Ohio’s Amish Country once offered visitors a genuine glimpse into the simple, traditional lifestyle of Amish communities. Over the decades, tourism has transformed parts of this cultural region into something quite different. What started as authentic cultural exchange has, in some areas, morphed into commercial enterprises that cater more to tourists’ expectations than reality. Here’s a look at five spots in Ohio’s Amish Country that many locals and repeat visitors now consider overly commercialized tourist traps.
1. Amish-Themed Restaurant Buffets
Giant parking lots filled with tour buses signal the presence of these massive eateries claiming to serve “authentic Amish cooking.” The reality? Most operate on an industrial scale that no Amish household would recognize, serving food prepared by non-Amish cooks following standardized recipes.
Menus feature dishes advertised as “Amish recipes” but often bear little resemblance to what you’d find at an actual Amish table. The buffet format itself – encouraging excess and waste – contradicts the Amish values of modesty and frugality.
These establishments emerged in the 1970s when tourism developers realized visitors wanted to “taste” Amish culture. While they provide convenient dining options for large groups, they’ve created a distorted perception of Amish cuisine that emphasizes quantity over authenticity. True Amish cooking happens in homes and small family-run shops, not commercial kitchens serving hundreds daily.
2. Sugarcreek’s Swiss Village Facade
Marketing itself as the “Little Switzerland of Ohio,” Sugarcreek’s downtown features Swiss-style building facades that have nothing to do with the area’s actual Amish or even Swiss-Amish heritage. This architectural cosplay began in the 1950s as a tourism gimmick and has little connection to authentic local culture.
The annual Swiss Festival draws crowds seeking European charm in Amish Country, creating a bizarre cultural mashup that confuses visitors about the region’s actual heritage. Many tourists leave believing the Amish are Swiss, missing the distinct Germanic/Anabaptist origins of the community.
Historical markers attempt to explain the actual settlement patterns of the area, but these nuances get lost amid the Alpine-inspired gift shops. The real Amish community largely avoids this area during peak tourist season, finding little connection to this reimagined version of their homeland that prioritizes marketability over historical accuracy.
3. Berlin’s Main Street Shopping District
Once a quiet village where Amish and English businesses operated side by side, Berlin’s main drag now resembles a theme park version of Amish life. Souvenir shops outnumber authentic businesses, selling mass-produced trinkets often made far from Ohio’s rolling hills.
Weekends bring bumper-to-bumper traffic as tour buses disgorge visitors eager for an “Amish experience” that increasingly feels manufactured. Many shops employ few if any actual Amish workers, though they heavily market Amish-themed merchandise.
Locals recall when Berlin served community needs rather than tourist desires. The transformation began in the 1980s when tourism boomed, gradually pushing authentic Amish businesses to more remote locations. Real Amish craftspeople now typically sell their wares from home workshops miles from the commercial center.
4. Staged Amish Farm Tours
Farmsteads converted specifically for tourist visitation often present an idealized, frozen-in-time version of Amish life that bears little resemblance to contemporary Amish farming practices. Visitors pay to see demonstrations of traditional techniques that many working Amish farms have actually modernized or adapted.
These attractions typically employ non-Amish guides who sometimes perpetuate misconceptions about Amish beliefs and practices. The carefully curated experience omits the complex realities of modern Amish life, including how communities negotiate technology use and interact with the broader society.
The first such attractions appeared in the 1960s and have multiplied as tourism increased. While they do preserve certain historical farming methods, they rarely acknowledge how Amish life evolves. Authentic interaction with Amish farmers is possible through smaller, family-run farm stands and workshops where visitors can engage directly with community members rather than viewing them as living museum exhibits.
5. Millersburg’s Factory Outlet Shops
Sprawling shopping complexes have sprouted along highways near Millersburg, selling discount goods that have absolutely nothing to do with Amish culture. These outlets leverage their location in “Amish Country” to draw tourists, though they primarily sell the same mass-produced items found at any American mall.
The jarring contrast between simple Amish values and aggressive consumer culture becomes evident when horse-drawn buggies pass outlet mall parking lots filled with cars from multiple states. Many visitors spend more time shopping for bargains than learning about Amish life.
This commercial development began in the 1990s when developers realized they could capitalize on existing tourist traffic. While these outlets create jobs, they’ve transformed parts of Holmes County into generic shopping destinations indistinguishable from suburban America. The authentic Amish shopping experience – visiting small workshops where craftspeople make and sell their own goods – offers a meaningful alternative to these disconnected commercial zones.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
