Pennsylvania’s food scene is a melting pot of cultural influences, from German and Polish to Italian and American traditions. When I visit the Keystone State, my taste buds go on an adventure through hearty comfort foods, sweet treats, and savory specialties that tell stories of the region’s rich history. Whether you’re exploring bustling Philadelphia or the serene Amish countryside, these iconic Pennsylvania dishes deserve a special place on your culinary bucket list.
1. Philly Cheesesteak: The Sandwich That Started a Revolution
Nothing screams Pennsylvania louder than biting into an authentic Philly cheesesteak while standing on a Philadelphia street corner! The magical combination of thinly sliced ribeye, melted cheese (Cheez Whiz if you’re going traditional), and grilled onions stuffed into a crusty roll makes my heart sing every single time.
Though debates rage fiercely about who serves the best version – Pat’s or Geno’s – I’ve found the perfect cheesesteak is all about balance. The bread should be soft yet sturdy enough to hold the juicy meat without getting soggy. The beef must be seasoned just right and chopped fine.
Honestly, there’s something almost spiritual about the way locals order: “Whiz wit” (with cheese and onions) or “without” (hold the onions). This sandwich isn’t just food – it’s a Philly identity card in edible form!
2. Soft Pretzels: Twisted Perfection with Mustard
Whenever I’m wandering through Reading Terminal Market in Philly, the aroma of freshly baked soft pretzels inevitably pulls me in like a magnet. These aren’t your average mall pretzels, folks! Pennsylvania’s version features a distinctive figure-eight shape with a mahogany brown exterior that gives way to a pillowy, slightly chewy interior.
German immigrants brought this tradition to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, and thankfully, it stuck around. The perfect pretzel should have a slight crackle when you bite into it, followed by that wonderfully soft middle that melts in your mouth.
While some purists enjoy them plain, I’m firmly in the spicy brown mustard camp. There’s something magical about that tangy zip cutting through the pretzel’s subtle sweetness. Whether from a street vendor or famous spots like Miller’s Twist, these twisted treasures are Pennsylvania incarnate!
3. Shoofly Pie: Sweet Molasses Magic in Pastry Form
How can something so simple taste so heavenly? That’s the question I ask myself every time I fork into a slice of authentic shoofly pie from Amish country. This sticky, sweet confection consists of a molasses filling topped with crumbs that form three distinct layers as it bakes – gooey bottom, cake-like middle, and crumbly top.
Legend has it the pie got its quirky name because the sweet molasses would attract flies that needed to be “shooed” away. Whether that’s true or not, I can certainly attest that willpower flies out the window when this dessert appears!
Though variations exist (wet-bottom versus dry-bottom is a serious debate), the classic version balances the robust, almost smoky flavor of molasses with warm spices like cinnamon and nutmeg. Paired with a strong cup of coffee on a crisp Pennsylvania morning, shoofly pie becomes more than dessert – it’s a cultural experience worth savoring slowly.
4. Pierogi: Pockets of Polish-Pennsylvania Perfection
While wandering through Pittsburgh’s Strip District, I stumbled upon what locals consider their ultimate comfort food – pierogi! These half-moon dumplings might have Polish origins, but Pennsylvania has embraced them as their own, particularly in the western part of the state where coal miners of Eastern European descent settled generations ago.
The classic version features a pillowy dough wrapped around mashed potatoes and cheese, then pan-fried with butter and onions until golden and slightly crisp at the edges. That first bite, where the tender dough gives way to creamy, savory filling, is pure bliss!
Beyond the traditional potato and cheese, you’ll find creative variations stuffed with sauerkraut, sweet cheese, or even fruit for dessert versions. Pittsburgh even celebrates with a pierogi race at Pirates games, where mascots dressed as these dumplings compete.
5. Whoopie Pie: The Cookie-Cake Hybrid That Sparks Joy
My first encounter with a Pennsylvania whoopie pie happened at a small Amish roadside stand, and frankly, I wasn’t prepared for how something so unassuming could deliver such happiness! These sandwich-like treats consist of two cake-like cookies (traditionally chocolate) with a fluffy marshmallow cream filling that squishes out the sides when you take a bite.
Though Maine and several other states try to claim this dessert as their own, Pennsylvania’s Amish and Mennonite communities have been making these handheld delights for generations. Legend says they got their playful name from farmers who would shout “Whoopie!” upon finding these treats in their lunch pails.
Beyond the classic chocolate with vanilla filling, Pennsylvania bakers have created countless variations – pumpkin with cream cheese frosting in fall, red velvet for Valentine’s Day, and even savory versions at some innovative bakeries. Size matters too – from two-bite minis to plate-sized monsters that require both hands!
6. Chicken Pot Pie (Pennsylvania Dutch Style): Not What You’re Expecting
Forget everything you know about pot pie! Pennsylvania Dutch chicken pot pie isn’t the crusty pastry you might expect – instead, it’s a hearty, soul-warming soup filled with hand-rolled square noodles, chunks of chicken, and fresh vegetables. When winter winds howl across Pennsylvania farmland, this is what locals crave.
My first spoonful came from a small family restaurant near Lancaster, where the owner explained this dish dates back to early German settlers who needed filling, economical meals. The square noodles (rolled out and cut by hand) absorb the rich broth while still maintaining their texture, creating something that sits between soup and stew.
Though simple ingredients – chicken, potatoes, carrots, celery, and those signature noodles – the flavor is anything but basic. Some families add saffron for a distinctive yellow color and subtle flavor, while others keep it traditional with just parsley and black pepper. Either way, it’s Pennsylvania comfort in a bowl!
7. Tomato Pie: Philly’s Answer to Pizza
If you’ve never experienced Philadelphia tomato pie, you’re missing out on one of the city’s best-kept culinary secrets! Unlike traditional pizza, this rectangular delight is served at room temperature and features a thick, focaccia-like crust topped with a layer of tangy tomato sauce – no cheese in sight (or maybe just a light sprinkle of Romano).
While wandering South Philly, I discovered locals don’t consider this pizza at all, but rather a category unto itself. Bakeries rather than pizzerias typically make the best versions, selling it by the square in brown paper bags. The sauce is the star here – deeply concentrated tomato flavor, often with oregano, garlic, and olive oil.
Though Italian immigrants brought this tradition to Philadelphia decades ago, it remains primarily a regional specialty you won’t easily find elsewhere. What makes it special is its simplicity – proof that sometimes the most straightforward foods are the most satisfying. Perfect for lunch on the go or a midnight snack!
8. Roast Pork Sandwich: The Unsung Hero of Philly Sandwiches
Though cheesesteaks get all the glory, many Philadelphians consider the roast pork sandwich their city’s true sandwich masterpiece! I still remember my first bite at DiNic’s in Reading Terminal Market – tender, slow-roasted pork sliced thin, topped with sharp provolone cheese and garlicky sautéed broccoli rabe, all tucked into a crusty Italian roll that somehow contained the juicy goodness.
What makes this sandwich special is the perfect balance of flavors and textures. The mild, succulent pork contrasts beautifully with the slightly bitter greens and the sharp, aged provolone. Meanwhile, the natural jus from the pork soaks slightly into the roll without making it fall apart.
Despite being overshadowed by its more famous cheesesteak cousin, this sandwich has deep roots in Philadelphia’s Italian-American community. The best versions come from family recipes passed down through generations, each claiming their special spice blend or roasting technique makes theirs supreme!
9. Butterscotch Krimpets: The Lunchbox Treat That Defined Childhoods
Though not technically a dish, no list of Pennsylvania foods would be complete without mentioning Tastykake’s Butterscotch Krimpets! These spongy, rectangular cakes topped with butterscotch icing have been a staple in Pennsylvania lunchboxes since 1914, and their nostalgic pull is stronger than gravity.
Growing up near Philly, these treats were currency on the playground – worth at least two Oreos in trade value! The magic lies in their perfect texture: not quite as dense as pound cake, not as light as angel food, with that sweet, buttery frosting that sticks slightly to the roof of your mouth in the most satisfying way.
While the Tastykake company now produces countless varieties of snack cakes, the humble Butterscotch
Krimpet remains their signature item. Ask any Pennsylvania expatriate what food they miss most, and these often top the list. Some fancy bakeries have even created gourmet homages to these beloved treats, but nothing beats the original in its cellophane wrapper!
Dear Reader: This page may contain affiliate links which may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Our independent journalism is not influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative unless it is clearly marked as sponsored content. As travel products change, please be sure to reconfirm all details and stay up to date with current events to ensure a safe and successful trip.
