When it comes to barbecue, North Carolina has a style all its own, where tangy vinegar-based sauce reigns supreme. This isn’t your typical sweet and sticky sauce – it’s a thin, peppery potion that cuts through fatty pork with the perfect acidic punch. I’ve traveled across the Tar Heel State, sampling the most authentic vinegar-doused barbecue joints where smoke-masters have been perfecting their craft for generations. Ready your taste buds as we explore these nine vinegar-soaked BBQ temples that’ll make your mouth water and your soul sing.
1. Skylight Inn BBQ – The Legendary Whole Hog Haven
Since 1947, the Skylight Inn has been cooking whole hogs over wood the old-fashioned way in Ayden, NC. The James Beard Foundation didn’t make a mistake when they crowned this place an “American Classic.”
What makes their barbecue special? The crackling-topped sandwiches come drenched in that signature peppery vinegar sauce that’ll make your taste buds dance. Their commitment to tradition is so serious that they chop the meat with massive cleavers on wooden blocks worn down from decades of use.
Though the building may look humble with its iconic capitol dome replica sitting atop, make no mistake – you’re standing on hallowed barbecue ground. The Jones family still runs the show, ensuring every bite honors their famous motto: “If it’s not cooked with wood, it’s not BBQ.”
2. Lexington Barbecue – Where Tradition Never Wavers
Fondly known as “The Monk” after its founder Harold O., this barbecue institution has been serving pork shoulders since 1962. If you’re wondering what Eastern North Carolina barbecue is all about, this is your textbook example.
Walking into Lexington Barbecue feels like stepping back in time. The pitmasters here smoke pork shoulders over hickory coals for hours until they develop that perfect pink smoke ring. Then comes the magic – they douse it with their signature vinegar-pepper sauce that’s got just enough tomato to give it that distinctive Lexington-style kick.
Locals know to order the “brown” – those outer bits with extra char and flavor. During the annual Lexington Barbecue Festival, this place becomes the epicenter of a town that proudly calls itself the “Barbecue Capital of the World.”
3. Wilber’s Barbecue – The Phoenix That Rose From The Ashes
How could I not cheer for Wilber’s comeback story? After closing in 2019, this Goldsboro legend was rescued by devoted fans and reopened in 2020, preserving a barbecue tradition that dates back to 1962.
Wilber’s epitomizes eastern-style whole hog cooking. The pitmasters here still use oak and hickory wood, tending fires through the night to create that perfect slow-cooked meat. Their vinegar sauce is the purest expression of Eastern Carolina style – no tomato, just vinegar, red pepper flakes, and secret spices that create liquid gold.
Though presidents and celebrities have dined here over the decades, Wilber’s treats everyone like family. The unassuming cinder-block building might not look fancy, but that first bite of their chopped pork sandwich will transport you to barbecue heaven faster than you can say “extra sauce, please.”
4. Buxton Hall Barbecue – Hip Joint, Old-School Methods
Though Asheville might be known for craft beer and hipster vibes, Buxton Hall proves this mountain city understands true Carolina barbecue. Pitmaster Elliott Moss blends contemporary restaurant aesthetics with deeply traditional whole-hog cooking methods.
Unlike many modern barbecue spots, Buxton Hall doesn’t cut corners. Their hogs cook for 18 hours over hardwood coals, with meat basking in dripping fat that falls onto vegetables cooking below. The eastern-style vinegar sauce here packs a wallop – bright, acidic, and peppery enough to make your lips tingle.
However, what truly separates Buxton from the pack is their commitment to using pasture-raised hogs from local farms. The converted roller skating rink space feels both trendy and timeless, much like their approach to barbecue. Their banana pudding pie might tempt you for dessert, but save room for another helping of that vinegar-kissed pork first.
5. B’s Barbecue – No Phone, No Website, Just Greatness
If you’re looking for fancy amenities, keep driving. B’s Barbecue in Greenville operates on its own terms – no phone, no website, and they’re only open until they sell out (which happens almost daily by early afternoon).
This cinderblock building with a smokehouse out back produces some of the most authentic eastern-style barbecue in existence. The vinegar sauce here is unapologetically acidic and peppery, designed to cut through the rich fattiness of their oak-smoked whole hog meat. Nothing gets wasted here – the crispy skin gets chopped right in with the tender meat.
Though the McLawhorn family has been running this joint since 1978, their techniques stretch back generations. The menu is beautifully simple: barbecue, chicken, ribs, and a few sides. Cash only, no reservations, and absolutely worth planning your entire day around. When they run out, they simply hang a “SOLD OUT” sign and call it a day.
6. Grady’s BBQ – Last Of The Wood-Only Pitmasters
Though nestled in the tiny community of Dudley, Grady’s BBQ has earned a reputation that extends far beyond rural Wayne County. Steve and Gerri Grady have been cooking whole hogs over oak and hickory since 1986, making them among the last authentic wood-only pitmasters in the state.
Their vinegar sauce exemplifies eastern Carolina purity – no tomato, just the perfect blend of apple cider vinegar, crushed red pepper, and secret spices. The sauce penetrates every fiber of their hand-chopped pork, creating harmony in each bite. What makes this place special is the Gradys themselves, who still work the pits well into their 80s.
Everything here is made from scratch daily – from the cornbread to the sweet potato pie. The modest building with screen doors might not look like much from the outside, but barbecue pilgrims know this is sacred ground where tradition remains untouched by modern shortcuts.
7. Parker’s Barbecue – Where Time Stands Deliciously Still
Since 1946, Parker’s Barbecue in Wilson has been serving eastern-style whole hog barbecue with such consistency that locals use it to mark time. “I’ve been eating here since before you were born” is a common refrain among the faithful customers.
Their vinegar sauce carries that signature eastern Carolina punch – clear, tangy, and peppery without a hint of tomato. What sets Parker’s apart is their military-precision operation. During busy times, white-uniformed servers move through the dining room with choreographed efficiency, delivering trays of chopped barbecue to hungry patrons.
Though they now cook with gas-fired cookers rather than wood, they’ve maintained the flavor profile that made them famous. The fried chicken rivals the barbecue for popularity, but true aficionados know to order the family-style feast with both. Their Brunswick stew and corn sticks complete a meal that hasn’t changed in over 70 years – and thank goodness for that.
8. Sam Jones BBQ – A Pitmaster Legacy Continues
When your grandfather is Pete Jones, founder of the legendary Skylight Inn, barbecue is literally in your blood. Sam Jones carried that legacy forward with his eponymous restaurant, blending time-honored techniques with just enough modern sensibility.
The whole hog barbecue here follows the eastern Carolina gospel – cooked over wood coals and dressed with that signature vinegar-pepper sauce that cuts through the rich pork like lightning. Unlike his grandfather’s place, Sam’s restaurant offers beer and a slightly expanded menu, but the barbecue remains gloriously traditional.
What makes this place special is watching tradition evolve without losing its soul. The open kitchen design lets you witness the chopping of meat on wooden blocks, just as it’s been done for generations. Sam himself is often present, ensuring that every tray maintains the standard his family name demands. The cornbread remains exactly as his grandfather made it – dense, flat, and perfect for sopping up extra sauce.
9. Stephenson’s Bar-B-Q – The Hidden Gem Of Johnston County
Though less famous than some of its counterparts, Stephenson’s has been quietly serving some of North Carolina’s finest eastern-style barbecue since 1958. Located in Willow Spring, this family-owned joint remains deliciously stuck in time.
Their vinegar sauce exemplifies eastern Carolina traditions – assertively tangy and peppery without a hint of sweetness or tomato. The pork shoulders cook low and slow over hardwood, developing that perfect smoke ring before being hand-chopped to order. Unlike many modernized spots, Stephenson’s still embraces the whole dining experience of a classic barbecue joint.
What truly separates them from the pack is their fried chicken and seafood offerings that rival their excellent barbecue. The hushpuppies here are legendary – crispy outside, fluffy inside, and perfect for soaking up extra sauce. Don’t expect fancy décor or craft beer – just plastic trays, sweet tea in styrofoam cups, and some of the most authentic barbecue experience left in the state.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
