When you visit Indiana’s Amish communities, you’re stepping into a world where traditions run deep and respect matters more than words.
Many travelers unknowingly cross invisible lines that upset the very people they came to admire.
Understanding these unspoken rules will help you explore thoughtfully while honoring a culture that values privacy, faith, and simplicity above all else.
1. Taking Pictures of Faces
The Amish believe that having their photograph taken violates a biblical commandment against creating graven images. They see it as encouraging pride and vanity, which goes against everything their faith teaches.
Snapping a picture of an Amish person’s face is the most common mistake tourists make. Even if you think you’re being sneaky or quick about it, they notice and feel disrespected.
If you want photos, focus on landscapes, barns, or empty buggies instead. Never aim your camera at people, and don’t expect permission if you ask; it will almost always be a polite no.
2. Honking at Buggies on the Road
Horses can be easily frightened by sudden loud noises like car horns or revving engines. A startled horse might bolt, putting the Amish family inside the buggy in serious danger.
When you’re driving behind a buggy, patience is everything. These slow-moving vehicles are part of daily life here, not tourist attractions blocking your way.
Wait for a long, clear stretch of road before passing safely. Keep your headlights on low beam at night, and give them plenty of room. Your few extra minutes could prevent a tragic accident.
3. Stopping at Unmarked Private Homes
Just because a home looks charming doesn’t mean it’s open to visitors. Many Amish families operate small businesses from their properties, but they always mark them clearly with signs.
Rolling up to a house without any indication of a shop or bakery is like someone parking in your driveway uninvited. It’s an invasion of their personal space and deeply uncomfortable for the family inside.
Only stop where you see a sign welcoming customers. Respect the boundary between public commerce and private family life, even if curiosity tempts you otherwise.
4. Knocking on Doors to Ask Questions
Treating the Amish like living museum exhibits is one of the rudest things travelers do. Approaching their homes to quiz them about their lifestyle makes them feel like objects on display rather than real people.
They didn’t choose to live differently so strangers could satisfy their curiosity at their doorstep. This kind of intrusion violates their privacy and makes them uncomfortable in their own homes.
If you genuinely want conversation, visit their shops or roadside stands where they’re open to friendly exchanges. Let interactions happen naturally, not forced through uninvited knocking.
5. Expecting Shops Open on Sunday
Sunday isn’t just another day for the Amish; it’s sacred time reserved for worship, rest, and family. Every business they own will be closed without exception.
Showing up expecting to shop on Sunday shows a lack of understanding about their faith. They take the Sabbath seriously, and no amount of tourist dollars will change that commitment.
Plan your visit for any other day of the week. Respecting their religious observance is a simple way to show you value their beliefs as much as you enjoy their handmade goods and fresh-baked treats.
6. Trying to Use Credit Cards Everywhere
Living simply means avoiding dependence on modern banking systems and electronic payment methods. Many Amish shops operate on cash or personal checks only.
Pulling out your credit card at a roadside stand or small cottage business will leave you empty-handed and embarrassed. They’re not being difficult; they’re staying true to their way of life.
Always bring cash when exploring Amish country. It’s not just practical; it honors their choice to keep technology at arm’s length and maintain independence from systems they see as unnecessary complications.
7. Staring and Pointing at Them
Yes, their clothing and lifestyle look different from what you’re used to. But staring, pointing, and whispering turns real people into a sideshow attraction.
The Amish notice when tourists gawk at them like zoo animals. It’s uncomfortable and disrespectful, making them feel like outsiders in their own community.
Treat them exactly as you’d treat anyone else you pass on the street. A friendly nod or wave is perfectly fine, but avoid making them the center of your attention. They’re just going about their daily lives.
8. Approaching Children Without Parents
Amish parents are protective of their children and committed to raising them according to strict religious values. Strangers approaching their kids crosses a serious boundary.
Don’t take photos of children, offer them candy or toys, or try to interact without a parent present. What might seem friendly to you feels threatening to families trying to shield their children from outside influences.
Give Amish kids space and privacy. If you encounter them at a family-run shop, a polite smile is enough. Their parents decide who interacts with them, not curious tourists passing through.
9. Wearing Revealing or Flashy Clothing
Modesty matters deeply in Amish culture, and showing up in tank tops, short shorts, or clothing covered in bold logos sends the wrong message. When you dress casually without thinking, you might accidentally make community members uncomfortable or feel disrespected in their own neighborhood. Remember, this isn’t a theme park but someone’s home.
Before heading out to explore, choose clothing that covers your shoulders and knees. Simple, plain outfits work best and help you blend in more naturally with the surroundings.
Packing a light cardigan or shawl can save the day if you realize your outfit might be too revealing. Showing cultural awareness through your clothing choices demonstrates genuine respect and makes your visit more meaningful for everyone involved.
10. Driving Too Fast Through Buggy Areas
Speed limits exist for good reasons, but in Amish country, going even the posted limit can sometimes be dangerous. Horse-drawn buggies travel much slower than cars, and sudden movements or close passes can startle the animals, creating serious safety risks for everyone on the road. Patience isn’t just polite here; it can literally save lives.
When you spot a buggy ahead, slow down well in advance and keep plenty of distance. Never rev your engine or try to squeeze past on narrow roads where there isn’t enough clearance.
Think of it as a chance to enjoy the scenery at a more relaxed pace. The Amish share these roads daily, and your careful driving shows you value their safety and way of life.
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
