New York State surprises you with its coastal wonders. Beyond the famous city skylines, there are hidden beaches, quaint villages, and waterfront escapes that make you want to plan another trip before you’ve even left.
I’ve explored these destinations over the years, and each has its own personality, some bustling, some quiet, all worth the journey. Here are seven coastal gems that stand out for their beauty, history, and the memories you’ll take home.
1. Montauk (Long Island)
Staring out from Montauk’s rugged bluffs, I always feel a sense of calm that’s hard to find elsewhere on Long Island. The iconic lighthouse, which has been guiding ships since George Washington authorized its construction in 1796, stands as a proud reminder of the region’s maritime roots. Surfers flock to Ditch Plains, where the waves create a friendly, low-key surf culture.
Walk a few blocks into town and you’ll notice the difference from the glitzier Hamptons. Montauk feels authentic, with easygoing cafés, family-run seafood spots, and local art galleries that haven’t traded creativity for popularity. It’s a place where people say hello as you wander the boardwalk.
Montauk Point State Park draws hikers and birdwatchers, especially as the sun sets behind the lighthouse. The salty breeze, sound of gulls, and miles of protected coastline make this spot special. If you want the Atlantic without the crowds, Montauk rewards the journey with simple pleasures and unforgettable views.
2. Greenport (North Fork, Long Island)
It’s easy to see why Greenport still feels like a real seafaring village, even as new shops and galleries open along Front Street. The marina bustles with boats, not just for show but for catching the day’s dinner. Walk along the docks and you’ll pass weathered fishermen, local artists, and visitors all sharing space without fuss.
Greenport hasn’t lost its heart to tourism. Small businesses, bakeries, ice cream parlors, bookstores, feel personal. I love how the village combines old-world charm with fresh creativity, especially in the summer when the streets fill up with music and laughter.
You can hop on the historic carousel, stroll to Mitchell Park for waterfront sunsets, or just watch the ferries from nearby benches. This Antique Carousel was built in the 1920s and has been delighting generations of families, its hand-carved horses now a village treasure. Local beaches like Gull Pond offer quiet escapes when you need a swim. Greenport’s appeal is subtle and lasting; it invites you to slow down and stay a while.
3. Shelter Island
Some places feel like a secret, and Shelter Island is one of them. The only way in or out is by ferry, and that short trip across the water instantly sets the tone for a quieter, slower-paced escape. I find the peacefulness here, especially around the Mashomack Preserve, refreshing after a busy week.
Salt marshes and white-sand beaches wrap the shoreline, offering spots for quiet walks and birdwatching. Biking around the island takes you through tree-lined roads and hidden coves, with barely a car in sight. It’s easy to meet locals at the farmer’s market or chat up fellow visitors at a small beach café.
The Mashomack Preserve, which covers about a third of the island, has marked trails that wind through woodlands and wetlands. I love how Shelter Island balances recreation with conservation. If you want a New York coastal gem that leaves you feeling renewed, this is it.
4. Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor always strikes me as a place where history lingers in every corner. Once a major whaling port, its streets still echo the past with preserved brick buildings and old ship captains’ homes. In fact, Sag Harbor was once one of the most important whaling ports in the entire United States, sending ships around the globe during the 19th century.
Main Street offers an inviting mix of boutiques, museums, and cozy cafes. I often find myself wandering the side streets, discovering new bookstores or enjoying ice cream by the water. The parks and waterfront paths are perfect for a relaxed afternoon walk.
Boats bob in the harbor, and the community’s maritime roots remain a visible part of daily life. There’s a sense of pride in Sag Harbor’s blend of old and new. Visit in any season and you’ll find something happening, music, festivals, or just the easy calm of a small port town.
5. East Hampton
East Hampton wears its history with quiet confidence. Settled in the 1648, it’s one of New York’s oldest towns, and you can feel the weight of its stories as you stroll along Main Beach. Early mornings here are a favorite of mine, watching the first light hit the sand while locals walk dogs along the shore.
Beyond the beach, tree-lined streets lead to historic homes and museums, each with its own tale. The town keeps a careful balance between preserving its colonial past and welcoming new ideas. Parks and open spaces make East Hampton feel open and inviting.
I appreciate how little has changed over the years. You still find farmers’ markets, art fairs, and family-run shops. Whether you’re after a quiet morning or a weekend exploring New York’s coastal history, East Hampton offers a gentle, grounding escape.
6. Long Beach
When I want a classic beach day that’s easy to reach, Long Beach hits the spot. The train from Manhattan pulls you straight to the boardwalk, where you can feel the city fade as soon as you step onto the sand. On summer weekends, the boardwalk buzzes with people biking, skating, and grabbing snacks from local stands.
Long Beach’s sandy curve stretches for miles, making it a favorite for swimming or just relaxing under an umbrella. Lifeguards keep watch, and volleyball games often pop up along the shore. The atmosphere stays upbeat without being overwhelming.
Evenings bring out a different crowd, locals out for a stroll, families with ice cream, and the golden glow of the sun setting behind the city skyline. If you’re looking for a coastal spot that combines convenience with authentic charm, Long Beach delivers every time.
7. Port Jefferson (Long Island North Shore)
Port Jefferson has a way of making you feel at home, even if it’s your first visit. The village hugs the North Shore, with a lively Main Street that’s packed with bakeries, shops, and sidewalk cafés. Walk down to the harbor and you’re met with views of ferries and sailboats gliding across the water.
Local history plays a big role here. Old shipyards and maritime museums tell stories of the town’s past, while new restaurants and markets bring in fresh energy. Port Jefferson’s community spirit is easy to spot, especially during seasonal festivals and farmers’ markets.
Sunsets from the waterfront are unforgettable, orange and pink hues reflecting off the calm harbor. It’s a blend of quiet and activity, where you can feel the pulse of a working village alongside a sense of calm. Port Jefferson’s mix of old and new makes every visit memorable.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
