
4. Burn Brae Mansion’s Lingering Residents
Victorian elegance masks generations of tragedy in this 1907 Glen Spey mansion. Original owner George Ross never enjoyed his dream home, dying shortly after construction finished – perhaps explaining why his spirit reportedly refuses to leave.
The lady in white seen gliding down the grand staircase is believed to be his grieving widow. Antique music boxes play without being wound, and guests report vivid dreams of attending early 1900s parties in rooms they’ve never entered.
The winding drive through the Catskill foothills to reach this isolated mansion builds anticipation for whatever supernatural encounters await.
5. Wing’s Castle: A Handcrafted House of Horrors
Stone gargoyles watch visitors approach this bizarre structure in Millbrook. Unlike traditional haunted locations, Wing’s Castle was built entirely by hand using salvaged materials from demolished historic buildings – bringing along whatever spiritual attachments they carried.
Created by artists Peter and Toni Ann Wing over four decades, the castle incorporates architectural elements from churches, banks, and even morgues. Guests staying in the bed and breakfast report objects moving overnight and feeling watched from hidden passages within the walls.
The scenic drive through horse country makes finding this architectural oddity all the more surprising.
6. Iron Island Museum’s Funeral Home Hauntings
Children’s laughter echoes through empty hallways in this former church and funeral home in Buffalo. Named for its location in the Iron Island neighborhood, this unassuming building processed thousands of deceased residents between 1883 and 1950.
During renovations, workers discovered forgotten cremated remains in the basement – perhaps explaining the intense paranormal activity. Ghost hunters have recorded clear EVPs asking visitors to “get out” and captured thermal images of figures standing in empty rooms.
The urban drive through Buffalo’s historic neighborhoods provides fascinating context for understanding why so many spirits might remain attached to this community hub.
7. Dunkirk Lighthouse’s Eternal Watchman
Waves crash against rocky shores as the lighthouse keeper’s footsteps continue his endless patrol. Standing since 1827, this Lake Erie lighthouse witnessed numerous shipwrecks and drownings, creating perfect conditions for paranormal activity.
Coast Guard personnel stationed here reported mysterious footsteps following them up the spiral staircase and the sensation of being watched from the tower. The keeper’s quarters exhibit classic haunting signs – cold spots, objects moving overnight, and the occasional apparition in period clothing.
The coastal drive offers spectacular lake views, contrasting sharply with the lighthouse’s reputation as one of New York’s most actively haunted locations.
8. Hyde Hall’s Aristocratic Apparitions
Aristocratic whispers float through candlelit corridors in this sprawling 1817 limestone mansion overlooking Otsego Lake. Built by wealthy English landowner George Clarke, Hyde Hall represents one of America’s finest examples of neoclassical architecture – and one of its most haunted estates.
Clarke’s domineering personality apparently survived death. Visitors report hearing his angry footsteps in the formal dining room and seeing his reflection in mirrors. His wife Ann’s ghost reportedly appears in the garden, still tending her beloved flowers.
The drive through Cooperstown’s picturesque farmland creates false security before encountering this imposing mansion’s supernatural residents.
9. Dannemora Prison’s Abandoned Death House
Rusted cell doors creak in forgotten prison wings where justice took its ultimate form. Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora contains an abandoned execution chamber nicknamed “The Death House” where 26 prisoners met their end between 1939 and 1963.
Though still an active prison, certain areas remain sealed off due to inexplicable events. Maintenance workers report tools disappearing and reappearing in locked rooms. Guards have heard cell doors slamming in vacant sections and seen shadowy figures darting between buildings.
The remote drive through Adirondack wilderness amplifies the isolation these condemned prisoners must have felt on their final journey.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
