Ohio’s kitchen tables hold culinary treasures that often leave visitors scratching their heads in confusion or delight. These regional comfort foods reflect generations of immigrant influence, blue-collar practicality, and creative Midwestern ingenuity. When you cross into the Buckeye State, prepare your taste buds for these beloved local specialties that might seem downright strange if you’re not from around here.
1. Cincinnati Chili
Out-of-state visitors often do a double-take when they first encounter this peculiar Ohioan dish. Unlike traditional Texas-style chili, Cincinnati’s version features finely ground beef in a thin, cinnamon and chocolate-laced sauce served over spaghetti and topped with mountains of shredded cheddar cheese.
Locals order by number – a ‘three-way’ means chili, spaghetti, and cheese, while a ‘five-way’ adds beans and diced onions. The spice profile, with hints of allspice and sometimes even cocoa, reflects the Greek and Macedonian immigrants who developed this regional specialty in the 1920s.
Skyline and Gold Star chains dominate the Cincinnati chili landscape, sparking fierce loyalty debates among residents. First-timers often struggle with the concept of chili as a topping rather than a standalone dish, but many become converts after that initial bewildering bite.
2. Goetta
German immigrants brought this hearty breakfast meat to Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky, creating a regional obsession that baffles outsiders. Pronounced ‘get-uh,’ this peculiar patty combines steel-cut oats with ground pork and beef, seasoned simply with bay leaves, rosemary, salt, and pepper, then formed into sliceable loaves.
Fried until crispy on the outside while remaining soft inside, goetta appears on breakfast plates alongside eggs or stuffed into sandwiches. The grain-meat combination emerged as a practical way for German settlers to stretch expensive meat with affordable oats, becoming a cherished tradition that persists today.
Visitors often mistake it for scrapple or meatloaf at first glance. Despite its unusual blend of meat and grain, goetta is a staple of breakfast menus and family tables throughout the region, firmly establishing its place in Ohio’s comfort food pantheon.
3. Buckeyes
Named after the nuts from Ohio’s state tree, these little confections cause confusion among first-time visitors who wonder why everyone’s so excited about peanut butter balls. The treat consists of sweetened peanut butter rolled into balls and dipped partially in chocolate, creating an uncanny resemblance to the eye-like buckeye nut.
During Ohio State football games, these treats become practically mandatory, with platters disappearing at tailgates and watch parties across the state. The distinctive look – chocolate coating with a circle of peanut butter peeking through – represents state pride in edible form.
Travelers often encounter buckeyes at bakeries, candy shops, and grandmothers’ kitchens throughout Ohio. What surprises visitors most isn’t the taste (who doesn’t love peanut butter and chocolate?) but rather the intense emotional attachment Ohioans have to these simple sweets and the proper ratio of peanut butter to chocolate.
4. Shredded Chicken Sandwiches
A staple at Ohio potlucks, church gatherings, and gas stations alike, these humble sandwiches perplex out-of-towners expecting traditional pulled chicken. Instead, they discover a uniquely creamy, finely shredded chicken mixture that’s more like a spread than barbecue.
The classic preparation involves slow-cooking chicken until it practically disintegrates, then mixing it with cream of chicken soup, crushed crackers (often Ritz or Club), and sometimes a touch of poultry seasoning. Served on soft hamburger buns, they’re especially popular in central and northern Ohio at graduation parties and community events.
What mystifies visitors most is the sandwich’s texture – not quite chicken salad, not quite pulled chicken, but something distinctly Ohioan in between. Look for them at small-town diners, convenience stores, and family celebrations, where they’re often kept warm in slow cookers and vanish quickly when served.
5. Barberton Chicken
Serbian immigrants created this distinctive fried chicken style in Barberton, Ohio during the Depression, and it remains virtually unknown outside the region. Unlike Southern fried chicken, Barberton’s version features a deep garnet-red coating achieved through paprika and lard-frying techniques passed down through generations.
The true surprise comes from the traditional sides – ‘hot rice’ (a spicy tomato rice pilaf) and vinegar-based coleslaw that cuts through the richness. Locals eat this chicken by hand, ignoring the bright orange stains it leaves on fingers and napkins as a badge of honor.
Belgrade Gardens, White House Chicken, and Hopocan Gardens still serve this specialty in the Akron-Barberton area. First-time visitors often don’t understand why Ohioans drive for miles specifically for this chicken until they taste the juicy interior beneath that crackling, distinctive crust and experience the perfect balance with the tangy sides.
6. Sauerkraut Balls
Originating in Akron’s German communities, these bite-sized morsels leave first-time visitors both intrigued and confused. Picture this: finely chopped sauerkraut mixed with cream cheese, sausage, and sometimes ham, rolled into balls, breaded, and deep-fried to golden perfection.
The combination creates an unexpected flavor bomb – tangy fermented cabbage mellowed by creamy cheese and savory meat. Popular as snacks and holiday appetizers throughout Northeast Ohio, they typically come served with spicy mustard for dipping, creating a perfect drink companion.
Travelers encounter these curious bites at German restaurants, taverns, and family gatherings across the state. The texture surprise – crispy exterior giving way to a soft, tangy center – often converts even the most skeptical visitors. During Oktoberfest celebrations, these little spheres of flavor become practically mandatory eating, with each family claiming their recipe reigns supreme.
7. Polish Boy Sandwich
Cleveland’s signature street food causes double-takes from visitors unprepared for its magnificent messiness. This indulgent creation starts with a kielbasa sausage stuffed into a bun, then gets completely buried under coleslaw, french fries, and barbecue sauce – creating an eat-with-fork situation that defies traditional sandwich logic.
Born in Cleveland’s Polish neighborhoods, this hand-held feast represents the city’s blue-collar roots and immigrant influences. The combination of hot sausage, cool creamy slaw, crispy potatoes, and tangy sauce creates a temperature and texture contrast that somehow works perfectly together.
Find authentic Polish Boys at stands like Seti’s Polish Boys, B&M BBQ, and Hot Sauce Williams. What baffles out-of-towners most isn’t just the unusual combination but watching locals somehow eat this towering creation without wearing most of it home – a skill developed through years of practice and civic pride in this beloved Cleveland specialty.
8. Johnny Marzetti
School cafeterias and church basements across Ohio regularly serve this hearty pasta casserole, leaving non-Ohioans wondering who Johnny is and why his pasta is so beloved. The classic version combines elbow macaroni, ground beef, tomato sauce, and melted cheese – often with mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers mixed in for good measure.
Created at Marzetti’s restaurant in Columbus during the 1920s, this economical dish became a staple in institutional cooking throughout the Midwest. The combination bakes into a comforting casserole that stretches ingredients to feed many hungry mouths at once.
What confuses visitors is both the unusual name and Ohioans’ nostalgic attachment to what appears to be simply a baked pasta dish. Found at potlucks, family gatherings, and in frozen form for fundraisers, Johnny Marzetti represents Ohio comfort food at its most practical and unpretentious – a dish that’s greater than the sum of its humble parts.
9. Fried Bologna Sandwich
Gas stations and diners across Ohio serve what locals consider the ultimate comfort sandwich but leaves visitors wondering why such a simple creation inspires so much devotion. The magic happens when thick-cut bologna (often a full 1/4-inch slice) hits a hot griddle until the edges curl up, creating a bowl-like shape that collects its own savory juices.
Served on white bread with yellow mustard and sometimes a slice of American cheese, this working-class hero represents Ohio’s unpretentious food culture. The best versions feature the bologna scored with knife cuts or with a hole in the middle to prevent bubbling – techniques debated with surprising passion by aficionados.
G&R Tavern in Waldo has achieved legendary status for their fried bologna sandwich, drawing road-trippers from across the Midwest. What startles visitors most is discovering that this sandwich they considered a desperate childhood lunch option is celebrated and elevated to cult status throughout the Buckeye State.
10. Pierogies
Cleveland’s Polish and Eastern European communities transformed these humble dumplings into an Ohio obsession that surprises visitors with both their ubiquity and the passion they inspire. These pockets of dough traditionally filled with potato, cheese, sauerkraut, or prunes get boiled then pan-fried in butter with onions until golden and crispy on the edges.
While pierogies exist in many regions, Ohio’s version often features distinctive local twists – like serving them alongside fried kielbasa or topped with creative garnishes at modern restaurants. Church basement pierogi sales remain legendary in Cleveland’s ethnic neighborhoods, with lines forming early for these handmade treasures.
What amazes outsiders most isn’t just the prevalence of pierogies but Ohioans’ fierce opinions about proper fillings, cooking methods, and toppings – debates that can divide families and neighborhoods for generations.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
